15 Pitching Performances That Still Don’t Feel Real

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Michael Schatz

Baseball’s greatest pitching performances have shaped the sport’s history, creating unforgettable moments that continue to captivate fans decades later. From perfect games to record-breaking strikeout performances, these legendary outings showcase the pinnacle of pitching mastery. Let’s explore 15 of the most remarkable pitching performances that have left an indelible mark on America’s pastime.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

Sandy Koufax’s Perfect Game (1965)

Screenshot 2025 01 20 at 9.54.34 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

On September 9, 1965, Sandy Koufax achieved baseball immortality with a perfect game against the Chicago Cubs. The legendary Dodgers southpaw struck out 14 batters without allowing a single baserunner, outdueling Bob Hendley in a 1-0 masterpiece. The game, lasting just 1 hour and 43 minutes, represents the peak of Koufax’s dominance during his Hall of Fame career.

Kerry Wood’s 20-Strikeout Game (1998)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 10.54.01 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

In just his fifth major league start, 20-year-old Kerry Wood delivered one of baseball’s most dominant performances. Against the Houston Astros, Wood struck out 20 batters, allowed just one hit, and earned a record-setting Game Score of 105. This remarkable outing by the Cubs’ rookie remains the highest-rated nine-inning pitching performance in MLB history.

Don Larsen’s World Series Perfect Game (1956)

Screenshot 2025 01 20 at 11.01.20 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

The only perfect game in World Series history came in Game 5 when Yankees pitcher Don Larsen faced the Brooklyn Dodgers. Using just 97 pitches, Larsen struck out seven in a 2-0 victory. The iconic embrace between Larsen and catcher Yogi Berra remains one of baseball’s most enduring images.

Nolan Ryan’s Seventh No-Hitter (1991)

Screenshot 2025 01 24 at 6.18.21 PM
Image Credit: YouTube

At age 44, Nolan Ryan threw his record-setting seventh no-hitter against the Toronto Blue Jays. The Texas Rangers’ ace struck out 16 batters and walked just two, showcasing his legendary power and durability. This historic achievement solidified Ryan’s status as baseball’s all-time strikeout king and no-hit master.

Max Scherzer’s 20-Strikeout Game (2016)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 10.56.29 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

Scherzer dominated his former team, the Detroit Tigers, with 20 strikeouts in a complete game victory. He threw 119 pitches, including an unprecedented 96 strikes, allowing just two hits. This masterful performance featured 33 swings and misses, showcasing modern pitching at its finest.

Pedro Martinez’s 17-Strikeout One-Hitter (1999)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 10.57.32 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

During the height of the steroid era, Pedro Martinez delivered a masterpiece at Yankee Stadium. He struck out 17 batters and allowed just one hit in a complete game victory. This performance came during what many consider the greatest pitching season in baseball history.

Warren Spahn’s Marathon Masterpiece (1963)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 10.58.24 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

At age 42, Spahn pitched an incredible 16 scoreless innings against the Giants. Though he eventually lost 1-0 to Juan Marichal, his 201-pitch performance remains unmatched in modern baseball. This remarkable display of endurance stands as the longest complete game by both starters in MLB history.

Harvey Haddix’s 12 Perfect Innings (1959)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 10.59.15 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

Pirates pitcher Harvey Haddix achieved perfection for 12 innings before losing in the 13th. He retired 36 consecutive batters – the equivalent of a perfect game plus three innings – only to suffer a heartbreaking loss. Many consider this the greatest game ever pitched despite its unfortunate ending.

Roger Clemens’ First 20-Strikeout Game (1986)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 11.00.14 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

The 23-year-old Red Sox ace made history as the first pitcher to strike out 20 batters in a nine-inning game. Clemens allowed no walks and just three hits against the Mariners, establishing himself as baseball’s premier power pitcher and ushering in a new era of dominance.

Tom Seaver’s 19 Strikeouts (1970)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 11.01.15 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

Tom Seaver dominated the San Diego Padres in April of 1970 to the tune of 19 strikeouts – including 10 in a row. The Mets and Seaver would win the game 2-1 in what was another example of Seaver’s precision and dominance during his prime.

Randy Johnson’s Perfect Game at 40 (2004)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 11.04.42 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

The Big Unit became the oldest pitcher to throw a perfect game, dominating the Braves with 13 strikeouts. At age 40, Johnson’s performance proved that his intimidating presence and devastating slider remained effective well into his fourth decade.

Bob Gibson’s World Series Record (1968)

Screenshot 2025 01 22 at 3.46.17 PM
Image Credit: YouTube

Gibson struck out a World Series record 17 Tigers in Game 1 of the 1968 Fall Classic. He allowed just five hits in a complete game shutout during “The Year of the Pitcher.” This performance epitomized Gibson’s intimidating presence and competitive fire on baseball’s biggest stage.

Roy Halladay’s Playoff No-Hitter (2010)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 11.06.29 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

In his first career playoff start, Halladay threw just the second postseason no-hitter in MLB history against the Reds. He walked one batter and struck out eight, showcasing the mastery that made him the most reliable pitcher of his generation.

David Cone’s Perfect Game (1999)

Screenshot 2025 01 30 at 11.09.04 AM
Image Credit: YouTube

On Yogi Berra Day at Yankee Stadium, with Don Larsen in attendance, Cone threw the 16th perfect game in MLB history. Using just 88 pitches against the Expos, he created a poetic connection to Larsen’s World Series perfect game that Berra caught in 1956.