Braves Greats Still Waiting on Cooperstown

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: September 3rd, 2026 by Matthew Brown

The Braves have such a long history that goes back multiple cities. I have only known them in Atlanta, but I have seen my fair share of Braves games thanks to Ted Turner trying to push them to be America's team. I'll relent that they made me a believer in the organization, that's for sure. Let's go over 20 Braves who have yet to get the voters' belief that they should be in the Hall of Fame.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

How We Made This List

We wanted to take into account multiple things that make a player great. There's always peak and longevity to go along with the accolades.

For this one, we also wanted to consider the impact on the Braves franchise that these players had, because some of them needed to really make a mark in order for their legacy to carry through multiple cities.

20. Johnny Logan: The Shortstop Who Anchored Milwaukee

Johnny Logan got to see the transition from Boston to Milwaukee in the 1950s as he took over the shortstop position and excelled for 11 years. He was a true everyday player and earned four All-Star selections. Even though he was less known with the bat, he still led the league in doubles in 1955 and built up an OPS+ over 100 in three seasons.

Johnny Logan — CareerTotal
G1503
AB5244
H1407
HR93
RBI547
SB19
AVG.268
OBP.330
SLG.378
OPS.708
All-Star selections4
World Series titles1

19. Mark Lemke: The Little Lemmer That Could

Let's move one position over and talk about the second baseman for those powerhouse Braves teams in the 1990s. Mark Lemke may be one of those forgotten names from those teams, but he was still able to contribute in a big way. His scrappy play gave him some big moments, especially in 1995 when he helped Atlanta win a World Series.

Mark Lemke — CareerTotal
G1069
AB3230
H795
HR32
RBI270
SB11
AVG.246
OBP.317
SLG.324
OPS.641
World Series titles1

18. Glenn Hubbard: When Second Base Had Snake Charm

We stay at the position and talk about Lemke's predecessor, Glenn Hubbard, who manned the position for 10 years. Hubbard was able to earn All-Star recognition in 1983, as he just played steady second base.

Looking at advanced fielding stats, he actually totaled a range factor per nine innings that is the greatest for any second baseman's career all-time. It baffles me how he was never a Gold Glove winner.

Glenn Hubbard — CareerTotal
G1354
AB4441
H1084
HR70
RBI448
SB35
AVG.244
OBP.328
SLG.349
OPS.677
All-Star selections1

17. Gene Garber: The Reliever Who Ended Pete's Streak

No hitter will beat Joe DiMaggio's 56-game hitting streak, and Gene Garber made sure of that when he stopped Pete Rose's hit streak in 1978 at 44 games.

Garber was just starting out in Atlanta that season, as that was his first of a decade-long relationship with the city. Garber became a reliable force out of the bullpen, totaling over 100 innings in three separate seasons with the Braves.

Gene Garber — CareerTotal
W96
L113
ERA3.34
G931
IP1510.0
SO940
WHIP1.26
SV218

16. Chris Chambliss: The Silent Leader of the Transition Years

Most people remember his time in the Bronx, but Chris Chambliss actually played as many years with the Braves as he did with the Yankees. The first baseman actually showed more pop in Atlanta, as he hit 80 home runs in his seven seasons with the team.

That totaled a 110 OPS+, which suggests that he was well above average as a hitter. He was also adept with the glove, as he led all first basemen in putouts, assists, and double plays in separate seasons.

Chris Chambliss — CareerTotal
G2175
AB7571
H2109
HR185
RBI972
SB40
AVG.279
OBP.334
SLG.415
OPS.749
All-Star selections1
Gold Gloves1
World Series titles2
Rookie of the Year1

15. Jeff Blauser: The Shortstop Who Sparked the Dynasty

The middle infield can be so important for finding offensive production, especially when you have a dynamic offense like the Braves did in the 1990s. Jeff Blauser was the perfect shortstop for them as he provided steady defense while showing off some pop at the plate. A 125 OPS+ in 1993 helped him earn his first of two All-Star selections.

Jeff Blauser — CareerTotal
G1407
AB4522
H1187
HR122
RBI513
SB65
AVG.262
OBP.354
SLG.406
OPS.760
All-Star selections2
Silver Sluggers1

14. Rafael Furcal: The Rookie Who Played Like a Vet

Ever since he burst onto the scene winning the Rookie of the Year award in 2000, Rafael Furcal has been a fan favorite in Atlanta. He would go on to earn one All-Star selection as a Brave, taking over the shortstop position for 6 seasons.

He became one of the premier leadoff hitters in the league, as his 2005 season saw him steal 46 bases with an impressive 11 triples and 31 doubles. Furcal's scrappiness as a shorter player brought out excitement from the crowd every night.

