Last Updated: August 17th, 2026 by Michael Schatz
It seems like it's been a yearly debate ever since these sluggers were put on Hall of Fame ballots. Should known users from the steroid era be inducted into Cooperstown if they have the credentials? We explore the best players from that era and what their case is for being enshrined.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
12. Barry Bonds: Baseball’s Controversial Home Run King
We start right at the top. I'm sure I don't need to mention the numbers or even the BALCO scandal involvement. Every inch of Barry Bonds' career is well documented. This is usually where the argument starts. If the ridiculous numbers that Bonds put up during his illustrious career are not enough to receive a bronze plaque, then none of the following players should either.
11. Mark McGwire: The Home Run Chase That Changed Everything
Mark McGwire reinvigorated baseball. Enough kids from that era have grown up now to voice that opinion. He has admitted to using steroids in front of a grand jury. We all know that. The question is: do enough of us acknowledge his impact on the game for it to be immortalized in Cooperstown?
His sky-scraping 583 home runs and that magical 70-home-run season are nostalgic. Are they nostalgic enough?
10. Alex Rodriguez: A-Rod’s Complicated Legacy
Alex Rodriguez is around sports in general these days. He has kept his face in the spotlight. However, when he shows up, you can still hear boos from the crowd. He smiles through it all.
He's admitted to making mistakes. Are they forgivable? Four homers shy of 700 and three MVPs, Alex Rodriguez revolutionized what power can look like from a shortstop.
9. Roger Clemens: The Rocket’s Descent
When I hear fans debate about who the greatest pitcher in baseball history is, I rarely hear Roger Clemens' name anymore. That's the point that this has gotten to. His placement on the Mitchell Report sent his legacy down a cliff. I almost feel obligated to remind you that he has a record seven Cy Youngs, 354 career victories, and an era of dominance.
8. Sammy Sosa: From Slugger to Scandal
Sammy Sosa adds one thing that some of the other sluggers on this list can't: a legendary arm. With over 600 career home runs with a rifle in right field, Sammy Sosa was indispensable on a daily basis. He is also known negatively, not just for using steroids, but for getting caught with a cork in his bat. The pros are added up, but the cons are as well.
7. Rafael Palmeiro: The Finger Wag Heard Round the World
It's sad that I believe Rafael Palmeiro is known more for when he testified before Congress than for when he collected his 3,020 hits and 569 home runs. He brought finesse to that era with that sweet left-handed swing. He also played a great defensive first base, but his defense in front of the public is infamous.
6. Jose Canseco: Baseball’s Steroid Whistleblower
One of the Bash Brothers and an icon of that era, Jose Canseco had a sneaky all-around game to him. His 1988 MVP season wasn't just for his 42 home runs, but for his 40 steals as well. More questions have arisen since he retired, given the way he has acted and the books he has sold. Does that make him look better or worse in the eyes of the public since his numbers hold up?
5. Manny Ramirez: Talent Tainted by Testing
Here is a player who couldn't take no for an answer. Manny was more or less in the clear while he was playing. But then he got caught in 2009. He served his 50-game suspension. Then got caught again and chose retirement.
You can say Manny was just being Manny, and his elite hitting stats hoist him up. But how far do those suspensions bring him down?
4. Gary Sheffield: BALCO’s Reluctant Client
Gary Sheffield was a very memorable player. That bat waggle is something I'll never forget. His 509 career home runs are tainted by his connection to the BALCO steroid scandal. He says he didn't know, but how much do we trust that? His career spanned many years with a handful of teams.
He has made many fans cheer. How many of those fans are still cheering for him?
3. Jason Giambi: The Apologetic Slugger
Jason Giambi is probably the most apologetic player on this list. He has admitted it and has said sorry. Does that help his case? Is there forgiveness? He's a 2000 AL MVP with 440 career home runs. He helped make Moneyball look inspiring. Is there inspiration, though, for his induction?
2. Ken Caminiti: A Tragic Pioneer
If I had to guess, I would guess that Ken Caminiti used the least amount of steroids of the players on this list. However, his MVP season may be the most obvious proof of anybody on this list, statistically. We really don't need the proof since he has publicly admitted to it. Even if he's forgiven, this is the closest of the players on this list to where I would say the numbers may not even be enough.
1. Andy Pettitte: The Honest Admission
Andy Pettitte was probably the player I was most disappointed to learn about his admission. The lefty was so fun to watch with his mix of impressive pitching repertoire and great pitching control. His 3.85 career ERA may not even be enough to get him in without the scandal. However, there are Yankee fans around the world who remember loving to watch him pitch in October.
