Last Updated: October 16th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
There is no franchise in baseball history that has seen more success than the New York Yankees. Fans in the Bronx have been spoiled with Hall of Fame talent basically year after year.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
As we go through this list, you'll find that the next-best all-time Yankees could probably make their own World Series team.
How We Made This List
The only requirement is that the player is not in the Hall of Fame. There are some obvious picks for this list, so those entries are easy. You'll see pretty quickly.
As for the rest, we wanted to balance the commitment to the franchise with the amount of impact they had. Sometimes, one great year is enough, while other times, a span of many good seasons is perfectly great to make this list.
20. Roger Clemens: The Rocket's Bronx Renaissance
The greatest pitcher outside of the Hall of Fame, Roger Clemens, is a must-add to this list. No matter what you think of his association with steroids, you can't deny his record seven Cy Young awards and 4,672 career strikeouts.
More than 1,000 of those strikeouts came in just six seasons in New York as he led them to two World Series championships.
| Roger Clemens — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 354 |
| L | 184 |
| ERA | 3.12 |
| G | 709 |
| IP | 4916.2 |
| SO | 4672 |
| WHIP | 1.17 |
| SV | 0 |
| MVP | 1 |
| Cy Young | 7 |
| All-Star selections | 11 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
19. Sparky Lyle: The Bronx Zoo's Relief King
We all know of baseball's first unanimous Hall of Famer, Mariano Rivera. However, before he was even born, Sparky Lyle was starting to get saves early in his career. When he found his way to the Bronx, his career became iconic.
He led the league in relief appearances once and led in games finished twice. He earned three All-Star appearances in his career, with all three coming as a Yankee. He finished his career with a very solid 2.88 ERA and 128 ERA+.
| Sparky Lyle — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 99 |
| L | 76 |
| ERA | 2.88 |
| G | 899 |
| IP | 1390.1 |
| SO | 873 |
| WHIP | 1.28 |
| SV | 238 |
18. Chris Chambliss: The Man Who Made The Bronx Dance
Chris Chambliss was a Gold Glove first baseman who had a solid bat, but not a phenomenal one. Then came the 1976 ALCS. Chambliss hit an incredible .524 with two home runs.
One of them will be remembered forever, as he hit a walk-off in Game 5 to win the pennant. I can't imagine a better feeling than making a single swing that sends your team to the World Series.
| Chris Chambliss — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 2175 |
| AB | 7571 |
| H | 2109 |
| HR | 185 |
| RBI | 972 |
| SB | 40 |
| AVG | .279 |
| OBP | .334 |
| SLG | .415 |
| OPS | .749 |
| All-Star selections | 1 |
| Gold Gloves | 1 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
| Rookie of the Year | 1 |
17. Allie Reynolds: The Superchief's Forgotten Dominance
One of the great rotation pieces from the late 1940s and early 1950s, Allie Reynolds is an underrated pitcher in Yankees history. He led all pitchers in shutouts two years in a row. He also earned five All-Star selections in six seasons.
His best was 1952, when he won 20 games and the ERA title with a 2.06 ERA. He ended up finishing second in MVP voting that season, proving how good he really was.
| Allie Reynolds — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 182 |
| L | 107 |
| ERA | 3.30 |
| G | 434 |
| IP | 2492.1 |
| SO | 1423 |
| WHIP | 1.39 |
| SV | 49 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| World Series titles | 6 |
16. Gil McDougald: The Versatile Infielder of Five Champions
There really is only one thing that holds Gil McDougald back from being a Hall of Famer. Longevity. The 1951 Rookie of the Year had a highly successful 10-year career.
He earned six All-Star selections as one of the better infielders in the league.
He helped the Yankees win five World Series championships and was a big contributor in every season of his career. A 40.9 career WAR in 10 years is as good as any player can wish for.
| Gil McDougald — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1336 |
| AB | 4676 |
| H | 1291 |
| HR | 112 |
| RBI | 576 |
| SB | 45 |
| AVG | .276 |
| OBP | .356 |
| SLG | .410 |
| OPS | .766 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| World Series titles | 5 |
| Rookie of the Year | 1 |
15. Elston Howard: Breaking the Yankees' Color Barrier
There are a lot of parallels between Elston Howard and the other historic barrier breakers in baseball. His skill was so good that it couldn't be ignored; he withstood a ton of racial discrimination, and he became a great player in MLB. Howard was a 12-time All-Star and two-time Gold Glove winner, and capped it off with an MVP award in 1963.
| Elston Howard — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1625 |
| AB | 5443 |
| H | 1491 |
| HR | 168 |
| RBI | 775 |
| SB | 10 |
| AVG | .274 |
| OBP | .321 |
| SLG | .427 |
| OPS | .748 |
| MVP | 1 |
| All-Star selections | 9 |
| Gold Gloves | 2 |
| World Series titles | 4 |
14. Mel Stottlemyre: The Ace of Lean Years
There have been some leaner times in Yankee history, and Mel Stottlemyre happened to be unfortunately in those times. His production was great for his shorter 11-year career. His career 2.97 ERA proves how good he was.
