Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
Last Updated: May 26th, 2026 by Michael Schatz
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
The Giants franchise has sent plenty of immortals to Cooperstown, but some of their greatest performers remain on the outside looking in. These are the players who made the Polo Grounds shake and Candlestick Park roar, who turned routine games into must-see events and defined what it meant to wear the orange and black.
From power hitters who changed the game to defensive wizards who made the impossible routine, these twenty Giants delivered Hall of Fame value to their franchise. Their numbers tell part of the story, but it’s the memories they created—the moonshots, the bare-handed catches, the clutch hits in October—that truly measure their greatness.
From the Polo Grounds to McCovey Cove, these franchise legends delivered Cooperstown-caliber performances without the bronze plaque.
We are counting down from #20 to #1, so the argument builds as the list gets closer to the top spot.
#20 Gary Matthews: The Original Sarge at Candlestick
Before he became Sarge in Philadelphia, Matthews was the spark plug that ignited the Giants offense of the early seventies. His 1973 Rookie of the Year campaign featured a .300 average and a presence in left field that made fans forget the departed Willie McCovey.
Those who saw his compact swing and aggressive baserunning still consider him the prototype of the modern leadoff hitter. His instincts on the bases turned singles into doubles and doubles into runs.
Matthews brought energy to a franchise searching for identity after the Mays era ended. His five seasons in San Francisco established him as one of the most complete players of his generation.
#19 Randy Moffitt: The Bullpen Ace Who Battled the Big Red Machine
Before the era of specialized relievers, Moffitt was the Giants firefighter during the tough NL West battles of the seventies. His submarine delivery and devastating sinker helped him rack up 96 saves in an era when closers often worked multiple innings.
The brother of tennis star Billie Jean King brought his own brand of competitive fire to those fog-shrouded Candlestick nights. He became one of the most reliable relievers in Giants history, the man managers turned to when games hung in the balance.
His durability and consistency defined an era when relief pitching was evolving from afterthought to essential. Moffitt showed that games could be won in the late innings with the right arm on the mound.
#18 George Burns: The Forgotten MVP of 1912
Before the Live Ball Era changed baseball forever, Burns defined excellence at first base for John McGraw’s Giants. His 1912 MVP season saw him lead the league in runs scored and walks, while his defensive wizardry at first base revolutionized the position.
Those Polo Grounds faithful witnessed a master craftsman who could handle any throw in the dirt. His ability to dig out low throws saved countless errors and turned the Giants infield into the league’s best.
Burns played winning baseball when winning meant manufacturing runs and playing flawless defense. His eight seasons with the Giants established the standard for first base play in the dead ball era.
#17 Tito Fuentes: The Dancing Infielder of the Seventies
With his trademark headband and pre-pitch dance moves, Fuentes brought Latin flair to Candlestick Park long before it was common. His defensive wizardry at second base was matched only by his showmanship—every double play was a performance, every at-bat an event.
The Giants first true baseball entertainer made even those frigid Candlestick nights feel tropical. His personality filled the ballpark while his glove work anchored the infield.
Fuentes hit .268 over nine seasons with the Giants and made the All-Star team in 1972. He proved that baseball could be both excellent and entertaining, that style and substance weren’t mutually exclusive.
#16 Chris Speier: The Three-Time All-Star Who Defined Giants Defense
In an era when shortstops weren’t expected to hit, Speier did it all. His three All-Star selections in the early seventies established him as the National League’s premier shortstop before Dave Concepcion took that crown.
The smooth-fielding infielder made the impossible look routine at Candlestick, where routine plays were anything but. His range and arm strength set the standard for Giants shortstops for decades.
Speier spent ten seasons with the Giants across two stints and provided steady leadership both in the field and in the clubhouse. His consistency and professionalism defined what it meant to be a Giant.
#15 Felipe Alou: The Original Dominican Dandy
Before the Dominican Republic became baseball’s greatest talent pipeline, Alou blazed the trail. His .286 average and 206 home runs only tell part of the story—he was the Giants first Latin American superstar, opening doors for generations to come.
Those who saw him patrol the Candlestick outfield alongside his brothers Matty and Jesus witnessed baseball history that will never be repeated. The Alou brothers playing together represented a milestone in the game’s integration.
Felipe’s eleven seasons with the Giants established him as one of the franchise’s most consistent performers. His impact extended far beyond statistics, changing the face of baseball itself.
