24 Best Second Basemen in Baseball History: Who’d We Miss?

Jake Cain

Jake Cain

Last Updated:

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: September 3rd, 2024 by Jake Cain

Our list of the best second basemen is full of guys who exhibited extraordinary skills, both defensively and offensively.

These players have not only redefined their position but have also etched their names in the annals of Major League Baseball (MLB) history.

Their impact transcends routine double plays and dives, marking them as pivotal to their teams’ successes and the evolution of the game.

Roberto Alomar, for instance, stands out with a record that includes an unmatched total of ten Gold Glove Awards at second base, solidifying his status as one of the finest fielders ever to play the position. His contemporaries and predecessors also brought distinct flair and prowess to the diamond, contributing to the sport’s rich narrative through their exemplary careers and numerous accolades.

While individual statistics like hits and batting averages capture the offensive prowess of second basemen, career honors such as all-star appearances and MVP awards reflect their broader contributions to the game. These metrics, alongside stolen base counts and other specialized achievements, offer a robust picture of their legacies and the indelible mark they’ve left on the sport of baseball.

Some of the players in this list like Robinson, Biggio, and others played a fair amount of their careers at positions other than second base. However, we tried to limit this list to people who played at least 300 games at second.

24. Nellie Fox

Considered a foremost figure at second base, Jacob Nelson “Nellie” Fox brought exceptional skill to the diamond. A consistent contact hitter, he became known for his defensive prowess and ability to difficultly strike out. His play with the Chicago White Sox in the 1950s solidified his legacy in Major League Baseball.

Nellie Fox’s compact stature belied his significant influence on the field. Choking up on a distinctive bottle bat, he exhibited a batting approach that prioritized control over power. Beyond his batting, Fox was a veteran of the 1959 “Go-Go” White Sox, a cornerstone of the team’s identity and success.

The career of Nellie Fox is encapsulated not just by statistics but by honors that highlight his impact on the game. His consistent performance earned him multiple Gold Glove Awards and All-Star selections, reflecting his status among peers. His talent and significance are further endorsed by his inclusion in the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

Career Statistics & Awards
Hits2,663
Batting Average.288
Gold Gloves3
All-Star Appearances15
Stolen Bases76
Hall of Fame Induction Year1997

23. Dustin Pedroia

Dustin Pedroia, former second baseman for the Boston Red Sox, made an indelible mark on the sport during his storied career from 2006 to 2019. His excellence at second base was recognized with four Gold Glove Awards, evidence of his defensive prowess. Pedroia was known for his exceptional skill, contributing to the Red Sox as a reliable catalyst at the top of the lineup.

Pedroia’s contribution to baseball was not just defensive. With a career batting average of .299 and a notable 2008 season, where he earned the American League MVP, he demonstrated a potent combination of contact hitting and on-base proficiency. This season also saw him claim a Silver Slugger Award, further emphasizing his offensive capabilities.

His competitive spirit and consistency earned him four All-Star appearances, with his rookie season in 2007 garnering him the AL Rookie of the Year Award. Despite challenges with injuries, Pedroia’s career statistics hold testament to his impact on the field. He accrued over 1,800 hits and displayed strategic speed, amassing over 100 stolen bases.

CategoryStatistics
Hits1,805
Batting Average.299
Gold Gloves4
All-Star Appearances4
MVP Awards1 (2008)
Silver Sluggers1 (2008)
Stolen Bases138

Pedroia’s legacy is carried not only through his achievements but also his leadership and tenacity on the baseball field. His career, entirely with the Boston Red Sox, earned him a respected place among its greats.

22. Bobby Doerr

Bobby Doerr stands out as one of the premier second basemen in baseball history, having spent his entire 14-year career with the Boston Red Sox. His consistency and skill at second base were matched by a powerful offensive presence. Inducted into Baseball’s Hall of Fame in 1986, his excellence on the field is remembered by fans and historians alike.

A nine-time All-Star, Doerr was known for his smooth fielding and clutch hitting, retiring with a .288 batting average. His contribution to the Red Sox includes over 100 RBIs in six different seasons. As a testament to his deft abilities, he led American League second basemen in double plays five times.

