Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
Before the era of $300 million contracts and social media highlights, there were Mets who showed up every day, played hard, and somehow never got the All-Star recognition they deserved. These forgotten heroes wore the orange and blue with pride, left their mark on Shea Stadium’s concrete, and gave fans memories that still echo in Queens.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Craig Swan: The ERA Champion Who Pitched in Pain
Craig Swan led the National League with a 2.43 ERA in 1978, yet somehow didn’t make the All-Star team that year or any other. The right-hander battled through arm problems throughout his career but was highly effective when healthy. Swan’s story is one of what might have been: a talented pitcher whose body betrayed him before he could achieve the recognition his skills deserved.
Endy Chavez: The Defensive Wizard Who Made “The Catch”
Endy Chavez made one of the greatest catches in postseason history, robbing Scott Rolen of a home run in Game 7 of the 2006 NLCS. The Venezuelan outfielder was a defensive magician who could track down balls that seemed impossible to reach. While his bat was light, his glove was pure gold, yet he never received All-Star recognition for his spectacular defensive play.
Turk Wendell: The Quirky Reliever Who Wore His Superstitions
Turk Wendell turned every mound appearance into performance art with his elaborate rituals, but his effectiveness was no act. The right-hander posted a stellar 3.34 ERA over five seasons in Queens, becoming a fan favorite with his tooth necklace and quirky antics. Despite his solid numbers and unforgettable personality, Wendell never earned All-Star recognition during his colorful career.
Skip Lockwood: The Closer Who Saved Games and Sanity
Skip Lockwood was the Mets’ closer during the mid-1970s, saving 65 games over five seasons with the team. The right-hander had a devastating slider that made hitters look foolish in crucial situations. Despite being one of the more reliable closers of his era, Lockwood never made an All-Star team, overshadowed by more famous names in bigger markets.
Rey Ordoñez: The Shortstop Who Made Impossible Plays Look Routine
Rey Ordoñez turned shortstop into an art form, making spectacular plays look effortless with his incredible range and arm strength. The Cuban defector won three Gold Gloves and was arguably the best defensive shortstop of his generation. While his bat was a liability, his glove was a thing of beauty, yet he never received All-Star recognition despite his defensive wizardry.
Bob Ojeda: The Crafty Lefty Who Made Hitters Look Foolish
Bob Ojeda was a key piece of the 1986 championship team, going 18-5 with a 2.57 ERA in his first season after arriving from Boston. The crafty left-hander had pinpoint control and knew how to pitch, not just throw. Despite his crucial role in the Mets’ World Series victory and several solid seasons, Ojeda never earned All-Star recognition during his time in Queens.
Benny Agbayani: The Hawaiian Hero of October Magic
Benny Agbayani became a cult hero during the Mets’ 2000 playoff run, delivering clutch hits when it mattered most. The Hawaiian outfielder had a knack for coming through in pressure situations, including a dramatic game-winning home run against the Giants in the NLDS. While his overall numbers were modest, his postseason heroics made him unforgettable to Mets fans, even without All-Star recognition.
Ron Hodges: The Backup Catcher Who Caught Lightning in a Bottle
Ron Hodges spent 12 seasons as a backup catcher for the Mets, providing steady defense and occasional clutch hitting. The left-handed hitter was a favorite of pitchers for his game-calling ability and quiet leadership behind the plate. While he never put up flashy numbers, Hodges was the kind of reliable veteran every team needs, even if All-Star voters never noticed his contributions.
Kevin McReynolds: The Quiet Slugger Who Let His Bat Do the Talking
Kevin McReynolds was a consistent power threat for the Mets in the late 1980s, averaging 24 home runs and 87 RBIs during his five seasons in Queens. The Arkansas native was never flashy but was incredibly reliable, playing solid defense while providing steady offensive production. Despite his consistent performance, McReynolds never received All-Star recognition during his time with the Mets.
Timo Perez: The Rookie Speedster Who Almost Changed Everything
Timo Perez burst onto the scene in 2000 as a rookie sensation, helping lead the Mets to the World Series with his speed and clutch hitting. The Dominican outfielder became an instant fan favorite with his aggressive baserunning and timely hits. Despite his memorable rookie campaign and the heartbreak of being held at third base in Game 1 of the World Series, Perez never received All-Star recognition during his brief but unforgettable time in Queens.
Wally Backman: The Scrappy Second Baseman Who Embodied ’86
Wally Backman was the heart and soul of the 1986 championship team, a scrappy second baseman who played with intensity and grit. The switch-hitter was a pest at the plate and a sparkplug in the clubhouse, embodying the swagger of that memorable Mets squad. Despite being a key contributor to one of the greatest teams in franchise history, Backman never made an All-Star team, forever the unsung hero of that magical season.
Wayne Garrett: The Third Baseman Who Anchored a Pennant Winner
Wayne Garrett was a rookie on the 1969 Miracle Mets and became the steady presence at third base for the 1973 pennant-winning team, yet somehow never made an All-Star team. The switch-hitting infielder had a knack for clutch hits and solid defense during the franchise’s golden era. While flashier players got the headlines, Garrett quietly anchored the hot corner with the reliability of a Swiss watch.