Where Does Todd Helton Stand Next to Fred McGriff?

June 17, 2026June 26, 2024 by Jake Cain

Last Updated: June 17, 2026

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain

When we think of all-time first basemen, two names that instantly get mentioned are Todd Helton and Fred McGriff. Both players enjoyed long, successful careers that saw them earn the ultimate prize: enshrinement in Cooperstown. Let’s explore the careers of these two amazing players and see what truly sets them apart.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

Screenshot 2024 05 21 11.29.05 AM — Via Stathead

Early Careers and Major League Breakthroughs

Todd Helton: The Colorado King

Todd Helton’s journey to the big leagues began in Knoxville, Tennessee, where he excelled in both football and baseball at Central High School. After being drafted by the Colorado Rockies in the first round of the 1995 MLB Draft, Helton spent a couple of years honing his skills in the minors.

In 1997, Helton debuted with the Rockies and quickly cemented himself as a cornerstone of the franchise. His rookie season saw him hitting .280 with five home runs, setting the stage for a stellar career. By 1998, Helton was the Rockies’ full-time first baseman, a role he would dominate for the next 17 years.

Fred McGriff: The Journeyman Slugger

Fred McGriff’s path to MLB greatness started in Tampa, Florida. Drafted by the New York Yankees in the ninth round of the 1981 MLB Draft, McGriff was later traded to the Toronto Blue Jays, a move that would eventually look incredibly one-sided in retrospect.

McGriff made his MLB debut in 1986 and by 1987, he was a full-time player. Known as the “Crime Dog,” McGriff showcased his power early on, hitting 34 home runs in 1988 and establishing himself as one of the premier power hitters of his era. He would go on to play for six different teams over his 19-year career, leaving a lasting impact wherever he went.

Offensive Prowess and Statistics

Batting Average and Hits

Throughout his career, Todd Helton was a model of consistency at the plate. His lifetime batting average of .316 and 2,519 hits stand as a testament to his hitting prowess. Helton’s ability to maintain such a high average, particularly given the altitude of Coors Field, is a significant part of his legacy.

Standard Batting
Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
1997	23	COL	NL	35	101	93	13	26	2	1	5	11	0	1	8	11	.280	.337	.484	.821	96	45	1	0	0	0	0	7H/39
1998	24	COL	NL	152	595	530	78	167	37	1	25	97	3	3	53	54	.315	.380	.530	.911	119	281	15	6	1	5	5	*3H	RoY-2
1999	25	COL	NL	159	657	578	114	185	39	5	35	113	7	6	68	77	.320	.395	.587	.981	122	339	14	6	0	4	6	*3/H
2000	26	COL	NL	160	697	580	138	216	59	2	42	*147*	5	3	103	61	*.372*	.463	*.698*	*1.162*	163	*405*	12	4	0	10	22	*3/H	AS,MVP-5,SS
2001	27	COL	NL	159	697	587	132	197	54	2	49	146	7	5	98	104	.336	.432	.685	1.116	160	402	14	5	1	5	15	*3/H	AS,MVP-9,GG,SS
2002	28	COL	NL	156	668	553	107	182	39	4	30	109	5	1	99	91	.329	.429	.577	1.006	148	319	10	5	0	10	21	*3	AS,MVP-19,GG,SS
2003	29	COL	NL	160	703	583	135	209	49	5	33	117	0	4	111	72	.358	.458	.630	1.088	165	367	19	2	0	7	21	*3/H	AS,MVP-7,SS
2004	30	COL	NL	154	683	547	115	190	49	2	32	96	3	0	127	72	.347	.469	.620	1.088	165	339	12	3	0	6	19	*3/H	AS,MVP-16,GG
2005	31	COL	NL	144	626	509	92	163	45	2	20	79	3	0	106	80	.320	*.445*	.534	.979	144	272	14	9	1	1	22	*3/H
2006	32	COL	NL	145	649	546	94	165	40	5	15	81	3	2	91	64	.302	.404	.476	.880	117	260	10	6	0	6	15	*3
2007	33	COL	NL	154	682	557	86	178	42	2	17	91	0	1	116	74	.320	.434	.494	.928	133	275	15	2	0	7	16	*3/DH
2008	34	COL	NL	83	361	299	39	79	16	0	7	29	0	0	61	50	.264	.391	.388	.779	99	116	9	1	0	0	8	3/H
2009	35	COL	NL	151	645	544	79	177	38	3	15	86	0	1	89	73	.325	.416	.489	.904	128	266	15	2	0	10	5	*3/H	MVP-13
2010	36	COL	NL	118	473	398	48	102	18	1	8	37	0	0	67	90	.256	.362	.367	.728	87	146	10	2	0	6	3	*3/H
2011	37	COL	NL	124	491	421	59	127	27	0	14	69	0	1	59	71	.302	.385	.466	.850	117	196	6	3	0	8	5	*3/H
2012	38	COL	NL	69	283	240	31	57	16	1	7	37	1	1	39	44	.238	.343	.400	.743	89	96	6	1	0	3	1	3/H
2013	39	COL	NL	124	442	397	41	99	22	1	15	61	0	0	40	87	.249	.314	.423	.738	89	168	4	0	0	5	1	*3H/D
17 Yrs				2247	9453	7962	1401	2519	592	37	369	1406	37	29	1335	1175	.316	.414	.539	.953	133	4292	186	57	3	93	185
162 Game Avg.				162	682	574	101	182	43	3	27	101	3	2	96	85	.316	.414	.539	.953	133	309	13	4	0	7	13
				G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/21/2024.