Below is a table highlighting Doerr’s notable career statistics and accolades:

StatisticValue
Hits2042
Batting Average.288
Home Runs223
RBIs1247
All-Star Appearances9
Fielding Percentage.980

Despite missing three seasons to military service during World War II, his offensive numbers remained impressive. Doerr’s legacy is that of a complete player who excelled both defensively and at the plate, making him a cherished figure in Red Sox lore.

21. Red Schoendienst

Albert Fred “Red” Schoendienst boasts a noteworthy career in Major League Baseball, primarily with the St. Louis Cardinals. Known for his dependability and skill at second base, he played for the Cardinals, New York Giants, and Milwaukee Braves throughout 19 seasons. Schoendienst’s playing style was marked by consistency and a keen baseball intellect, which later translated into a successful coaching and managing career.

Beyond his playing days, Red was widely respected as a coach and manager, contributing to the success of the Cardinals’ franchise. His influence extends beyond his stats, as he played a vital part in the growth of baseball during the mid-20th century. His coaching career began in earnest in 1964, a pivotal year for the Cardinals.

Red Schoendienst’s career statistics and achievements highlight his impact on the game:

Career StatisticAchievement
Hits2,449
Batting Average.289
All-Star Appearances10
Gold Gloves0
MVPs0
Stolen Bases89

Schoendienst’s lack of MVP awards or Gold Gloves does not diminish his legacy as a notable player in baseball history. He was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1989, an honor that underscores his contribution to the sport.

20. Bid McPhee

Bid McPhee, known as baseball’s preeminent second baseman of the 19th century, cemented a lasting legacy during his 18-season tenure with the Cincinnati Reds. His exceptional fielding skills set the standard for second basemen in the era before fielders used gloves. Notably, McPhee was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2000, underscoring his historical significance to the sport.

McPhee’s career, spanning from 1882 to 1899, was marked by his consistent performance and resilience, demonstrated by his participation in over 2,000 games. He led the league in assists a total of ten times and in putouts nine times, showcasing his defensive prowess at second base. Although McPhee was more renowned for his defense, he contributed offensively as well, amassing over 2,500 hits and a lifetime batting average over .270.

Here is a brief overview of McPhee’s career statistics and accolades:

CategoryStatistic
Hits2,250
Batting Average.271
Home Runs53
Stolen Bases568
Games Played2,138
Fielding Percentage.944
Hall of Fame Induction2000

His legacy is less about the raw numbers and more about the transformation of the game he helped shape, reflecting in the strategies employed once gloves were adopted. McPhee’s career retains an indelible mark on baseball’s rich history, especially for aficionados who appreciate the evolution of defensive play in the sport.

19. Jeff Kent

Jeff Kent is recognized as one of baseball’s top second basemen, having carved out a significant career in the Major Leagues. With an impressive tenure from 1992 to 2008, Kent’s offensive contributions were substantial, especially noted by his power hitting—a rarity at the second base position. He notably achieved the National League Most Valuable Player award in 2000 as a member of the San Francisco Giants, underscoring his impact on the game.

Kent’s career statistics reflect his prowess at the plate and his significant contributions to every team he played for, including the Toronto Blue Jays, New York Mets, Cleveland Indians, San Francisco Giants, Houston Astros, and Los Angeles Dodgers. His consistent hitting and ability to drive in runs established him as a formidable middle-of-the-order hitter. Beyond his MVP year, Kent made five All-Star appearances and won four Silver Slugger awards, reflecting his status as one of the best-hitting second basemen of his era.

His career achievements can be quantified by his notable statistics in key areas. Consider the following summary of Jeff Kent’s career highlights:

StatValue
Hits2,461
Batting Average.290
Home Runs377
RBIs1,518
All-Star Appearances5
MVP Awards1 (2000)
Silver Sluggers4
Gold Gloves0
Stolen Bases94

Kent’s legacy in Major League Baseball is hallmarked by his significant offensive contributions and his status as an elite second baseman in the sport’s history.

