The Gold Glove Argument: Walker vs. Edmonds

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain

Larry Walker and Jim Edmonds might not be instantly thought of as all-time greats, but they have the stats that say they are. To truly appreciate their contributions, let’s dive into their careers through the lens of a casual baseball fan, examining their statistics, awards, and lasting impact.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

Larry Walker vs Jim Edmonds
via Stathead

Early Careers and Breakout Seasons

Larry Walker

Larry Walker, hailing from Maple Ridge, British Columbia, embarked on his MLB journey with the Montreal Expos in 1989. Initially known for his raw athleticism, Walker quickly turned heads with his exceptional skills in hitting, fielding, and base-running.

Walker’s breakout came after he joined the Colorado Rockies in 1995, transitioning from Montreal’s artificial turf to the hitting-friendly Coors Field. His most notable season was in 1997, when he hit an impressive .366 with 49 home runs, 130 RBIs, and 33 stolen bases. This earned him the National League MVP Award and cemented his status as one of the greatest all-around players of his time.

Jim Edmonds

Jim Edmonds, born in Fullerton, California, made his MLB debut with the California Angels in 1993. Known for his jaw-dropping defensive plays and powerful hitting, Edmonds quickly became a fan favorite.

Edmonds’ breakout season came in 1995 when he hit .290 with 33 home runs and 107 RBIs. However, it was his trade to the St. Louis Cardinals in 2000 that truly elevated his career. In his first season with the Cardinals, Edmonds hit .295 with 42 home runs and 108 RBIs, earning his first of four All-Star selections with the team.

Offensive Prowess

Larry Walker’s Stats

  • Batting Average: .313
  • Hits: 2,160
  • Home Runs: 383
  • RBIs: 1,311
  • OPS: .965
  • Stolen Bases: 230

Larry Walker was a hitting machine. His .313 career batting average is a testament to his consistent excellence at the plate. Walker’s ability to combine hitting for average with power, along with his base-stealing prowess, made him a multidimensional threat.

Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
198922MONNL20564748000411513.170.264.170.434278013009/H7
199023MONNL13347841959101183195121749112.241.326.434.76111218285325*9HRoY-7
199124MONNL13753948759141302166414942102.290.349.458.8071272237514293/8H
199225MONNL1435835288515931423931864197.301.353.506.859141267960810*9/HAS,MVP-5,GG,SS
199326MONNL1385824908513024522862978076.265.371.469.841120230860620*9/3HGG
199427MONNL1034523957612744219861554774.322.394.587.9811512328406593/HMVP-11
199528COLNL13156249496151315361011634972.306.381.607.98813130013140513*9/8HMVP-7
199629COLNL83304272587518418581822058.276.342.570.9121161557903289/H
199730COLNL153664568143208464491303387890.366.452.7201.17217840915140414*9/38HDAS,MVP-1,GG,SS
199831COLNL13052445411316546323671446461.363.445.6301.075158286114022*9/H845DAS,MVP-17,GG
199932COLNL127513438108166264371151145752.379.458.7101.1681643111212068*9H/DAS,MVP-10,GG,SS
200033COLNL873723146497217951554640.309.409.506.91511015912903497/HD
200134COLNL1426014971071743533812314582103.350.449.6621.111160329914086*9/HDAS,MVP-24,GG
200235COLNL1365534779516140426104656573.338.421.6021.02315128787046*9/DHMVP-20,GG
200336COLNL143564454861292571679749887.284.422.476.8981212169110114*9H/D
200437TOTNL8231625851771641747604957.298.424.5891.013154152880139/H8D
200437COLNL38138108223593620202523.324.464.6301.09316668240129/HD
200437STLNL441781502942711127402434.280.393.560.95314484640019/H8
200538STLNL10036731566912011552214164.289.384.502.886130158990239H/D8
17 Yrs19888030690713552160471623831311230769131231.313.400.565.9651413904153138765117
162 Game Avg.1626545631101763853110719674100.313.400.565.96514131812111510
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
COL (10 yrs)11704795407689213612974425884812640584659.334.426.6181.0441472520989803771
MON (6 yrs)6742690236636866614716993849835264474.281.357.483.8391281142402772642
STL (2 yrs)144545465951332722679616598.286.387.520.9081342421513024
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Jim Edmonds’ Stats

  • Batting Average: .284
  • Hits: 1,949
  • Home Runs: 393
  • RBIs: 1,199
  • OPS: .903
  • Stolen Bases: 67

Edmonds was a power hitter with nearly 400 home runs to his name. While his .284 batting average isn’t as high as Walker’s, his slugging ability and knack for clutch hits made him a potent offensive force. His .903 OPS underscores his ability to get on base and drive in runs effectively.

Defensive Mastery

Larry Walker

Larry Walker’s defensive skills were nothing short of spectacular. He won seven Gold Glove Awards, showcasing his prowess in the outfield. Walker’s strong arm, quick reflexes, and smart positioning made him a formidable defender, often preventing extra bases and runs.

Jim Edmonds

Jim Edmonds was a defensive wizard in center field, earning eight Gold Glove Awards during his career. His acrobatic catches and fearlessness in the outfield are the stuff of legend. Edmonds’ ability to read the ball off the bat and make seemingly impossible plays made him one of the best defensive players of his era.