Fred McGriff, while not as high in batting average, hit a respectable .284 over his career and collected 2,490 hits. McGriff’s consistency is evident as he was able to sustain a high level of performance across multiple teams and ballparks, something that is not easy to achieve.

Standard Batting
Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
1986	22	TOR	AL	3	5	5	1	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	2	.200	.200	.200	.400	8	1	0	0	0	0	0	/D3
1987	23	TOR	AL	107	356	295	58	73	16	0	20	43	3	2	60	104	.247	.376	.505	.881	130	149	3	1	0	0	4	DH3
1988	24	TOR	AL	154	623	536	100	151	35	4	34	82	6	1	79	149	.282	.376	.552	.928	157	296	15	4	0	4	3	*3/H	MVP-17
1989	25	TOR	AL	161	680	551	98	148	27	3	36	92	7	4	119	132	.269	.399	.525	.924	165	289	14	4	1	5	12	*3/DH	MVP-6,SS
1990	26	TOR	AL	153	658	557	91	167	21	1	35	88	5	3	94	108	.300	.400	.530	.930	153	295	7	2	1	4	12	*3/D	MVP-10
1991	27	SDP	NL	153	642	528	84	147	19	1	31	106	4	1	105	135	.278	.396	.494	.890	147	261	14	2	0	7	26	*3	MVP-10
1992	28	SDP	NL	152	632	531	79	152	30	4	35	104	8	6	96	108	.286	.394	.556	.950	165	295	14	1	0	4	23	*3/H	AS,MVP-6,SS
1993	29	TOT	NL	151	640	557	111	162	29	2	37	101	5	3	76	106	.291	.375	.549	.924	144	306	14	2	0	5	6	*3/H	MVP-4,SS
1993	29	SDP	NL	83	349	302	52	83	11	1	18	46	4	3	42	55	.275	.361	.497	.858	127	150	9	1	0	4	4	3
1993	29	ATL	NL	68	291	255	59	79	18	1	19	55	1	0	34	51	.310	.392	.612	1.004	165	156	5	1	0	1	2	3/H
1994	30	ATL	NL	113	478	424	81	135	25	1	34	94	7	3	50	76	.318	.389	.623	1.012	157	264	8	1	0	3	8	*3/H	AS,MVP-8
1995	31	ATL	NL	144	604	528	85	148	27	1	27	93	3	6	65	99	.280	.361	.489	.850	119	258	19	5	0	6	6	*3	AS,MVP-20
1996	32	ATL	NL	159	691	617	81	182	37	1	28	107	7	3	68	116	.295	.365	.494	.859	120	305	20	2	0	4	12	*3/H	AS
1997	33	ATL	NL	152	641	564	77	156	25	1	22	97	5	0	68	112	.277	.356	.441	.797	106	249	22	4	0	5	4	*3/H
1998	34	TBD	AL	151	649	564	73	160	33	0	19	81	7	2	79	118	.284	.371	.443	.815	111	250	14	2	0	4	9	*3D/H
1999	35	TBD	AL	144	620	529	75	164	30	1	32	104	1	0	86	107	.310	.405	.552	.957	142	292	12	1	0	4	11	*3D/H