18. José Altuve

José Altuve is a Venezuelan professional baseball player renowned for his tenure with the Houston Astros. A seasoned second baseman, his stature belies his impressive ability to generate powerful hits and maintain a high batting average. Altuve is also known for his speed on the bases, resulting in a considerable number of stolen bases throughout his career.

He has received several awards, reflecting his status as one of the game’s elite players. His accolades include multiple All-Star selections, several Silver Slugger Awards, and a notable Most Valuable Player (MVP) Award. Defensively, he has been recognized with a Gold Glove, complementing his all-around contribution to the game.

Here is a summary of José Altuve’s key career statistics and awards:

Statistic/AwardTotal
Hits1,777
Batting Average.308
Stolen Bases254
Gold Gloves1
All-Star Appearances7
Silver Sluggers5
MVP Awards1

Altuve has played an integral role in the Astros’ success, achieving a World Series victory and establishing himself as a formidable presence at second base. His consistency and skill have cemented his status among the best at his position in modern baseball history.

17. Joe Gordon

Joe Gordon was an influential figure in the annals of Major League Baseball, recognized for his defensive prowess and offensive impact as a second baseman. Known as “Flash” for his quick reflexes, Gordon played primarily for the New York Yankees and the Cleveland Indians during the 1930s and 1940s. He was a pivotal part of the Yankees’ championship teams and later helped the Indians secure a World Series title.

His career was distinguished by both his powerful hitting and his defensive abilities at second base. Gordon’s accolades include nine All-Star appearances, highlighting his reputation among contemporaries as an elite player at his position. Despite the era’s lower batting averages, Gordon maintained a respectable batting average while providing significant power, which was less common for middle infielders of his time.

Here is a brief overview of Joe Gordon’s career highlights and statistics:

Career Statistics
Hits1,530
Batting Average.268
Home Runs253
RBI975
Stolen Bases89
Gold Gloves
All-Star Appearances9
MVP Awards1

Gordon’s absence of Gold Gloves is not indicative of his defensive skills, as the award was not established until after his career ended. His legacy, however, continues to be remembered by baseball historians and fans alike for his all-around talent and contribution to the sport.

16. Bobby Grich

Considered one of the premier second basemen during his career, Bobby Grich started his Major League journey in 1970 with the Baltimore Orioles. Grich was renowned for his defensive prowess, capturing four Gold Glove Awards, and he later transitioned to the California Angels in 1977. A consistent hitter, his offensive skills earned him a Silver Slugger Award and saw him lead the American League in home runs in 1981.

In his 17-year career, Grich was selected as an All-Star six times, indicative of his high level of play and respect from players and fans alike. His smooth fielding and potent batting were pivotal in the multiple post-season appearances of his teams. Even with the absence of an MVP award, Grich’s performance and skillset on the field have solidified his legacy in baseball history.

Here is a brief summary of Bobby Grich’s career statistics and accolades:

CategoryTotal
Hits1,833
Batting Average.266
Gold Gloves4
All-Star Appearances6
Silver Slugger Awards1
Home Runs224
Stolen Bases104

15. Billy Herman

Billy Herman was esteemed for his defensive prowess and consistent batting as a second baseman in Major League Baseball (MLB). His career spanned the 1930s and 1940s, during which he set numerous National League (NL) defensive records for second basemen. Inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1975, Herman’s legacy in baseball history is notable for his technical skill and game intelligence.

Throughout his MLB tenure, Herman remained a formidable presence at the plate and on the field. His skillset contributed immensely to the teams he played for, making him a valuable team player and often a game-changing factor in tight situations. Offensively, his career hits and batting average positioned him among the elite second basemen of his era.

Career Achievements:

StatisticTotal
Hits2,345
Batting Average.304
Gold GlovesN/A (award not established during his career)
All-Star Appearances10
MVPs0 (finished top-five in MVP voting twice)
Stolen Bases67

Herman’s absence of MVP titles does not diminish the impact he had on the game, as his All-Star selections underscore his consistent performance and respect amongst his peers and baseball journalists of the time. His contributions to the sport extend beyond his playing days, with post-retirement roles in coaching and scouting.

