The 22-Ace Elite: Pitching’s True Ceiling

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: November 11th, 2026 by Matthew Brown

The ace is such a unique form of recognition for an athlete. American football has its QB1, soccer has its striker, hockey has its goon, and basketball has its 3-and-D player. All of these are unique to their respective sports, but I don't think any of them are quite like an ace.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

For one, there's rarity. An ace doesn't play every game. What that brings is anticipation.

I'm sure many of you looked forward to the day of the week where at least one of these aces toed the rubber, especially in the years we specify.

22. Chris Sale (2014-2018)

Chris Sale delivering a powerful pitch, showcasing his strikeout prowess as detailed in "The Greatest Pitchers of the 2010s."
Image Credit: YouTube.

I don't know why, but my mind can see the delivery of Chris Sale in an instant. I just think it's iconic and one of the more effective deliveries in baseball history. His release point just seems so wide that his fastball looks like zooming frisbees, and his sliders look like boomerangs.

Just a unique pitcher who has seen so much success in his career.

Chris Sale — CareerTotal
W157
L95
ERA2.96
G414
IP2207.0
SO2730
WHIP1.04
SV12
Cy Young1
All-Star selections10
Gold Gloves1
World Series titles1

21. Felix Hernandez (2009-2014)

Felix Hernandez showcasing his elite pitching skills, making hitters look foolish.
Image Credit: YouTube.

King Felix became an icon thanks to his pitching style and his entire look when he took to the mound. But his iconic status wouldn't be as strong if he didn't have the skills to back it up.

That he did during this stretch in his career. He seemed like one of the most iconic arms in baseball history when he was on his game. A 2.27 ERA that led all of baseball in 2010 is his peak.

Félix Hernández — CareerTotal
W169
L136
ERA3.42
G419
IP2729.2
SO2524
WHIP1.21
SV0
Cy Young1
All-Star selections6

20. Kevin Brown (1996-2000)

1998 NLCS Gm2 Kevin Brown
Image Credit: YouTube.

The Florida Marlins were one of the surprise champions in the 1990s. They kind of came out of nowhere, naturally because of the young nature of their organization. However, Kevin Brown had no problem putting the franchise on his back and carrying them to an improbable World Series title.

Looking back on this part of his career, he was a legitimate star, and it's no wonder why he will forever be the first six-figure contracted player in baseball history.

Kevin Brown — CareerTotal
W211
L144
ERA3.28
G486
IP3256.1
SO2397
WHIP1.22
SV0
All-Star selections6
World Series titles1

19. Curt Schilling (2001-2004)

Curt Schilling in action, a key figure among Hall of Fame pitchers overlooked for Cy Young.
Image Credit: YouTube

I don't think there was a single pitcher in all of baseball who teams would rather want on the mound in a playoff game than Curt Schilling during this duration of time. He didn't have a single Cy Young Award to his name, yet looked like an award winner when the lights were brightest.

It didn't even matter if he was hurt and blood was showing on one of his socks. He was delivering a clutch performance every time out.

Curt Schilling — CareerTotal
W216
L146
ERA3.46
G569
IP3261.0
SO3116
WHIP1.14
SV22
All-Star selections6
World Series titles3

18. Juan Marichal (1963-1969)

Historic image capturing Marichal and Spahn during their epic 1963 matchup.
Image Credit: YouTube.

Juan Marichal was one of the toughest pitchers who ever stepped onto a mound. His lack of fear made hitters second-guess before stepping into the batter's box. Then there was that iconic leg kick, which brought a sense of flair to his game that was captivating to watch.

I don't think it would matter if he played in any other era. He wouldn't back down one bit.

Juan Marichal — CareerTotal
W243
L142
ERA2.89
G471
IP3507.1
SO2303
WHIP1.10
SV2
All-Star selections9

17. Orel Hershiser (1988-1989)

Orel Hershiser celebrates after a pivotal win in the 1988 World Series, showcasing his role in the Dodgers' surprising vic...
Image Credit: jimmyack205/Flickr, CC BY 2.0.

