Two Expos, One Verdict: Larry Walker vs. Tim Raines

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain

The Montreal Expos fielded some of the best players in Major League History during their time in existence. Two of the best to don the Expo jersey are Larry Walker and Tim Raines. Both have left indelible marks on the game, with stellar statistics, countless accolades, and memorable moments. Let’s explore their journeys, their impacts, and how they stack up against each other.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

Larry Walker vs Tim Raines
via Stathead

Early Careers and Breakthroughs

Larry Walker: A Late Bloomer with Raw Talent

Larry Walker’s path to Major League Baseball is as fascinating as his career. Growing up in Maple Ridge, British Columbia, he dreamed of being an NHL goalie before baseball captured his heart. The Montreal Expos signed him as an amateur free agent in 1984. Walker made his MLB debut in 1989 and quickly showcased his five-tool prowess: hitting for average and power, combined with exceptional fielding and speed.

By the mid-’90s, playing for the Colorado Rockies, Walker became one of the most feared hitters in the league. His breakout season came in 1997 when he won the National League MVP award with a .366 batting average, 49 home runs, and 130 RBIs. That year, Walker also led the league in slugging percentage (.720) and total bases (409).

Tim Raines: Speed and Consistency

Tim Raines, affectionately known as “Rock,” had a meteoric rise in the MLB. Born in Sanford, Florida, Raines was drafted by the Montreal Expos in the fifth round of the 1977 MLB draft. His debut in 1979 was just a taste of what was to come. By his rookie season in 1981, Raines was already setting records, stealing 71 bases—a rookie record at the time.

Raines’ career was defined by his speed and consistency. He led the NL in stolen bases for four consecutive years from 1981 to 1984, with a personal best of 90 steals in 1983. Beyond his speed, Raines was a formidable hitter, winning the NL batting title in 1986 with a .334 average.

Impact on the Game

Larry Walker: The Powerhouse from the North

Walker’s impact on the game is multifaceted. As a Canadian, he inspired a generation of young players in a country where hockey dominated the sports landscape. His performance in the high-altitude and hitter-friendly Coors Field often sparked debates about the influence of the environment on his stats. However, Walker’s consistent production, both at home and on the road, proved his prowess was not merely a byproduct of the ballpark.

Walker was also a defensive stalwart, earning seven Gold Glove awards, reflecting his elite fielding skills. His all-around abilities made him a complete player and a cornerstone for the teams he played for, particularly the Rockies.

Tim Raines: The Quintessential Leadoff Hitter

Raines brought an electrifying style of play to the game, redefining the role of the leadoff hitter. His ability to get on base, complemented by his extraordinary base-running, made him a constant threat. Raines’ career on-base percentage (OBP) of .385 is a testament to his plate discipline and batting skills.

Beyond his individual stats, Raines’ presence on the field energized his teams. His tenure with the Expos, White Sox, and Yankees not only bolstered their lineups but also provided a standard of excellence and professionalism.