14. Chase Utley

Chase Utley, a former professional baseball second baseman, had a distinguished career in Major League Baseball (MLB), predominantly with the Philadelphia Phillies. He was a central figure in the Phillies’ 2008 World Series championship, revered for his consistent performance and leadership. Utley’s style of play earned him the affectionate nicknames “the Man” and “Silver Fox.”

His career was marked by a mix of power and defensive prowess. Utley’s ability to hit for both average and power while playing stellar defense positioned him as one of the best second basemen of his generation. His quick double-play turns and reliable glove work were as integral to his game as his offensive output.

During his 16-season tenure in the MLB, Utley amassed notable career statistics and awards. He was selected for six All-Star Games, demonstrating his consistent excellence and league-wide recognition during the peak years of his career. Utley’s legacy in the MLB is significant, not only for his statistics but also for his impact on the field and in the clubhouse.

StatisticCareer Total
Hits1,885
Batting Average.275
Home Runs259
RBIs1,025
Stolen Bases154
All-Star Appearances6
Gold Gloves0

More information on Utley’s career, recognition, and statistics can be found on his Wikipedia page.

13. Lou Whitaker

Lou Whitaker, often referred to as “Sweet Lou,” is highly esteemed among the best second basemen in baseball history. Whitaker’s career, which spanned from 1977 to 1995, was marked by a remarkable consistency and skill that made him an integral part of the Detroit Tigers, the only team he played for in Major League Baseball (MLB). His collaboration with shortstop Alan Trammell formed one of the most enduring double-play combinations in the history of the sport.

In a time when power was scarce among middle infielders, Whitaker combined solid defensive work with a productive bat. He was recognized with three Silver Slugger awards and was a perennial Gold Glove candidate, earning the award five times for his defensive excellence. His impressive track record also includes an American League Rookie of the Year award and contributions to the Tigers’ World Series win in 1984.

Below is a brief overview of his career highlights and statistics:

Career HighlightsTotal
Hits2,369
Batting Average.276
Home Runs244
RBIs1,084
Stolen Bases143
Gold Gloves5
All-Star Appearances5
Silver Slugger Awards4
World Series Titles1

Whitaker’s numbers reflect a balance of offensive production and defensive prowess, earning him a dedicated following and a place in baseball history discussions. Despite these accomplishments, Whitaker’s recognition in terms of national awards like MVP has been limited, a point often highlighted in debates on his Hall of Fame candidacy.

12. Jackie Robinson

Jackie Robinson’s impact on baseball extends beyond the infield, yet his prowess as a second baseman is noteworthy. He played 748 games at the position for the Brooklyn Dodgers, demonstrating consistent skill. His career at second base was truncated after 1952, but his overall performance was marked by agility and smart defensive play.

Robinson was a versatile player, also taking roles at first base, third base, and outfield. He played with determination and finesse, challenging opponents with his strategic base running. His offensive statistics were impressive, underscored by a strong on-base percentage and batting average.

Known for breaking Major League Baseball’s color barrier, Robinson’s career achievements extend beyond stats. His play earned him six All-Star selections, the 1949 National League MVP award, and he was an instrumental figure in the Dodgers’ success during his tenure.

Career HighlightsDetails
Hits1,518
Batting Average.311
Stolen Bases197
All-Star6x
MVP Awards1
Gold GlovesN/A

11. Robinson Canó

Robinson Canó is a highly regarded figure in baseball with a career that spans multiple teams. He began with the New York Yankees, then played for the Seattle Mariners, the New York Mets, and the San Diego Padres before joining the Dubai Wolves of Baseball United. His influence extends beyond Major League Baseball (MLB), as he also captains the Estrellas Orientales in the Dominican Professional Baseball League.

Throughout his career, Canó has been recognized for his powerful hitting and defensive skills. His on-field performance has garnered numerous accolades and has placed him amongst the most talented second basemen in the history of the game. Canó has been a major contributor to his teams’ successes and left a lasting impact on the sport.

