Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Michael Schatz
Baseball’s greatest players have graced the All-Star Game throughout its storied history. From legendary sluggers to defensive wizards, these athletes have dominated the Midsummer Classic with record-setting performances and unforgettable moments. Here’s a look at the most decorated All-Stars at each position, based on their starts and selections.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Iván “Pudge” Rodríguez – The Ultimate All-Star Catcher
With 12 starts and 14 All-Star selections, Pudge Rodríguez dominated the catching position for over a decade. His incredible run included nine straight starts (1993-2001) with the Rangers and three more with the Tigers. The defensive mastermind earned 13 Gold Gloves and captured the 1999 AL MVP award, cementing his legacy as one of baseball’s greatest catchers.
Steve Garvey – The First Base Star
Despite being the only non-Hall of Famer in this lineup, Garvey’s impact was undeniable with 9 starts and 10 All-Star selections. The 1974 NL MVP spent 14 seasons with the Dodgers, hitting over .300 seven times and winning four Gold Gloves. His All-Star excellence earned him MVP honors twice (1974, 1978), showcasing his ability to perform on baseball’s biggest stage.
Roberto Alomar – Second Base Excellence
Alomar’s All-Star consistency was remarkable, earning selections in every season from 1990-2001 across four different teams. With 9 starts and 12 selections, he dominated the AL second base position throughout the 1990s. Though a .300 career hitter, Alomar’s All-Star performances were surprisingly modest, batting just .233 in his 30 at-bats during the Midsummer Classic.
Brooks Robinson – The Human Vacuum at Third
The Orioles legend made 11 starts across 18 All-Star selections, matching Wade Boggs for most starts at the hot corner. Robinson’s defensive prowess earned him 16 Gold Gloves, and he showed his offensive capabilities in the 1966 All-Star Game, collecting hits off three Hall of Fame pitchers: Sandy Koufax, Juan Marichal, and Gaylord Perry.
Cal Ripken Jr. – The Iron Man Shortstop
Ripken’s 14 starts and 19 selections included an incredible run from 1984-96 at shortstop. His final All-Star appearance in 2001 provided a storybook ending, hitting a home run and winning MVP honors. His record of starting in 17 different seasons remains unmatched, showcasing his unprecedented consistency and durability.
Ted Williams – The Greatest Left Fielder
The Splendid Splinter’s All-Star career was nothing short of spectacular, with 12 starts and 19 selections. His 1946 return from military service featured a legendary 4-for-4 performance with two homers at Fenway Park. Williams holds All-Star records for RBIs (12) and walks (11), posting an impressive .304/.439/.652 line in the Midsummer Classic.
Willie Mays – The Say Hey Kid in Center
Mays’ record 18 starts across 24 selections included two MVP performances (1963, 1968). The Say Hey Kid holds the all-time record with six stolen bases in All-Star competition, demonstrating his exceptional combination of power and speed. His presence in center field defined excellence for multiple generations of baseball fans.
Hank Aaron – The All-Time All-Star in Right
Hammerin’ Hank’s 25 All-Star selections stand as an unbreakable record, featuring 14 starts in right field. His versatility allowed him to also start at first base, left field, and center field. Aaron’s All-Star appearances spanned multiple eras of baseball, demonstrating his remarkable longevity and consistent excellence.
Don Drysdale – The All-Star Ace
The Dodgers’ legendary right-hander dominated All-Star competition with 5 starts across 9 selections. Drysdale holds records for innings pitched (19 1/3) and strikeouts (19) in All-Star competition, posting an impressive 1.40 ERA. His intimidating presence on the mound made him the natural choice to start multiple Midsummer Classics.
Tony Gwynn – Mr. Padre off the Bench
Despite being one of baseball’s greatest pure hitters with a career .338 average, Gwynn’s All-Star performances tell a different story. The eight-time batting champion made 10 starts across 15 selections, showing his versatility by starting at all three outfield positions and DH. Surprisingly, Mr. Padre hit just .241 (7-for-29) in the Midsummer Classic, a rare instance where his legendary bat didn’t match his regular-season excellence.