2000	36	TBD	AL	158	664	566	82	157	18	0	27	106	2	0	91	120	.277	.373	.452	.826	110	256	16	0	0	7	10	*3D/H	AS
2001	37	TOT	MLB	146	586	513	67	157	25	2	31	102	1	2	66	106	.306	.386	.544	.930	144	279	13	3	0	4	13	*3D/H
2001	37	TBD	AL	97	385	343	40	109	18	0	19	61	1	1	40	69	.318	.387	.536	.923	144	184	7	0	0	2	9	3D/H
2001	37	CHC	NL	49	201	170	27	48	7	2	12	41	0	1	26	37	.282	.383	.559	.942	145	95	6	3	0	2	4	3
2002	38	CHC	NL	146	595	523	67	143	27	2	30	103	1	2	63	99	.273	.353	.505	.858	125	264	13	4	0	5	6	*3/HD
2003	39	LAD	NL	86	329	297	32	74	14	0	13	40	0	0	31	66	.249	.322	.428	.750	99	127	7	1	0	0	4	3/H
2004	40	TBD	AL	27	81	72	7	13	3	0	2	7	0	0	9	19	.181	.272	.306	.577	53	22	1	0	0	0	2	D/H3
19 Yrs				2460	10174	8757	1349	2490	441	24	493	1550	72	38	1305	1882	.284	.377	.509	.886	134	4458	226	39	2	71	171
162 Game Avg.				162	670	577	89	164	29	2	32	102	5	3	86	124	.284	.377	.509	.886	134	294	15	3	0	5	11
				G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
TBD (5 yrs)				577	2399	2074	277	603	102	1	99	359	11	3	305	433	.291	.380	.484	.864	122	1004	50	3	0	17	41
ATL (5 yrs)				636	2705	2388	383	700	132	5	130	446	23	12	285	454	.293	.369	.516	.885	128	1232	74	13	0	19	32
TOR (5 yrs)				578	2322	1944	348	540	99	8	125	305	21	10	352	495	.278	.389	.530	.919	153	1030	39	11	2	13	31
SDP (3 yrs)				388	1623	1361	215	382	60	6	84	256	16	10	243	298	.281	.388	.519	.906	149	706	37	4	0	15	53
CHC (2 yrs)				195	796	693	94	191	34	4	42	144	1	3	89	136	.276	.361	.518	.879	130	359	19	7	0	7	10
LAD (1 yr)				86	329	297	32	74	14	0	13	40	0	0	31	66	.249	.322	.428	.750	99	127	7	1	0	0	4

NL (10 yrs)				1305	5453	4739	724	1347	240	15	269	886	40	25	648	954	.284	.370	.512	.882	132	2424	137	25	0	41	99
AL (10 yrs)				1155	4721	4018	625	1143	201	9	224	664	32	13	657	928	.284	.384	.506	.891	137	2034	89	14	2	30	72

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/21/2024.

Home Runs and Slugging

Helton hit 369 home runs in his career, a number that places him firmly in the upper echelon of power hitters. His 2000 season was particularly memorable, where he led the league with a .698 slugging percentage and hit 42 home runs.