Robinson Canó has accumulated impressive statistics over the course of his career, reflecting his abilities and consistency as a second baseman. Below is a table summarizing his most notable career achievements.

StatisticNumber
Hits2,624
Batting Average.302
Home Runs334
Gold Gloves2
All-Star Appearances8
Stolen Bases51

For in-depth details on Canó’s career and statistics, a thorough profile can be found on Robinson Canó – Wikipedia.

10. Frankie Frisch

Frankie Frisch, known as “the Fordham Flash,” was a switch-hitting second baseman renowned for his speed and defensive skill. Starting his Major League Baseball career with the New York Giants in 1919, Frisch later achieved fame with the St. Louis Cardinals. He was instrumental in the Cardinals’ successful run during the 1930s, contributing both as a player and manager.

Frisch’s leadership qualities were evident when he managed the Cardinals to a World Series victory in 1934. His playing career was punctuated by consistent performance, earning him a respectable batting average and a significant number of stolen bases. Frisch was selected for the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1947, underlining his significance within the sport.

His career statistics reflect the impact he had on the game:

StatisticCareer Total
Hits2,880
Batting Average.316
Stolen Bases419
MVP Awards1 (1931)
All-Star Appearances3
World Series Titles4 (1921, 1922, 1931, 1934)

Frisch excelled in fielding as well, although Gold Glove Awards were not given out during his era. His agility and quick reflexes at second base established him as a defensive stalwart. His expertise on the field contributed significantly to the dynamic and successful Cardinals teams of the 1930s.

For further detail on his life and career, the comprehensive Frankie Frisch Wikipedia page provides extensive information.

9. Ryne Sandberg

Ryne Sandberg, inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2005, stands out as one of the most accomplished second basemen in baseball history. In a career spanning sixteen seasons, largely with the Chicago Cubs, Sandberg was renowned for his defensive skills and offensive versatility. Notably, he won nine Gold Glove Awards and was a ten-time All-Star, reflecting his all-around contributions to the game.

His offensive prowess is highlighted by his seven Silver Slugger Awards, demonstrating his exceptional hitting among second basemen. Sandberg’s career was punctuated by memorable moments, such as the “Sandberg Game” in his MVP year of 1984, where he hit game-tying home runs in both the ninth and tenth innings against the St. Louis Cardinals.

Career Statistics and Awards:

StatisticTotal
Hits2,386
Batting Average.285
Gold Gloves9
All-Star Appearances10
Silver Sluggers7
Home Runs282
Stolen Bases344
Hall of Fame Induction2005
MVP Awards1

Sandberg’s impact on the field was matched by his leadership and poise, characteristics that made him a beloved figure among Cubs fans and a respected opponent across Major League Baseball.

8. Craig Biggio

Craig Biggio, who spent his entire 20-season MLB career with the Houston Astros, is widely considered one of the greatest second basemen in the game’s history. Beginning his career as a catcher before transitioning to second base, he achieved exceptional versatility that bolstered his value. His impressive career featured seven All-Star selections, indicative of his standing among peers and fans alike.

Biggio was known for his exceptional hitting, recording over 3,000 hits, a milestone that underscores his consistent offensive production. He also demonstrated speed on the bases with over 400 stolen bases. Defensively, his talent earned him four Gold Glove Awards, immortalizing his proficiency in the field.

The table below encapsulates Craig Biggio’s major career statistics and accomplishments:

Statistic/AwardTotal
Hits3,060
Batting Average.281
Home Runs291
Runs Batted In (RBI)1,175
Stolen Bases414
All-Star Appearances7
Gold Gloves4
Silver Slugger Awards5

His entry into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2015 further solidifies his legacy as an elite second baseman and a legend of the sport.

7. Charlie Gehringer

Charles Leonard Gehringer, often referred to as “the Mechanical Man,” is a storied figure in baseball history. Recognized for his reliability and consistent high performance, Gehringer spent his entire 19-season career with the Detroit Tigers. His precision at second base and his offensive prowess made him a central figure in the Tigers’ lineup.

