Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Michael Schatz
Baseball history has seen its share of controversial figures who’ve stirred the pot and created drama both on and off the field. From explosive personalities to notorious troublemakers, these players left an indelible mark on America’s pastime – though not always for the right reasons. Here are the 12 biggest agitators in MLB history.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
1. Nyjer Morgan: Baseball’s Most Theatrical Troublemaker
Known by his alter ego “Tony Plush,” Morgan was one of baseball’s most eccentric agitators during his 2007-2014 career. His most infamous moment came during a 2010 brawl with the Marlins when he charged the mound after Chris Volstad threw behind him. Morgan’s theatrical post-game interviews, on-field antics, and frequent confrontations with opponents made him a constant source of controversy throughout his career.
2. Carlos Gomez: The Bat-Flipping Instigator
Gomez’s flamboyant style and excessive bat flips regularly sparked confrontations during his tenure from 2007-2019. His most notorious incident occurred in 2013 when he admired a home run against the Braves, leading to a bench-clearing brawl with Brian McCann blocking his path to home plate. His aggressive style and emotional outbursts made him one of baseball’s most controversial figures.
3. Yasiel Puig: The Wild Horse
“The Wild Horse” earned his nickname through unpredictable behavior both on and off the field from 2013-2019. His bat flips, tongue wagging, and confrontational style regularly angered opponents. Puig’s tardiness to games, conflicts with teammates, and numerous bench-clearing incidents, including a seven-game suspension for a 2019 brawl, made him one of baseball’s most volatile personalities.
4. Gary Sheffield: The Intimidator
Sheffield’s menacing bat waggle and outspoken personality made him one of baseball’s most intimidating figures from 1988-2009. He frequently clashed with team management and made controversial statements about race in baseball. His involvement in the BALCO scandal and confrontational relationship with the media further cemented his reputation as an agitator.
5. A.J. Pierzynski: Baseball’s Most Hated Player
Pierzynski mastered the art of getting under opponents’ skin during his career from 1998-2016. From phantom hit-by-pitches to questionable baserunning tactics, his gamesmanship often crossed into unsportsmanlike territory. He was repeatedly voted “Most Hated Player in MLB” in player polls, earning a reputation that followed him throughout his career.
6. John Rocker: The Controversial Closer
Rocker’s brief career (1998-2003) was marked by controversial statements and behavior. His infamous 1999 Sports Illustrated interview, where he made derogatory comments about New York City’s diverse population, led to a suspension and made him baseball’s premier villain. His confrontational style with fans and media only amplified his negative reputation.
7. Roberto Alomar: The Spitting Incident
Despite his Hall of Fame credentials, Alomar’s reputation was forever tarnished by the 1996 incident where he spat in umpire John Hirschbeck’s face during an argument. This shocking moment overshadowed his exceptional playing career from 1988-2004. His later confrontations with teammates and management further cemented his status as an agitator.
8. Albert Belle: The Intimidating Slugger
Belle’s intense personality and frequent outbursts made him one of baseball’s most feared players from 1989-2000. Known for charging the mound, destroying clubhouse equipment, and confronting fans, his most infamous moment came during the corked bat incident of 1994, where teammate Jason Grimsley crawled through air ducts to retrieve the evidence.
9. Carl Everett: Jurassic Carl
Nicknamed “Jurassic Carl” for his denial of dinosaurs’ existence, Everett’s career (1993-2006) was marked by bizarre beliefs and confrontational behavior. His most notorious moment came when he headbutted umpire Ronald Kulpa during an argument about the strike zone. He frequently clashed with managers, teammates, and opponents throughout his career.
10. Milton Bradley: The Volatile Outfielder
Bradley’s career (2000-2011) was defined by his volatile temperament and numerous confrontations. He once attempted to confront a broadcaster in the press box during a game and had multiple run-ins with umpires and fans. His career was marked by ejections, suspensions, and trades due to his inability to control his emotions.
11. Billy Martin: The Ultimate Instigator
As both a player and manager (1950-1988), Martin was baseball’s ultimate troublemaker. Known for his explosive temper, he was involved in numerous fights, including the infamous Copacabana Club incident. As a manager, he frequently argued with umpires and even had physical altercations with his own players.
12. Vicente Padilla: The Headhunter
Nicknamed “The Headhunter,” Padilla (1999-2012) was notorious for intentionally throwing at batters. He led the league in hit batsmen multiple times and was involved in numerous brawls. His reputation was so established that teams would warn new players about his tendency to target hitters, especially in retaliation situations.