He just didn't get the run support he needed to collect wins. He led the league in losses twice, but was an absolute workhorse, leading the league in complete games twice.
| Mel Stottlemyre Sr. — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 164 |
| L | 139 |
| ERA | 2.97 |
| G | 360 |
| IP | 2661.1 |
| SO | 1257 |
| WHIP | 1.22 |
| SV | 1 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
13. Tommy John: The Man Who Changed Pitching Forever
The old saying goes that it never would be famous it wasn't successful. Boy, was Tommy John successful. The Yankees were the biggest beneficiaries too.
He earned two of his three straight All-Star selections in the Bronx, where he had two straight 20-game seasons. 91 of his 288 career wins came with the Yankees in eight seasons, more than any of the other franchises he played for.
| Tommy John — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 288 |
| L | 231 |
| ERA | 3.34 |
| G | 760 |
| IP | 4710.1 |
| SO | 2245 |
| WHIP | 1.28 |
| SV | 4 |
| All-Star selections | 4 |
12. Bobby Murcer: Mickey's Heir Who Never Got His Due
13 years of commitment to the Yankees organization earned Murcer a spot on this list. He was given the tall task of filling the great Mickey Mantle's shoes. He did so admirably, earning four of his five consecutive All-Star selections as a Yankee.
His best season came in 1972 when he led the league in runs and earned a Gold Glove Award.
| Bobby Murcer — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1908 |
| AB | 6730 |
| H | 1862 |
| HR | 252 |
| RBI | 1043 |
| SB | 127 |
| AVG | .277 |
| OBP | .357 |
| SLG | .445 |
| OPS | .802 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| Gold Gloves | 1 |
11. Roy White: The Most Underrated Yankee Ever
Roy White was such a good ballplayer. He spent his entire 15-year career in the Bronx racking up the stats. He had a solid 3.2 WAR or more in 10 straight seasons, being as dependable as any outfielder they could start.
He earned two All-Star selections and probably should have received more. A 121 career OPS+ puts him just outside of a Hall of Fame tier.
| Roy White — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1881 |
| AB | 6650 |
| H | 1803 |
| HR | 160 |
| RBI | 758 |
| SB | 233 |
| AVG | .271 |
| OBP | .360 |
| SLG | .404 |
| OPS | .764 |
| All-Star selections | 2 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
10. Roger Maris: More Than Just 61 Home Runs
There are still some fans out there who will say that this man is the all-time single-season home run king. Considering the fact that the 61 home runs that Roger Maris hit were in 1961, that means that there were no steroids, a higher mound for pitchers to throw off of, and fewer technological advancements in physical training.
With that level of difficulty, I can see the argument.
| Roger Maris — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1463 |
| AB | 5101 |
| H | 1325 |
| HR | 275 |
| RBI | 850 |
| SB | 21 |
| AVG | .260 |
| OBP | .345 |
| SLG | .476 |
| OPS | .821 |
| MVP | 2 |
| All-Star selections | 4 |
| Gold Gloves | 1 |
| World Series titles | 3 |
9. Paul O'Neill: The Warrior's Passionate Legacy
For all the attention that Paul O'Neill garnered because of his hot-headed attitude, he had a very solid career. Four out of the five All-Star selections he earned came in the second half of his career when he was a Yankee.
He was a big part of their four World Series championships in five years, posting a good 125 OPS+ in the nine seasons he spent in the Bronx.
| Paul O’Neill — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 2053 |
| AB | 7318 |
| H | 2105 |
| HR | 281 |
| RBI | 1269 |
| SB | 141 |
| AVG | .288 |
| OBP | .363 |
| SLG | .470 |
| OPS | .833 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| World Series titles | 5 |
8. Willie Randolph: The Quiet Engine of the Dynasty
Having a good second baseman has always been an underrated part of a championship team. Willie Randolph was that second baseman for the Yankees for 13 years, earning five All-Star selections and a Silver Slugger.
He was a young contributor to their 1977 World Series championship as he hit a home run in the World Series at just 22 years old.
| Willie Randolph — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 2202 |
| AB | 8018 |
| H | 2210 |
| HR | 54 |
| RBI | 687 |
| SB | 271 |
| AVG | .276 |
| OBP | .373 |
| SLG | .351 |
| OPS | .724 |
7. Ron Guidry: Louisiana Lightning Struck Fast
I think Ron Guidry is the one great ace in Yankee history who is truly on the outside looking in at the Hall of Fame. Some of the others who can lay claim either have steroid accusations, played for other teams, or just didn't have the success that Guidry had.