Gehringer’s batting skill was exceptional, boasting a career average of .320 and achieving over 200 hits in seven seasons. He was known for his disciplined approach at the plate, rarely striking out and often putting the ball into play. His notable base running added to his offensive threat, recording a significant number of stolen bases in his career.

He was an integral part of the Tigers’ success, contributing to their American League pennant wins and their World Series championship in 1935. Gehringer’s numerous accolades, including multiple All-Star Game appearances and MVP recognition, highlight his impact on the game and solidify his legacy as one of the best to ever play at second base.

Career Statistics
Batting Average.320
Hits2,839
Stolen Bases181
RBIs1,427
Awards
MVP1
All-Star Appearances6
Gold GlovesN/A (Award not yet established)

6. Roberto Alomar

Roberto Alomar is celebrated as one of baseball’s elite second basemen, combining stellar defense with a potent offensive skill set. With a career spanning sixteen seasons, his legacy is especially tied to his time with the Toronto Blue Jays. His slick fielding and ability to deliver at the plate earned him a reputation as a complete player.

Alomar amassed over 2,700 hits in his career, maintaining a strong .300 batting average. He was known for his speed on the bases, reflected in his impressive tally of 474 stolen bases. Alomar’s consistent excellence on the field garnered him 10 Gold Glove Awards, the most ever by a second baseman at the time of his retirement.

Selected to the All-Star team 12 times, Alomar’s impact on the game was recognized by coaches, players, and fans alike. Although he never clinched an MVP award, his contributions to his teams’ successes resonated beyond individual accolades. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, a testament to his all-around talent and lasting influence on the game.

Career Statistics
Hits2724
Batting Average.300
Gold Gloves10
All-Star Appearances12
Stolen Bases474
Hall of Fame2011 Inductee

5. Joe Morgan

Joe Morgan shines as one of the greatest second basemen in the annals of baseball history. A pivotal member of the Cincinnati Reds’ “Big Red Machine,” Morgan’s blend of power, speed, and defensive prowess set him apart. His consistency at the plate and on the field earned him a place in the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1990.

Morgan’s career was distinguished by his exceptional on-base skills and intelligent base running. He accumulated 2,517 hits and boasted a career batting average of .271. Notably, Morgan led the National League in on-base percentage four times, underscoring his keen eye and patience at the plate.

Defensively, Morgan was a wizard, capturing five consecutive Gold Glove Awards from 1973 to 1977. His defensive abilities were complemented by his base-stealing talent, swiping a total of 689 bases over his career. This blend of offensive and defensive skills helped earn him two Most Valuable Player (MVP) Awards in 1975 and 1976.

Career StatisticAchievement
Hits2,517
Batting Average.271
Gold Gloves5
All-Star Appearances10
MVP Awards2
Stolen Bases689

In summary, Morgan’s statistics underscore why he remains a benchmark for excellence at second base, and his accolades are a testament to his impact on the game.

4. Nap Lajoie

Nap Lajoie, regarded as one of baseball’s top second basemen, played for the Philadelphia Phillies, Philadelphia Athletics, and the Cleveland Naps, a team named after him due to his fame. Lajoie’s impressive career statistics boast a .338 batting average and he amassed 3,242 hits. His fielding prowess and batting skill earned him the reputation of being an all-round exceptional player.

During his career, Lajoie won a batting title with a staggering .426 average in 1901, a feat that underscores his status as an elite hitter of his era. His consistency at bat is illustrated by his five batting titles. Despite stiff competition, Lajoie excelled, maintaining a notable presence in the major leagues from 1896 to 1916.

His achievements extend beyond batting titles, as Lajoie was known for his skillful defense, contributing to his team’s infield strength. While contemporary awards like Gold Gloves were not awarded in his time, his defensive contributions are well acknowledged by baseball historians. Lajoie was not only a player but also served as a player-manager, demonstrating leadership and versatility.

