Rusty Staub vs. Dave Winfield: Who Deserves the Edge?

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain

Rusty Staub and Dave Winfield are two players who not only impressed on the field but also off it. Their careers are filled with memorable moments, amazing accomplishments, and lasting memories. Join us as we delve deep into the careers of these two baseball legends, comparing their impact, statistics, and accolades.

Early Careers and Breakthroughs

Rusty Staub: Le Grand Orange

Daniel Joseph “Rusty” Staub began his MLB journey with the Houston Colt .45s in 1963 at just 19 years old. His initial seasons were challenging, with batting averages hovering around .220. However, by 1967, Staub broke out, leading the National League in doubles with 44 and earning his first All-Star selection. Known for his hitting prowess, Staub posted a career batting average of .279 with 2,716 hits, 292 home runs, and 1,466 RBIs over a 23-year career. He became particularly beloved in Montreal, where he was affectionately called “Le Grand Orange” due to his red hair and his spectacular performance as the Expos’ first star player.

Dave Winfield: A Multi-Sport Marvel

David Mark Winfield’s entrance into Major League Baseball was nothing short of extraordinary. Drafted by the San Diego Padres in 1973, Winfield bypassed the minors and went straight to the majors—a testament to his immense talent. Over his 22-year career, Winfield played for six teams, including the New York Yankees and the Toronto Blue Jays. With a career batting average of .283, 3,110 hits, 465 home runs, and 1,833 RBIs, Winfield’s athleticism was undeniable. His transition from a multi-sport star in college, where he excelled in baseball and basketball, to one of baseball’s most consistent performers is a testament to his versatility and skill.

Comparisons in Performance and Statistics

Consistency at the Plate

Staub and Winfield both boasted impressive hitting statistics, but Winfield’s power and longevity at the plate give him an edge. Staub’s career .279 batting average, with 2,716 hits, 292 home runs, and 1,466 RBIs, highlights his consistency and ability to contribute offensively over two decades. However, Winfield’s .283 batting average, with 3,110 hits, 465 home runs, and 1,833 RBIs, showcases his superior power and run-producing capabilities.

Winfield’s ability to hit for both power and average is exemplified by his 12 All-Star selections, compared to Staub’s six. Winfield also led the National League in RBIs in 1979 and showcased his power with several seasons surpassing 30 home runs. Staub, on the other hand, had his best power season in 1970 with 30 home runs and consistently provided solid offensive production, especially highlighted during his time with the Montreal Expos.

Defensive Prowess

Defensively, both players were notable, but Winfield’s athleticism and multiple Gold Glove Awards set him apart. Winfield earned seven Gold Glove Awards, showcasing his exceptional fielding abilities in right field. His powerful arm was a significant asset, preventing extra bases and contributing to his overall defensive excellence.

Staub also displayed solid defensive skills, particularly noted during his time with the Expos and Mets. His ability to play both outfield and first base added versatility to his defensive contributions.

Awards and Accolades

Rusty Staub’s Achievements

• Six-time All-Star (1967–1971, 1976)
• Montreal Expos No. 10 retired
• New York Mets Hall of Fame
• Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame induction (2012)
• Montreal Expos’ career leader in on-base percentage (.402)