#14 John Montefusco: The Rookie Who Predicted No-Hitters
The Count wasn’t just another talented arm—he was baseball’s most colorful character of the mid-seventies. He famously predicted his 1976 no-hitter against Atlanta, and his Rookie of the Year season in 1975 brought showmanship back to the mound.
In an era when Candlestick Park needed heroes, Montefusco delivered both style and substance. His 16-win rookie campaign gave Giants fans hope that the franchise’s pitching tradition would continue.
Montefusco’s confidence bordered on arrogance, but he backed it up with performance. His six seasons with the Giants featured an All-Star appearance and moments of pure dominance that made him unforgettable.
#13 Jim Ray Hart: The Giant Who Time Forgot
Before injuries derailed his promising career, Hart was the most feared right-handed bat in the Giants lineup not named Willie Mays. His 1964-1968 peak saw him average 27 home runs per season when 20 was considered power hitting.
Old-timers still talk about his tape-measure shots that challenged the physics of Candlestick Park. His swing generated power that seemed impossible from his compact frame.
Hart’s eight seasons with the Giants produced 170 home runs and a .286 average. Had injuries not shortened his prime, his career numbers would have demanded Cooperstown consideration.
#12 Johnny Antonelli: The Southpaw Who Brought the Series to SF
When the Giants moved west in 1958, Antonelli became San Francisco’s first pitching hero. His masterful 16-win season and 2.96 ERA helped bring the first pennant race to the City by the Bay.
Those who witnessed his devastating slider still say it moved like no pitch they’d ever seen before or since. His ability to change speeds and hit spots made him nearly unhittable on his best days.
Antonelli’s four seasons in San Francisco established the winning culture the franchise needed in its new home. His 1958 performance proved the Giants could compete with the Dodgers in California.
#11 Vida Blue: The Man Who Made Candlestick Electric
When Blue took the mound at Candlestick, even the infamous fog seemed to part in respect. His electric fastball and devastating curve made him the most exciting pitcher in San Francisco during the late seventies and early eighties.
Blue turned those cold nights at the Stick into must-see events, bringing Oakland’s championship magic across the bay. His presence on the mound gave the Giants credibility in an era when the franchise struggled for relevance.
His six seasons with the Giants featured two All-Star appearances and consistent excellence. Blue proved that great pitching could still dominate in an era when offense was beginning to take over the game.
#10 Robby Thompson: The Heart of the ’89 Giants
The quintessential Giant of the late eighties, Thompson’s gritty play and clutch hitting embodied the spirit of Roger Craig’s Humm-Baby era. His pivot on the double play was poetry in motion, and his unexpected power—37 homers in 1993—showed that good things come in scrappy packages.
Those who watched him play still measure every Giants second baseman against his standard. His consistency and professionalism made him the foundation of a franchise rebuilding its identity.
Thompson’s eleven seasons with the Giants produced two All-Star appearances and a reputation as one of the game’s most complete second basemen. His leadership helped guide the franchise from also-ran to contender.
#9 Kevin Mitchell: The Bare-Handed Wonder of ’89
Before highlight reels became routine, Mitchell made the impossible look easy. His bare-handed catch running toward the left-field line in 1989 remains one of baseball’s most iconic plays.
The 1989 NL MVP wasn’t just about defense though—his 47 homers that year came when 47 really meant something. Mitchell’s combination of power and athleticism made him the most feared hitter in the National League.
His five seasons with the Giants featured two All-Star appearances and moments of pure brilliance. Mitchell showed that raw talent combined with confidence could produce magical results.
#8 Darrell Evans: The Most Underrated Power Hitter Ever
Before sabermetrics made on-base percentage fashionable, Evans was living it. His 407 career home runs and exceptional eye at the plate would make him a statistical darling in today’s game.
Those who watched him in the seventies remember a third baseman who could change a game with both his glove and his bat—a complete player before that became a buzzword. His patience at the plate frustrated pitchers who couldn’t find a weakness to exploit.
Evans spent eight seasons with the Giants and made two All-Star teams. His ability to draw walks and hit for power made him one of the most productive players of his generation.
#7 Matt Williams: The Last of the Old-School Third Basemen
Before the steroid era changed baseball’s power dynamics, Williams was the game’s premier slugging third baseman. His 43 homers in the strike-shortened 1994 season had him on pace to challenge Roger Maris’s record, and his bare-handed plays at third base were worth the price of admission alone.
That cannon arm and lightning-quick release became the standard for hot corner defense. Williams made plays that other third basemen wouldn’t even attempt, turning impossible chances into routine outs.