Awards and Accolades

Larry Walker

  • NL MVP: 1997
  • All-Star Selections: 5 times (1992, 1997–1999, 2001)
  • Gold Glove Awards: 7 times (1992, 1993, 1997–1999, 2001, 2002)
  • Silver Slugger Awards: 3 times (1992, 1997, 1999)
  • NL Batting Champion: 3 times (1998, 1999, 2001)
  • NL Home Run Leader: 1997
  • Colorado Rockies No. 33 retired
  • Induction into National Baseball Hall of Fame: 2020

Jim Edmonds

  • All-Star Selections: 4 times (1995, 2000, 2003, 2005)
  • World Series Champion: 2006
  • Gold Glove Awards: 8 times (1997, 1998, 2000–2005)
  • Silver Slugger Award: 2004
  • St. Louis Cardinals Hall of Fame
Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
199323CALAL186361515410402216.246.270.344.6146321100019/87H
199424CALAL943222893579131537423072.273.343.377.7208610931113*739/H8RoY-8
199525CALAL141620558120162304331071451130.290.352.536.888129299105154*8/HAS,MVP-14
199626CALAL1144834317313128327664046101.304.375.571.94613724684022*8/HD
199727ANAAL133571502821462702680576080.291.368.500.86812325184055*83/DHGG
199828ANAAL15465959911518442125917557114.307.368.506.874123303161117*8/HGG
199929ANAAL552332043451172523542845.250.339.426.7669587300108/D3H
200030STLNL15264352512915525042108103103167.295.411.583.99414730656183*8/3HAS,MVP-4,GG
200131STLNL15060850095152381301105593136.304.410.564.9741492828411012*8/H3GG
200232STLNL1445764769614831228834386134.311.420.561.981158267980614*8/HMVP-17,GG
200333STLNL1375314478912332239891377127.275.385.6171.002160276114126*8H/D7AS,MVP-27,GG
200434STLNL1536124981021503834211183101150.301.418.6431.061171320450812*8/H3DMVP-5,GG,SS
200535STLNL1425674678812337129895591139.263.385.533.918137249641410*8/HAS,MVP-26,GG
200636STLNL110408350529018019704053101.257.350.471.8221101651100578H/3
200737STLNL11741136539921521253024175.252.325.403.72888147902328H/3
200838TOTNL11140134053801922055225582.235.343.479.822112163821338H
200838SDPNL26103906162016211024.178.265.233.4984121111118/H
200838CHCNL8529825047641721949014558.256.369.568.937135142710228/H
201040TOTNL8627224644682301123202460.276.342.504.846125124210108H9/37
201040MILNL732402173862210820202153.286.350.493.843125107210108H9/3
201040CINNL1332296620330037.207.281.586.8671251700000/H8379
17 Yrs2011798068581251194943725393119967509981729.284.376.527.903132361512249106591
162 Game Avg.16264355210115735232975480139.284.376.527.903132291104157
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
STL (8 yrs)11054356362869010332341124171337246451029.285.393.555.9471432012633164666
ANA (7 yrs)70929512644464768161121214082624274558.290.359.498.8561191316491531522
SDP (1 yr)26103906162016211024.178.265.233.498412111111
CIN (1 yr)1332296620330037.207.281.586.8671251700000
CHC (1 yr)8529825047641721949014558.256.369.568.93713514271022
MIL (1 yr)732402173862210820202153.286.350.493.84312510721010
NL (10 yrs)13025029421478711812761327279141267241171.280.386.546.9321392299733475069
AL (7 yrs)70929512644464768161121214082624274558.290.359.498.8561191316491531522
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Both players have illustrious resumes, but while Walker’s accolades are diverse, covering both offensive and defensive excellence, Edmonds’ awards highlight his defensive brilliance and significant contributions to a championship-winning team.

Memorable Moments and Impact

Larry Walker

Walker’s career is dotted with memorable moments, but perhaps none more iconic than his 1997 season. That year, he became the only player in MLB history to post a .700 slugging percentage and steal 30 bases in the same season. His combination of power, speed, and defensive skill made him a true five-tool player.

Walker also had a significant impact on Canadian baseball. As one of the greatest Canadian-born players, his success helped increase the sport’s popularity in Canada and inspired countless young athletes.

Jim Edmonds

Edmonds’ career is filled with jaw-dropping moments, especially his incredible catches in the outfield. One of his most famous plays came in 1997, when he made an over-the-shoulder, diving catch that is still considered one of the greatest defensive plays in baseball history.

His 2004 postseason performance, including a walk-off home run in Game 6 of the NLCS, is another hallmark of his career. Edmonds’ ability to deliver in clutch moments endeared him to Cardinals fans and solidified his legacy as a postseason hero.

Conclusion

Larry Walker and Jim Edmonds were both remarkable players who left a lasting impact on the game of baseball. Walker’s blend of hitting, speed, and defense made him one of the most well-rounded players of his era, while Edmonds’ defensive genius and power-hitting made him a standout performer in crucial moments.