Awards and Accolades

Larry Walker

  • 5× All-Star (1992, 1997–1999, 2001)
  • NL MVP (1997)
  • 7× Gold Glove Award (1992, 1993, 1997–1999, 2001, 2002)
  • 3× Silver Slugger Award (1992, 1997, 1999)
  • 3× NL batting champion (1998, 1999, 2001)
  • NL home run leader (1997)
  • Colorado Rockies No. 33 retired
  • Member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame (Inducted in 2020)
Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
198922MONNL20564748000411513.170.264.170.434278013009/H7
199023MONNL13347841959101183195121749112.241.326.434.76111218285325*9HRoY-7
199124MONNL13753948759141302166414942102.290.349.458.8071272237514293/8H
199225MONNL1435835288515931423931864197.301.353.506.859141267960810*9/HAS,MVP-5,GG,SS
199326MONNL1385824908513024522862978076.265.371.469.841120230860620*9/3HGG
199427MONNL1034523957612744219861554774.322.394.587.9811512328406593/HMVP-11
199528COLNL13156249496151315361011634972.306.381.607.98813130013140513*9/8HMVP-7
199629COLNL83304272587518418581822058.276.342.570.9121161557903289/H
199730COLNL153664568143208464491303387890.366.452.7201.17217840915140414*9/38HDAS,MVP-1,GG,SS
199831COLNL13052445411316546323671446461.363.445.6301.075158286114022*9/H845DAS,MVP-17,GG
199932COLNL127513438108166264371151145752.379.458.7101.1681643111212068*9H/DAS,MVP-10,GG,SS
200033COLNL873723146497217951554640.309.409.506.91511015912903497/HD
200134COLNL1426014971071743533812314582103.350.449.6621.111160329914086*9/HDAS,MVP-24,GG
200235COLNL1365534779516140426104656573.338.421.6021.02315128787046*9/DHMVP-20,GG
200336COLNL143564454861292571679749887.284.422.476.8981212169110114*9H/D
200437TOTNL8231625851771641747604957.298.424.5891.013154152880139/H8D
200437COLNL38138108223593620202523.324.464.6301.09316668240129/HD
200437STLNL441781502942711127402434.280.393.560.95314484640019/H8
200538STLNL10036731566912011552214164.289.384.502.886130158990239H/D8
17 Yrs19888030690713552160471623831311230769131231.313.400.565.9651413904153138765117
162 Game Avg.1626545631101763853110719674100.313.400.565.96514131812111510
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
COL (10 yrs)11704795407689213612974425884812640584659.334.426.6181.0441472520989803771
MON (6 yrs)6742690236636866614716993849835264474.281.357.483.8391281142402772642
STL (2 yrs)144545465951332722679616598.286.387.520.9081342421513024
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Tim Raines

  • 7× All-Star (1981–1987)
  • 3× World Series champion (1996, 1998, 2005)
  • Silver Slugger Award (1986)
  • NL batting champion (1986)
  • 4× NL stolen base leader (1981–1984)
  • Montreal Expos No. 30 retired
  • Member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame (Inducted in 2017)

Statistics Comparison

Batting

  • Larry Walker:
    • Batting Average: .313
    • Hits: 2,160
    • Home Runs: 383
    • RBIs: 1,311
    • OBP: .400
    • SLG: .565
  • Tim Raines:
    • Batting Average: .294
    • Hits: 2,605
    • Home Runs: 170
    • RBIs: 980
    • OBP: .385
    • SLG: .425

Speed and Base Running

  • Larry Walker:
    • Stolen Bases: 230
  • Tim Raines:
    • Stolen Bases: 808

Fielding

  • Larry Walker:
    • Gold Glove Awards: 7
    • Fielding Percentage: .986 (primarily as a right fielder)
  • Tim Raines:
    • Gold Glove Awards: None, but was known as an excellent defensive player with 21 outfield assists in 1983.
    • Fielding Percentage: .987 (primarily as a left fielder)

Career Highlights

Larry Walker

Walker’s crowning achievement was undoubtedly his 1997 MVP season, where he led the league in home runs and total bases, while also stealing 33 bases. His career batting average of .313 and on-base plus slugging (OPS) of .965 cement his legacy as one of the great hitters of his era. Walker’s defensive prowess also earned him seven Gold Gloves, underscoring his value on both sides of the ball.

Tim Raines

Raines’ career is highlighted by his dominance on the basepaths and his ability to get on base. Winning the NL batting title in 1986 with a .334 average and leading the league in on-base percentage the same year showcase his hitting skills. His induction into the Hall of Fame in 2017 affirmed his status as one of the greatest leadoff hitters in MLB history.

Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
197919MONNL6003000002000000000/H
198020MONNL1527205100005063.050.269.050.319-5100100H/47
198121MONNL88363313619513753771114531.304.391.438.82913513772035*7/H4AS,MVP-19,RoY-2
198222MONNL1567316479017932844378167583.277.353.369.72310123962619*74AS
198323MONNL156720615133183328117190149770.298.393.429.822129264122249*7/48H9AS,MVP-5
198424MONNL16071862210619238986075108769.309.393.437.83013827272347*8/4HAS,MVP-11
198525MONNL150665575115184301311417098160.320.405.475.880151273933313*7/HAS,MVP-12
198626MONNL1516645809119435109627097860.334.413.476.88914527662139*7/HAS,MVP-6,SS
198727MONNL13962753012317534818685059052.330.429.526.955149279940326*7AS,MVP-7
198828MONNL1094884296611619712483375344.270.350.431.7821201858204147/H
198929MONNL145618517761482969604199348.286.395.418.813132216830518*7/HMVP-17
199030MONNL1305384576513111596249167043.287.379.392.77111717993088*7/H
199131CHWAL15570960910216320655051158368.268.359.345.7039821075939*7D/H89
199232CHWAL1446445511021622297544568148.294.380.405.78412222350484*7D/H8
199333CHWAL1154864157512716416542176435.306.401.480.88013819973224*7/H
199434CHWAL1014533848010215510521306143.266.365.409.774102157101433*7/H
199535CHWAL1335815028114325412671327052.285.374.422.79611121283333*7DH/9
199636NYYAL5924020145571009331013429.284.383.468.85111494510417/HD
199737NYYAL743182715687202438854134.321.403.454.856124123400607D/H
199838NYYAL1093823215393131547835549.290.395.383.77810712353031D7H
199939OAKAL58164135202950417412617.215.337.341.6787946501217H/D8
200141TOTMLB51109891427811910189.303.413.449.8621244020020H7/D
200141MONNL4797781324810410186.308.433.436.8691263420010H7
200141BALAL412111300150003.273.250.545.795106600010/7HD
200242FLANL98114899173017002219.191.351.258.609662331024H7/D
23 Yrs2502103598872157126054301131709808081461330966.294.385.425.8101233771142423976148
162 Game Avg.16267157410216928711635298663.294.385.425.810123244933510
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
MON (13 yrs)14526256538394716222818296556635106793569.301.391.437.829131235583251639118
CHW (5 yrs)6482873246144069798285027714330359246.283.375.407.78111310013712221923
NYY (3 yrs)24294079315423743318118269130112.299.395.429.8231153401440132
FLA (1 yr)98114899173017002219.191.351.258.609662331024
BAL (1 yr)412111300150003.273.250.545.795106600010
OAK (1 yr)58164135202950417412617.215.337.341.678794650121
NL (14 yrs)15506370547295616392848297563635106815588.300.390.435.825130237886261641122
AL (10 yrs)95239893400615966146317341717340515378.284.377.410.78711213935616233526
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Legacy

Larry Walker

Walker’s legacy is multifaceted. As one of the greatest Canadian baseball players ever, he opened doors for future Canadian athletes in the MLB. His induction into the Hall of Fame in 2020 was a testament to his outstanding career, despite playing in the hitter-friendly Coors Field. Walker’s blend of power, average, and elite defense makes him a complete player whose contributions to the game are celebrated by fans and analysts alike.

Tim Raines

Raines revolutionized the leadoff position with his combination of speed and ability to get on base. His career stolen base percentage remains one of the highest in MLB history, and his consistency over 23 seasons speaks volumes about his skill and dedication. His Hall of Fame induction in 2017 was a long-awaited recognition of a player who excelled in every facet of the game.

Conclusion

Larry Walker and Tim Raines were both exceptional players who brought unique skills to the field. Walker’s powerful bat and stellar defense made him a cornerstone player, while Raines’ speed and on-base ability redefined the leadoff role. Both have left lasting legacies, not just in their statistics, but in how they influenced the game and inspired future generations of players. Their enshrinement in the Baseball Hall of Fame is a fitting tribute to their exceptional careers.