For a pitcher who isn't considered by the rest of MLB as a Hall of Famer, Orel Hershiser sure gets treated like one in Dodger Stadium. In 1988, he looked like he could take on any Hall of Fame batter in the history of the game.

His scoreless inning streak may never be touched, and his legendary performances in the playoffs make him a beloved figure in Los Angeles for the rest of time.

Orel Hershiser — CareerTotal
W204
L150
ERA3.48
G510
IP3130.1
SO2014
WHIP1.26
SV5
Cy Young1
All-Star selections3
Gold Gloves1
Silver Sluggers1
World Series titles1

16. Dwight Gooden (1984-1986)

Dwight Gooden Sora AI
Image Credit: OpenAI.

Dwight Gooden is a perfect example for this list. For a limited stretch, he wasn't just the ace of the Mets; he was the ace of baseball. A 1.53 ERA in 1985 will do that for you.

I know that the rest of his career didn't quite see the same success, but that's not what this list is concerned about.

For some reason, Doc Gooden wasn't even voted into the top three of the MVP conversation that year, and I think he should have been.

Dwight Gooden — CareerTotal
W194
L112
ERA3.51
G430
IP2800.2
SO2293
WHIP1.26
SV3
Cy Young1
All-Star selections4
Silver Sluggers1
World Series titles1
Rookie of the Year1

15. Steve Carlton (1972-1977)

how steve carlton became the mos 2
Image Credit: YouTube.

I think Steve Carlton is an example of how the career of Sandy Koufax could have looked if he stayed healthy throughout. His 1972 season is the stuff of legend, winning 27 games with a 1.97 ERA and 310 strikeouts. I don't know how he didn't win the MVP that year.

Carlton is just an iconic lefty who inspired many generations who followed.

Steve Carlton — CareerTotal
W329
L244
ERA3.22
G741
IP5217.1
SO4136
WHIP1.25
SV2
Cy Young4
All-Star selections10
Gold Gloves1
World Series titles2

14. Nolan Ryan (1972-1979)

Nolan Ryan delivers a powerful fastball, showcasing his dominance in baseball's toughest era.
Image Credit: YouTube.

It's hard to explain how the MLB's all-time strikeout leader never won a Cy Young Award in his illustrious 27-year career. He got as close as ever in this stretch, as he finished second in 1973.

I genuinely think that the writers just assumed that he would eventually win one, but forgot to ever put his name down enough to win. I'm sure it comes as no surprise that Ryan led the league in strikeouts eight out of the nine years of this stretch.

Nolan Ryan Jr. — CareerTotal
W324
L292
ERA3.19
G807
IP5386.0
SO5714
WHIP1.25
SV3
All-Star selections8
World Series titles1

13. Justin Verlander (2011-2019)

Image of Justin Verlander in action, representing the Tigers' pitching legacy.
Image Credit: YouTube.

Longevity is part of what makes Justin Verlander such a legendary ace. He won two ERA titles over a decade apart. Obviously, this stretch of his career doesn't include his 2022 because there's a couple of injury-riddled seasons in between.

We still get to see how Verlander was able to withstand his excellence between carrying the Detroit Tigers and then becoming a key piece in the World Series run of the Houston Astros.

Justin Verlander — CareerTotal
W266
L159
ERA3.33
G556
IP3571.1
SO3554
WHIP1.14
SV0
MVP1
Cy Young3
All-Star selections10
World Series titles2
Rookie of the Year1

12. Max Scherzer (2013-2018)

Image of Max Scherzer dominating the mound during his historic 20-strikeout game.
Image Credit: YouTube.

I know this can be considered a hot take, but I don't think there's a more competitive pitcher in the history of baseball than Max Scherzer. That takes into account his skill combined with his refusal to lose. I feel like he took the responsibility of leading his team to victory personally every time it was his turn to start.

Three Cy Young Awards across two teams is an impressive rate of dominance.