McGriff, on the other hand, was a true power hitter, belting 493 home runs, just seven short of the magical 500 mark. Known for his smooth swing and ability to drive the ball out of any park, McGriff led the league in home runs twice (1989 in the AL and 1992 in the NL), demonstrating his power across different teams and leagues.

Runs Batted In (RBIs)

Both players were clutch performers when it came to driving in runs. Helton accumulated 1,406 RBIs over his career, while McGriff tallied 1,550 RBIs. McGriff’s ability to drive in runs was a key factor in his teams’ successes, particularly during his time with the Atlanta Braves, a period highlighted by a World Series title in 1995.

Awards and Accolades

Todd Helton: The All-Star Rockie

Helton’s career is filled with numerous accolades that highlight his excellence on the field:

5× All-Star (2000–2004)
3× Gold Glove Award (2001, 2002, 2004)
4× Silver Slugger Award (2000–2003)
NL Hank Aaron Award (2000)
MLB batting champion (2000)
MLB RBI leader (2000)

In addition to these, Helton holds multiple Rockies’ franchise records, including most hits (2,519), home runs (369), and RBIs (1,406).

Fred McGriff: The Consistent Slugger

McGriff’s career is equally decorated, showcasing his impact across various teams:

5× All-Star (1992, 1994–1996, 2000)
World Series champion (1995)
3× Silver Slugger Award (1989, 1992, 1993)
2× Home run leader (1989, 1992)

McGriff’s legacy was further cemented by his induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2023, a fitting honor for a player who consistently performed at a high level throughout his career.

Defensive Skills and Versatility

Todd Helton: The Defensive Anchor

Helton was not just a force at the plate; he was also a stalwart defensively. His three Gold Glove Awards highlight his exceptional skills at first base, where he was known for his ability to scoop errant throws and make difficult plays look routine. Helton’s defensive prowess provided stability for the Rockies’ infield and contributed significantly to his overall value as a player.

Fred McGriff: The Reliable Veteran

While McGriff didn’t garner as many defensive accolades as Helton, he was a reliable presence at first base. Over his career, he played in 2,239 games at first, ranking third in career games at the position. McGriff’s steady defense and ability to turn double plays made him a valuable asset to his teams, complementing his offensive contributions.

Impact on the Game and Legacy

Helton’s Enduring Rockies Legacy

Todd Helton’s impact on the Colorado Rockies is unparalleled. Spending his entire 17-year career with the same team, Helton became the face of the franchise. His consistent performance, leadership, and dedication helped the Rockies achieve multiple playoff appearances, including a trip to the World Series in 2007.

Helton’s influence extends beyond the field as well; his jersey number 17 was retired by the Rockies, a testament to his lasting legacy. In 2024, Helton was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame, solidifying his place among the game’s greats.

McGriff’s Cross-Country Contributions

Fred McGriff’s career is a testament to his adaptability and excellence. Playing for six different teams, McGriff left a significant mark wherever he went. His time with the Atlanta Braves, in particular, stands out, as he played a crucial role in their 1995 World Series victory.

McGriff’s nickname, “Crime Dog,” and his long-running ESPN commercial for Tom Emanski’s Baseball Fundamentals have made him a beloved figure in baseball pop culture. His induction into the Hall of Fame in 2023 is a recognition of his consistent power-hitting and impact over nearly two decades in the league.

Final Thoughts

Comparing Todd Helton and Fred McGriff offers a fascinating glimpse into two different yet equally remarkable careers. Helton’s tenure with the Rockies and his impressive batting average, combined with his defensive skills, made him a franchise icon. McGriff’s power and consistency over a career that spanned six teams highlight his versatility and enduring talent.

Both players have earned their places in baseball history, with their respective inductions into the Hall of Fame serving as a crowning achievement. Whether it’s Helton’s smooth swing at Coors Field or McGriff’s towering homers across different parks, their contributions to the game will be remembered and celebrated by baseball fans for generations to come.