Rafael Furcal — CareerTotal
G1614
AB6477
H1817
HR113
RBI587
SB314
AVG.281
OBP.346
SLG.402
OPS.748
All-Star selections3
World Series titles1
Rookie of the Year1

13. Felipe Alou: Before He Built the Dynasty

Yeah, many remember him as a Giant mostly. That is thanks to his six years as a player and even more as a manager. But Alou actually saw the migration of the Braves from Milwaukee to Atlanta.

He earned All-Star recognition in the inaugural Atlanta season, as he led all of baseball with 218 hits on a .327 batting average and finished fifth in MVP voting.

Felipe Alou — CareerTotal
G2082
AB7339
H2101
HR206
RBI852
SB107
AVG.286
OBP.328
SLG.433
OPS.761
All-Star selections3

12. Steve Avery: The Young Gun Who Burned Too Bright

If there were a baseball definition for an unsung hero, I would have to say Steve Avery is up there as an example for me. It is so easy to get lost in the elite rotations that include John Smoltz, Tom Glavine, and Greg Maddux.

Steve Avery was right there with them. In fact, he was named the NLCS MVP in 1991 when he was just 21 years old. Then he earned an All-Star selection in 1993, when he went 18-6 with a 2.94 ERA and looked just as good as those aces on some nights.

Steve Avery — CareerTotal
W96
L83
ERA4.19
G297
IP1554.2
SO980
WHIP1.35
SV0
All-Star selections1
World Series titles1

11. Bob Horner: The Rookie Phenom Who Vanished Too Soon

Bob Horner was a light that shone bright from the very start. The Braves knew that he had a ton of talent as they plucked him from Arizona State and sent him straight to the MLB roster.

All he did was win Rookie of the Year in 1978 and give them productive seasons in a handful of years afterward. He earned an All-Star selection in 1982, but his career was eventually cut short by injuries, and we only got to witness a 10-year career.

Bob Horner — CareerTotal
G1020
AB3777
H1047
HR218
RBI685
SB14
AVG.277
OBP.340
SLG.499
OPS.839
All-Star selections1
Rookie of the Year1

10. Joe Niekro: Phil's Brother and the Knuckleball Legacy

Most people are well aware of the Hall of Famer Phil Niekro, who played many seasons in a Braves uniform. Not as many remember that his brother, Joe, also got to don a Braves uniform.

Joe Niekro danced his knuckleball in Atlanta through two seasons, where he was mostly coming out of the bullpen. Though those years can't compare to what his brother was able to do for the franchise, Joe was still able to carve out a really good career that saw 221 wins over 22 years in the MLB.

Joe Niekro — CareerTotal
W221
L204
ERA3.59
G702
IP3584.0
SO1747
WHIP1.32
SV16
All-Star selections1
World Series titles1

9. Ron Gant: The 30-30 Man on a Harley

Ron Gant is just one of those cool players that fans of the era will talk about glowingly. It doesn't matter that he wasn't one of the superstars in the league.

He just played the game with a tenacity and skill that saw him hit more than 30 home runs in three separate seasons while also stealing 30 bases in three separate seasons. That was the amount of value that he was able to bring to the Braves on a daily basis.

Ron Gant — CareerTotal
G1832
AB6449
H1651
HR321
RBI1008
SB243
AVG.256
OBP.336
SLG.468
OPS.804
All-Star selections2
Silver Sluggers1

8. Javy Lopez: The Catching Star of TBS America

Atlanta has seen some good catchers over the years, and I would like to say that it kind of started with this man. Javy Lopez was the kind of catcher that you feared at the plate. His pitchers were so good that they really didn't need as much of a defensive catcher behind the plate.

So Lopez got to focus on how he could contribute with the bat. He hit 43 home runs in 2003 while earning his third All-Star selection to cap off his 12 years in Atlanta.

Javy Lopez — CareerTotal
G1503
AB5319
H1527
HR260
RBI864
SB8
AVG.287
OBP.337
SLG.491
OPS.828
All-Star selections3
Silver Sluggers1
World Series titles1

7. Joe Adcock: The Man Who Beat the Perfect Game

We turn our focus to Milwaukee, as Joe Adcock remains a forgotten slugger from those days. The Braves first baseman slugged his way to 239 home runs over 10 seasons with the franchise. That built up to a 131 OPS+, which is highly impressive and great offensive support for teammates who are in the Hall of Fame.

He may not be known like Aaron or Mathews, but Adcock made an impression that remains with the organization today.

Joe Adcock — CareerTotal
G1959
AB6606
H1832
HR336
RBI1122
SB20
AVG.277
OBP.337
SLG.485
OPS.822
All-Star selections1
World Series titles1

6. Terry Pendleton: The MVP Nobody Saw Coming

When you talk about having a short burst of success, you talk about Terry Pendleton. He came over from St. Louis in 1991 after having some pretty mediocre production as the Cardinals' third baseman.

