Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Michael Griffin
There was a time when baseball had more characters than a whole network’s programming lineup. Some wacky players made teammates, opponents, and fans all roar — whether with laughter or utter confusion. Then the game became more corporate, and many players walk a line between being a personality and an athlete. Here are 12 players that would give Rob Manfred and other MLB suits fits if they were active today:
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Bill “Spaceman” Lee’s Cosmic Dugout Rambles
While Bill Lee threw curveballs, he was an oddball, to put it mildly. Known for his irreverent wit, “Spaceman” would riff on politics, space, and vegetarianism between starts, making even the postgame interviews feel like a trip through the looking glass. Try picturing a team PR manager letting a guy compare mound visits to UFO sightings. They’d be shutting down interviews in record time.
Mark “The Bird” Fidrych Talking to the Ball
With his mop of curls and childlike wonder, Mark Fidrych would chat with the ball, pat the mound like it was a pet, and wave to fans mid-inning. He couldn’t do that today just for the fact that he would run into pitch clock issues on every single pitch.
Tug McGraw’s “Ya Gotta Believe” Rallying Cries
Tug McGraw could turn a dugout funeral into a pep rally. With his infectious grin and signature slogan, he made hope contagious—even when the standings said otherwise. Today, they would be calling it “toxic positivity.”
Ty Cobb’s Spikes-High Slide into Infamy
More outlaw than athlete, Ty Cobb played baseball with a mean streak as sharp as his cleats. Sliding spikes-high and snarling at opponents, Cobb’s aggression would earn him multiple suspensions in the same season in today’s game. He’d have to take anger management classes.
Dock Ellis’ Psychedelic No-Hitter
Dock Ellis claimed he pitched a no-hitter on LSD, seeing tracers instead of seams and somehow baffling every batter. Yeah, that wouldn’t happen today.
Turk Wendell’s Toothbrush Rituals and Necklace of Fangs
Turk Wendell was part pitcher, part shaman: he brushed his teeth between innings, leapt over foul lines, and wore a necklace strung with animal teeth. Teammates today would look at him like he had four heads.
Fritz Peterson & Mike Kekich’s Unbelievable Yankee Wife Swap
There was a TV show in the 2000s called Wife Swap, where wives would swap families for a set period. In 1973, Yankees pitchers Fritz Peterson and Mike Kekich took it even further — they swapped wives, kids, and even dogs. It was a tabloid twist that would melt social media today.
Earl Weaver’s Tobacco-Fueled Umpire Tirades
There are some good umpire/manager arguments today. They still aren’t at the level of Earl Weaver’s umpire tirades. They were legendary—he’d kick dirt, wave his hat, and invent new cuss words with every ejection.
Al Hrabosky’s Fu Manchu and Psycho Mound Rituals
“The Mad Hungarian” would glare, stomp, and psych himself up behind the mound, his Fu Manchu bristling with intensity. Al Hrabosky’s pre-pitch rituals were part theater, part intimidation. It was so over the top that today’s management would tell him to tone it down.
Billy Martin’s Bench-Clearing Brawls and Barroom Antics
Billy Martin brought as much drama off the field as on it—brawling with players, feuding with bosses, and never backing down from a fight. He’d be in the HR office on a regular basis today.
Rube Waddell Chasing Fire Trucks and Striking Out the World
Baseball’s original eccentric, Rube Waddell would leave mid-game to chase fire trucks. Can you imagine Aroldis Chapman doing that today? “OK, folks, we’re going to have to wait while Chapman finds the fire truck ….”
Bill Veeck’s Exploding Scoreboards and Short-Statured Batters
Bill Veeck was baseball’s master showman—he once sent a little person to bat, staged exploding scoreboards, and filled stadiums with wild stunts. He’d laugh at the Phillie Phanatic today and call him too tame. Modern MLB management would pull out its hair at Veeck’s antics.