Max Scherzer — CareerTotal
W222
L121
ERA3.27
G492
IP2999.0
SO3516
WHIP1.09
SV0
Cy Young3
All-Star selections8
World Series titles2

11. Johan Santana (2004-2008)

Image of Johan Santana, showcasing his dominance in 2005 Cy Young voting.
Image Credit: YouTube.

This stretch of five seasons is so impressive that it has made fans say that Johan Santana should be inducted into the Hall of Fame. A 2.82 ERA and a 157 ERA+ are just elite, especially considering the fact that he didn't have overpowering stuff. Watching Santana work was like watching a sculptor chisel away at a masterpiece, except the masterpiece was making opposing hitters look like fools.

Johan Santana — CareerTotal
W139
L78
ERA3.20
G360
IP2025.2
SO1988
WHIP1.13
SV1
Cy Young2
All-Star selections4
Gold Gloves1

10. Roy Halladay (2008-2011)

Roy Halladay
Image Credit: SD Dirk/Flickr/CC BY 2.0.

The late, great Roy Halladay is such an awesome example of a true ace who didn't exactly dominate with his numbers. It was a tough era to pitch in, and he had to carry a middling organization on his back for so long. This part of Doc's career is where he transitioned from his franchise-carrying performances to a playoff team in Philadelphia.

It helped everyone in baseball truly recognize how good he was.

Roy Halladay — CareerTotal
W203
L105
ERA3.38
G416
IP2749.1
SO2117
WHIP1.18
SV1
Cy Young2
All-Star selections8

9. Jacob deGrom (2018-2021)

Jacob deGrom in Mets Uniform.  In  windup throwing a pitch.
Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

Jacob deGrom is a "what-if" scenario at the highest level. Injuries have derailed the ceiling of his career, but he has been so good that he has still accomplished a lot. Two consecutive Cy Young Awards, with one of them containing a mind-boggling 1.70 ERA.

Unfortunately, his offense has never been able to give him enough run support. He won 21 games in those two Cy Young seasons combined. Maybe if his hitters could score more runs, we'd see him in an even brighter light.

Jacob deGrom — CareerTotal
W104
L72
ERA2.66
G270
IP1658.1
SO1995
WHIP1.00
SV0
Cy Young2
All-Star selections5
Rookie of the Year1

8. Clayton Kershaw (2011-2016)

Clayton Kershaw, a key player in the Dodgers' pitching legacy.
Image Credit: YouTube.

In the 2010s, it is hard to find a pitcher who held down opposing offenses quite like Clayton Kershaw. Four consecutive ERA titles, three Cy Young Awards in four years, and an MVP Award catapulted this Dodger to the top of the charts among all stars in baseball.

Even when money started flowing through the organization and other great arms joined the rotation, they all still deferred to Kershaw as the true ace of Los Angeles.

Clayton Kershaw — CareerTotal
W223
L96
ERA2.53
G455
IP2855.1
SO3052
WHIP1.02
SV0

7. Tom Seaver (1969-1975)

Image of Tom Seaver, showcasing his pitching form and dominance over today's hitters.
Image Credit: YouTube.

Tom Terrific was amazing from the get-go. I don't know if the Mets could have developed a more successful ace. Yes, that includes Nolan Ryan.

This stretch of dominance doesn't even include the two "development years" of Seaver's career. All that included was two All-Star selections and a Rookie of the Year Award.

He won all three of his Cy Young Awards in these seven years while maintaining an impressive 2.46 ERA throughout.

Tom Seaver — CareerTotal
W311
L205
ERA2.86
G656
IP4782.2
SO3640
WHIP1.12
SV1
Cy Young3
All-Star selections12
World Series titles1
Rookie of the Year1

6. Roger Clemens (1986-1992)

Screenshot of Roger Clemens, part of the 90s best players debate in baseball.
Image Credit: YouTube.