Then, he just exploded in Atlanta, won the batting title, and was voted MVP. He almost won back-to-back MVP awards, as he finished runner-up in 1992, when he was selected as an All-Star and Gold Glove Award winner.

Terry Pendleton — CareerTotal
G1893
AB7032
H1897
HR140
RBI946
SB127
AVG.270
OBP.316
SLG.391
OPS.707
MVP1
All-Star selections1
Gold Gloves3
TOP FIVE SNAPSHOT #1 Dale Murphy #2 Andruw Jones #3 David Justice #4 Rico Carty #5 Brian McCann

5. Brian McCann: The Hometown Hero Behind the Plate

RANK #5 Brian McCann
The Hometown Hero Behind the Plate

This is being written in 2025, so I think there's still plenty of time for Brian McCann to be considered a Hall of Famer. He made a strong case over his 15-year career, earning seven All-Star selections, all in Atlanta. McCann was one of the premier hitters at the position during his time, as he won five Silver Sluggers, proving that he was thought of as one of the most feared catchers with the bat.

Brian McCann — CareerTotal
G1755
AB6067
H1590
HR282
RBI1018
SB25
AVG.262
OBP.337
SLG.452
OPS.789
All-Star selections7
Silver Sluggers6
World Series titles1

4. Rico Carty: El Beeg Boy's Caribbean Thunder

RANK #4 Rico Carty
El Beeg Boy’s Caribbean Thunder

Rico Carty was able to produce at a very high level when he was healthy. Unfortunately, he wasn't as healthy as we wanted him to be. He won the batting title in 1970 with All-Star recognition along the way.

Given how early it was in incorporating Latin players into baseball, you can consider Carty as one of the pioneers who inspired some of the great Dominican players that you see today.

Rico Carty — CareerTotal
G1651
AB5606
H1677
HR204
RBI890
SB21
AVG.299
OBP.369
SLG.464
OPS.833
All-Star selections1

3. David Justice: The World Series Hero Who Got Away

RANK #3 David Justice
The World Series Hero Who Got Away

There is no doubt that David Justice had Hall of Fame talent. He earned two All-Star selections in his eight years in Atlanta, where he built up a 132 OPS+. That is a Hall of Fame level. He won Rookie of the Year in 1990, when he hit .282 with 28 home runs.

His time in Atlanta culminated in a Game 6 home run in the 1995 World Series that Braves fans still remember to this day.

David Justice — CareerTotal
G1610
AB5625
H1571
HR305
RBI1017
SB53
AVG.279
OBP.378
SLG.500
OPS.878
All-Star selections3
Silver Sluggers2
World Series titles2
Rookie of the Year1

2. Andruw Jones: The Center Field Wizard Who Changed Defense Forever (HOF)

RANK #2 Andruw Jones
The Center Field Wizard Who Changed Defense Forever

Even more than McCann, I really hope that this player is in the Hall of Fame by the time you are reading this. Andruw Jones was the gold standard in center field during his era.

10 Gold Gloves puts him in a tier that is above many other outfielders who are in the Hall of Fame. He was great with the bat as well, hitting an MLB-leading 51 home runs in 2005 that added to his total of 434 in his career. Again, this list is originally being made in 2025. So I hope his long wait is over.

Andruw Jones — CareerTotal
G2196
AB7599
H1933
HR434
RBI1289
SB152
AVG.254
OBP.337
SLG.486
OPS.823
All-Star selections5
Gold Gloves10
Silver Sluggers1

1. Dale Murphy: The Back-to-Back MVP and Braves Standard-Bearer

RANK #1 Dale Murphy
The Back-to-Back MVP and Braves Standard-Bearer

Dale Murphy is another one whom I hope Cooperstown invites in the near future. This would have to be through the Veterans Committee, but I think Murphy has a legitimate case. Back-to-back MVPs in 1982 and 1983 were just a shining example of consistency.

He hit exactly 36 home runs in three straight seasons. He earned five straight Gold Glove awards and four straight Silver Sluggers. That is as good a prime as you can get in any baseball career in the 1980s. For a good while, Dale Murphy was not just the face of the Braves, but he was one of the faces of baseball.

Dale Murphy — CareerTotal
G2180
AB7960
H2111
HR398
RBI1266
SB161
AVG.265
OBP.346
SLG.469
OPS.815
MVP2
All-Star selections7
Gold Gloves5
Silver Sluggers4

Final Thoughts

As this list was made initially in 2025, there are names here that have a legitimate shot at being put into the Hall of Fame in the near future. I hope by the time you are reading this, there are even more names that are representing the Braves franchise in Cooperstown.

Keep reading