Here are Lajoie’s most notable statistics and awards:

CategoryStatistic
Hits3,242
Batting Average.338
Batting Titles5
Triple Crowns1

*Note: MVP awards and Gold Gloves were not awarded during Lajoie’s era.

3. Rod Carew

Rod Carew is renowned as one of baseball’s quintessential hitters, with a career that made an indelible mark on the game. A native of Panama, Carew debuted in Major League Baseball in 1967 and swiftly established himself as an elite contact hitter. Over his 19-year career, predominantly with the Minnesota Twins and then the California Angels, he garnered an impressive array of accolades, testament to his prowess at the plate and on the field.

He won the American League (AL) Rookie of the Year Award in 1967 and captured the AL batting title seven times, epitomizing consistency and skill in hitting for average. Carew’s hitting technique, which allowed him to consistently place the ball and beat out grounders for infield hits, made him a feared presence at the batter’s box. His 1977 season remains particularly noteworthy — he led the league with a .388 batting average and secured the AL Most Valuable Player (MVP) award.

Beyond his batting achievements, Carew was also a skilled baserunner, accumulating 353 stolen bases over his career. His versatility on the field is highlighted by playing both second base and first base, where he demonstrated his keen defensive abilities by earning Gold Glove Awards.

Below is a table highlighting Rod Carew’s career achievements and statistics:

StatisticTotal
Hits3,053
Batting Average.328
Gold Gloves1
All-Star Appearances18
MVP Awards1
Stolen Bases353

Carew’s legacy in baseball is not only marked by his Hall of Fame induction, but also by his influence on future generations of hitters who seek to emulate his remarkable hitting technique and on-base proficiency.

2. Eddie Collins

Eddie Collins stands out as a key figure in baseball’s history. His Major League career spanned from 1906 to 1930, where he excelled as a second baseman for the Philadelphia Athletics and Chicago White Sox. A graduate from Columbia University, he was known for his strategic play and sharp baseball intellect.

Collins’s ability to hit and run bases set a new standard in the deadball era. He was a skilled place-hitter and a master at stealing bases, which earned him a place in the Hall of Fame. His consistent performance over the years contributed significantly to his teams’ successes during his career.

Career Highlight Statistics:

StatisticTotal
Hits3,315
Batting Average.333
Stolen Bases744
MVP Awards1 (1914)
All-StarNot applicable*

*The All-Star Game was not established until 1933, after Collins’s prime playing years.

Collins remains one of the few players whose career statistics bear testimony to his versatile and tactical approach to the game. A trailblazer of his time, his legacy persists among the greatest second basemen in baseball history.

1. Rogers Hornsby

rogers hornsby baseball hall of

Rogers Hornsby stands as a titan among second basemen, famed for his remarkable hitting skills. His career batting average of .358 is eclipsed only by Ty Cobb’s average, securing Hornsby’s place as a historical hit leader. In 23 seasons, Rogers Hornsby’s prowess at the plate was complemented by his strategic mind, which also led him to roles as a manager and coach.

In 1922, Hornsby became the first player to bat over .400 and hit 40 home runs in a single season, an accomplishment that left an indelible mark on baseball history and reflected his extraordinary ability to combine power with precision. Regarded by many as the game’s greatest right-handed hitter, his performance earned him two MVP awards and solidified his legacy in the Hall of Fame.

Rogers Hornsby was not just an offensive juggernaut. His defensive skills contributed significantly to the teams he played for, although his prowess at second base didn’t garner Gold Glove recognition as the award wasn’t established until after his career ended. Nonetheless, Hornsby’s contributions were multifaceted and instrumental in shaping the role of a second baseman.

Rogers Hornsby’s Career Highlights
Hits: 2,930
Batting Average: .358
Home Runs: 301
RBI: 1,584
Stolen Bases: 135
NL MVP Awards: 1925, 1929
All-Star Appearances: 2 (1933, 1934)*
Hall of Fame Induction: 1942

*The All-Star Game was established in 1933, late into Hornsby’s career.

4 thoughts on “24 Best Second Basemen in Baseball History: Who’d We Miss?”

Comments are closed.