Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Michael Schatz
Throughout MLB history, there have been numerous MVP winners whose achievements have faded from memory. From groundbreaking Latin American players to defensive specialists, these 10 forgotten MVP winners each had their moment of glory as their league’s most valuable player. Let’s revisit these overlooked baseball heroes and their remarkable seasons.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Zoilo Versalles: Baseball’s First Latin American MVP (1965)
The Cuban-born shortstop made history as MLB’s first Latin American MVP winner in 1965. Leading the American League with 126 runs, 45 doubles, and 12 triples, Versalles was the catalyst for the pennant-winning Twins. His .273 batting average and 19 home runs that season would stand as career highs, making his MVP campaign even more remarkable.
Jeff Burroughs: The Rangers’ First MVP Star (1974)
In 1974, Burroughs delivered a stellar offensive campaign, hitting .301 with 25 home runs and a league-leading 118 RBIs. The Rangers’ slugger outshined contemporary stars like Reggie Jackson and Rod Carew to claim the American League MVP award in just his third full season.
Don Baylor: The Angels’ Power-Speed MVP (1979)
Better known to modern fans as a manager, Baylor’s 1979 MVP season was remarkable. Leading the Angels to their first division title, he topped the American League with 139 RBIs and 120 runs scored while hitting .296 with 36 home runs. His rare combination of power (36 homers) and speed (22 stolen bases) made him a unique threat in his era.
Willie McGee: The Cardinals’ Speedy Sensation (1985)
McGee’s MVP season showcased his exceptional all-around skills, winning the National League batting title with a .353 average while collecting 216 hits and stealing 56 bases. His speed and defense were elite, leading the Cardinals to a pennant in an era dominated by power hitters.
George Bell: Toronto’s First MVP Winner (1987)
The Dominican slugger made history as Toronto’s first MVP winner with an outstanding season: .308 batting average, 47 home runs, and 134 RBIs. Bell’s achievement, though somewhat forgotten today, represented a breakthrough moment for both the Blue Jays franchise and Dominican baseball.
Terry Pendleton: The Braves’ Worst-to-First Hero (1991)
Pendleton’s MVP season coincided with Atlanta’s miraculous worst-to-first campaign. He won the batting title (.319), led the league in hits (187), and added 22 home runs while playing stellar defense at third base. His leadership helped launch the Braves’ dynasty of the 1990s.
Ken Caminiti: The Padres’ Power-Hitting Third Baseman (1996)
Caminiti’s MVP campaign was one of the most impressive all-around seasons by a third baseman in MLB history. He hit .326 with 40 home runs and 130 RBIs while playing Gold Glove defense. As the first Padre to win MVP, his achievement marked a significant milestone for the franchise.
Juan Gonzalez: Texas’ Powerful Run Producer (1996)
“Igor” dominated American League pitching in 1996, batting .314 with 47 home runs and 144 RBIs. His incredible run production and clutch hitting made him one of the most feared batters of his era, though his achievements are often overlooked in discussions of 1990s baseball greats.
Mo Vaughn: Boston’s Beloved “Hit Dog” (1995)
In a strike-shortened season, “The Hit Dog” captured the AL MVP with a .300 average, 39 home runs, and 126 RBIs. Vaughn’s combination of power and surprising athleticism for his size made him a fan favorite in Boston, though injuries would later cut short his promising career.
Roger Peckinpaugh: The Defensive Wizard MVP (1925)
Perhaps the most surprising MVP winner in baseball history, Peckinpaugh won primarily for his leadership and defensive excellence at shortstop. Despite modest offensive numbers (.294 average, 4 home runs), his steady play helped Washington capture the AL pennant, showcasing how different MVP voting criteria were in baseball’s early days.