Remarkably, this stretch for the Rocket is during a time when I believe he wasn't using steroids. There are many pitchers in baseball history, including those in the Hall of Fame, who would have loved to have had just the Red Sox years of Roger Clemens' career. Three Cy Young Awards, four ERA titles, and 136 wins in just this duration of time are as impressive as any.

Roger Clemens — CareerTotal
W354
L184
ERA3.12
G709
IP4916.2
SO4672
WHIP1.17
SV0
MVP1
Cy Young7
All-Star selections11
World Series titles2

5. Bob Gibson (1968-1972)

Infographic showing Bob Gibson's 3,117 career strikeouts and key achievements.
Image Credit: YouTube.

I feel like if there were a dictionary with baseball players connected to each word, Bob Gibson would be right next to the word "dominant". I don't think there is any more proof of dominance than forcing the MLB to lower the height of the mound to give hitters some semblance of a chance.

The legend of Gibson carries on to this day, and many will say he would set records against today's hitters.

Bob Gibson — CareerTotal
W251
L174
ERA2.91
G528
IP3884.1
SO3117
WHIP1.19
SV6
MVP1
Cy Young2
All-Star selections8
Gold Gloves9
World Series titles2

4. Randy Johnson (1995-2002)

randy johnson strikes out 20 may
Image Credit: YouTube.

The Big Unit wasn't just big. He was skilled. Many remember that he would have some control issues earlier on in his career.

That only added to the intimidation factor that he would impose from the mound. It was when he honed in on the command of his pitches that he became truly feared.

He's one of two pitchers in history who have won four Cy Young Awards in consecutive seasons. Simply dominant.

Randy Johnson — CareerTotal
W303
L166
ERA3.29
G618
IP4135.1
SO4875
WHIP1.17
SV2
Cy Young5
All-Star selections10
World Series titles1

3. Greg Maddux (1992-1995)

Image of Greg Maddux showcasing his remarkable pitching stats from the 1995 season, highlighting his efficiency.
Image Credit: YouTube.

This is my favorite baseball player of all time. The further we get from his retirement, the more I'm satisfied with my pick. The juxtaposition between the two pitchers in history to win four consecutive Cy Young Awards is fascinating.

Randy Johnson dominated with his size and velocity. Maddux dominated with his mind and his control.

At times, it's just amazing to look back at Maddux's highlights and see how he outsmarted his opponents.

Greg Maddux — CareerTotal
W355
L227
ERA3.16
G744
IP5008.1
SO3371
WHIP1.14
SV0
Cy Young4
All-Star selections8
Gold Gloves18
World Series titles1

2. Sandy Koufax (1963-1966)

Sandy Koufax celebrating his remarkable 27-9 record in his final season.
Image Credit: YouTube.

One can only imagine how impressive Sandy Koufax's career would look had modern medical training and technology been around to help his pitching arm. His four-year run of dominance was so good that it reaches this high on this list, and I don't think there's much of an argument.

He earned three Cy Young Awards in four years, and that one season where he didn't, he had an astonishing 1.74 ERA. That's how good he was.

Sandy Koufax — CareerTotal
W165
L87
ERA2.76
G397
IP2324.1
SO2396
WHIP1.11
SV9
MVP1
Cy Young3
All-Star selections6
World Series titles3

1. Pedro Martinez (1997-2003)

Pedro Martinez dominating the mound during the 1999 All-Star Game, showcasing his skill.
Image Credit: YouTube.

I don't know if there has ever been a pitcher who had a better stretch as a true ace than Pedro Martinez. Yes, I said it. I am well aware of the other names on this list, but you have to consider multiple things here.

So many opposing hitters were using banned substances to gain major advantages.

There were more home runs hit by more players during this era than any other. Pedro still absolutely dominated. With five ERA titles, a 1.90 season, and a 1.74 season mixed in, he made these big hitters look tiny.

Pedro Martínez — CareerTotal
W219
L100
ERA2.93
G476
IP2827.1
SO3154
WHIP1.05
SV3
Cy Young3
All-Star selections8
World Series titles1

Keep reading