His ten seasons with the Giants produced 247 home runs and four Gold Glove awards. Williams represented the complete package—power, defense, and clutch performance when games mattered most.
#6 Jack Clark: The Fear Factor Before Steroids
When Jack the Ripper Clark dug in at Candlestick, pitchers suddenly found the corners of the plate. His legendary power and patience at the plate made him the most feared Giant of the early eighties.
Those towering shots into the swirling winds of Candlestick seemed to defy both gravity and the elements. Clark’s ability to hit for power in one of baseball’s toughest home run parks made his accomplishments even more impressive.
His eight seasons with the Giants featured four All-Star appearances and a .299 average. Clark’s combination of power and discipline made him the prototype for the modern slugger.
#5 Bobby Bonds: Living in the Shadow of His Son
Before there was Barry, there was Bobby—the original five-tool Giant who could change a game with his speed, power, or glove. His 461 career steals and 332 homers made him one of baseball’s first 300-300 club members.
Those who saw him patrol right field at Candlestick still talk about his graceful routes and rocket arm. Bonds combined power and speed in ways that seemed impossible, creating a template his son would later perfect.
His seven seasons with the Giants produced three All-Star appearances and established him as one of the game’s most dynamic players. Bobby Bonds proved that baseball’s future would belong to athletes who could do everything.
#4 Buster Posey: The Perfect Giant Who Changed the Game
The face of the Giants dynasty years, Posey revolutionized catching in the modern era. His 2012 MVP season came after a devastating injury that would have ended lesser careers, proving his mental toughness matched his physical skills.
But it was his handling of the greatest pitching staff in San Francisco history—Lincecum, Cain, Bumgarner, and company—that truly set him apart. Posey’s game-calling and leadership turned good pitchers into great ones and great pitchers into legends.
Three World Series rings later, he retired as the most beloved Giant since Willie Mays. His combination of offense, defense, and leadership defined excellence at baseball’s most demanding position.
#3 Jeff Kent: The Most Powerful Second Baseman Ever
Before second basemen were supposed to hit for power, Kent was launching bombs into the bleachers with regularity. His 377 career home runs remain the most ever by a second baseman, a record that may never be broken.
That MVP season in 2000 made him Barry Bonds’ perfect protection in the lineup. The mustache, the intensity, and those clutch doubles down the line defined an era when Giants baseball meant business.
Kent’s six seasons with the Giants produced four All-Star appearances and established him as the greatest offensive second baseman in baseball history. His ability to drive in runs from the two-hole changed how teams constructed their lineups.
#2 Will Clark: The Sweetest Swing That Cooperstown Forgot
That sweet left-handed stroke was pure baseball artistry, a swing so perfect it belonged in the Louvre. Will the Thrill Clark arrived at Candlestick Park in 1986 and promptly homered off Nolan Ryan in his first at-bat, setting the tone for a career that would define Giants baseball in the late eighties.
His intensity, his clutch hitting in the 1989 NLCS, and that signature eye black made him the face of a franchise reborn. Clark’s .333 average in that series against the Cubs remains one of the greatest postseason performances in Giants history.
His nine seasons with the Giants produced six All-Star appearances and a .299 average. Clark combined hitting excellence with fierce competitiveness, making him the most complete first baseman of his generation.
#1 Barry Bonds: The Home Run King Without a Crown
The numbers speak volumes: 762 home runs, seven MVP awards, and a .444 on-base percentage that made pitchers lose sleep. Barry Bonds transformed the game during his 15 seasons with the Giants, turning walks into weapons and at-bats into must-see TV.
The controversies that kept him out of Cooperstown can’t erase the memories of those moonshots into McCovey Cove or the electricity that coursed through Pac Bell Park every time number 25 stepped to the plate. Bonds was the most feared hitter in baseball history, a player who changed how the game was played.
His Giants career produced 586 home runs and redefined what was possible at the plate. Bonds delivered more franchise value than any player in San Francisco history, making him the greatest Giant who ever played.
Final Thoughts
These twenty Giants represent more than just impressive statistics and memorable moments. They embody the franchise’s rich history across two coasts and multiple generations, from the dead ball era at the Polo Grounds to the modern dynasty at Oracle Park.
Whether they ever receive the call from Cooperstown or not, these players delivered Hall of Fame value to the Giants franchise. Their contributions built a legacy that continues to define what it means to wear the orange and black, proving that greatness isn’t always measured by bronze plaques but by the memories that last forever.