For all 14 years of his career, Ron Guidry was a Yankee. He won back-to-back ERA titles and had three 20-win seasons, earning that Cy Young Award in 1978.
| Ron Guidry — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 170 |
| L | 91 |
| ERA | 3.29 |
| G | 368 |
| IP | 2392.0 |
| SO | 1778 |
| WHIP | 1.18 |
| SV | 4 |
| Cy Young | 1 |
| All-Star selections | 4 |
| Gold Gloves | 5 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
6. Graig Nettles: The Hot Corner's Defensive Wizard
One of the best third basemen outside of Cooperstown, Graig Nettles was the favorite player of a lot of Yankee fans back in the day. He hit 250 of his 390 career home runs in pinstripes, earning six All-Star selections and two Gold Gloves.
Nettles led the league in WAR back in 1976 thanks to his league-leading 32 home runs that season. A 68.0 career WAR is well inside the threshold of average Hall of Famers.
| Graig Nettles — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 2700 |
| AB | 8986 |
| H | 2225 |
| HR | 390 |
| RBI | 1314 |
| SB | 32 |
| AVG | .248 |
| OBP | .329 |
| SLG | .421 |
| OPS | .750 |
| All-Star selections | 6 |
| Gold Gloves | 2 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
5. Andy Pettitte: October's Most Reliable Arm
It's actually hard to picture Andy Pettitte in anything else but pinstripes. His World Series performances are still remembered in the Bronx. It's like they forgot he had a three-year hiatus in Houston before returning to the organization for the second time.
219 of his 256 career wins came with the Yankees, and I'm sure that fans will remember the five World Series wins that he obtained for the franchise too.
| Andy Pettitte — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| W | 256 |
| L | 153 |
| ERA | 3.85 |
| G | 531 |
| IP | 3316.0 |
| SO | 2448 |
| WHIP | 1.35 |
| SV | 0 |
| All-Star selections | 3 |
| World Series titles | 5 |
4. Jorge Posada: The Fierce Heart of Four Championships
Jorge Posada has an argument to be the best catcher, not in the Hall of Fame. Five All-Star selections with five Silver Sluggers might even be too little for this star behind the plate.
He rose to prominence near the end of the legendary 1990s dynasty and just delivered great offensive numbers for a catcher throughout his 17-year career.
| Jorge Posada — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1829 |
| AB | 6092 |
| H | 1664 |
| HR | 275 |
| RBI | 1065 |
| SB | 20 |
| AVG | .273 |
| OBP | .374 |
| SLG | .474 |
| OPS | .848 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| Silver Sluggers | 5 |
| World Series titles | 4 |
3. Bernie Williams: The Smooth Center of the Dynasty
Sometimes, the quietest one can make the loudest noise. For Bernie Williams, both can be true. Williams nowadays lets his guitar do the talking, while he let his bat and glove do the talking during his heyday.
With five All-Star selections and four Gold Gloves, Bernie Williams commanded center in Yankee Stadium as well as anyone, and that's saying something.
| Bernie Williams — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 2076 |
| AB | 7869 |
| H | 2336 |
| HR | 287 |
| RBI | 1257 |
| SB | 147 |
| AVG | .297 |
| OBP | .381 |
| SLG | .477 |
| OPS | .858 |
| All-Star selections | 5 |
| Gold Gloves | 4 |
| Silver Sluggers | 1 |
| World Series titles | 4 |
2. Don Mattingly: Donnie Baseball's Brief Brilliance
No first baseman could really compare to the defensive skills of Don Mattingly when he was in his prime. The nine-time Gold Glove winner earned six All-Star selections and three Silver Slugger awards.
It's a shame that defense could be respected more by Hall of Fame voters because Mattingly's induction has been long overdue. I'm sure Yankee fans would agree.
| Don Mattingly — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1785 |
| AB | 7003 |
| H | 2153 |
| HR | 222 |
| RBI | 1099 |
| SB | 14 |
| AVG | .307 |
| OBP | .358 |
| SLG | .471 |
| OPS | .829 |
| MVP | 1 |
| All-Star selections | 6 |
| Gold Gloves | 9 |
| Silver Sluggers | 3 |
1. Thurman Munson: The Captain Who Left Too Soon
This is the closest to a sure thing that I could think of if the scenario that happened didn't happen. Thurman Munson passed away in 1979 after 10 and a half seasons in pinstripes.
He earned seven All-Star selections, a Rookie of the Year, and the 1976 MVP Award. He accumulated a 46.0 career WAR, incredible for a catcher in that short amount of time.
| Thurman Munson — Career | Total |
|---|---|
| G | 1423 |
| AB | 5344 |
| H | 1558 |
| HR | 113 |
| RBI | 701 |
| SB | 48 |
| AVG | .292 |
| OBP | .346 |
| SLG | .410 |
| OPS | .756 |
| MVP | 1 |
| All-Star selections | 7 |
| Gold Gloves | 3 |
| World Series titles | 2 |
| Rookie of the Year | 1 |
Final Thoughts
Like I said at the top, I think that the players on this list could just make their own World Series run as one unit. Sure, the lineup could use a little power, but the caliber of play is at such a consistently high level.
This was a pretty fun list to go through, and I hope you have remembered some entries you would've liked to see on this list.
