Dewey and the Hawk: Two Right Fielders Who Never Get Enough Credit

Defensive Excellence

Dwight Evans was a defensive stalwart, winning eight Gold Glove Awards as a right fielder. His arm was legendary, and he regularly gunned down baserunners trying to advance. Evans’ defensive skills made him a cornerstone for the Red Sox for nearly two decades.

Andre Dawson, while starting his career as a center fielder, transitioned to right field due to knee issues. Despite this, he won eight Gold Glove Awards, showcasing his defensive capabilities. His early years were marked by incredible defensive plays and strong arm strength, similar to Evans.

Awards and Accolades

Both Evans and Dawson accumulated numerous awards and honors throughout their careers. Here’s a look at their accolades side by side:

Dwight Evans:

• All-Star Appearances: 3 (1978, 1981, 1987)
• Gold Glove Awards: 8 (1976, 1978, 1979, 1981–1985)
• Silver Slugger Awards: 2 (1981, 1987)
• AL Home Run Leader: 1981
• Boston Red Sox Hall of Fame Inductee

Andre Dawson:

• All-Star Appearances: 8 (1981–1983, 1987–1991)
• Gold Glove Awards: 8 (1980–1985, 1987, 1988)
• Silver Slugger Awards: 4 (1980, 1981, 1983, 1987)
• NL Rookie of the Year: 1977
• NL MVP: 1987
• NL Home Run Leader: 1987
• NL RBI Leader: 1987
• Hall of Fame Induction: 2010

Postseason Performance

Dwight Evans played crucial roles in the postseason for the Red Sox, including the memorable 1975 and 1986 World Series. In the 1975 World Series, Evans hit .292 with a home run and five RBIs. His defensive prowess was also on display, particularly his game-saving catch in Game 6 that helped the Red Sox force a Game 7.

Andre Dawson, despite his individual greatness, had limited postseason success. His most notable postseason run came with the Chicago Cubs in 1989 when they won the NL East title. However, Dawson struggled in the NLCS, batting only .105 as the Cubs fell to the San Francisco Giants.

Impact on the Game

Dwight Evans is often considered one of the most underrated players of his era. His combination of offensive and defensive skills made him a valuable player for the Red Sox. Evans’ influence extended beyond his playing days as he took on roles as a hitting coach and player development consultant, continuing to impact the game.

Andre Dawson had a significant impact on the game, not just with his on-field performance but also with his leadership and work ethic. Known for his meticulous preparation and study of the game, Dawson set an example for younger players. His post-career involvement in charitable and community activities further cemented his legacy as not just a great player, but a great person.

Legacy and Hall of Fame Consideration

Dwight Evans has long been considered an overlooked candidate for the Hall of Fame. Despite his impressive stats and contributions to the game, he never received the needed 75% of votes during his eligibility period. However, many baseball historians and analysts argue that Evans’ all-around game merits Hall of Fame induction.

Andre Dawson was elected to the Hall of Fame in 2010, his ninth year of eligibility. Dawson’s election was a recognition of his outstanding career and his impact on the game. Despite some controversy over which team’s cap he would wear on his Hall of Fame plaque, Dawson’s place in Cooperstown is undisputed.

Conclusion

Both Dwight Evans and Andre Dawson brought unique skills and talents to Major League Baseball. Evans, with his combination of offensive power and defensive brilliance, was a cornerstone for the Red Sox over nearly two decades. Dawson, with his blend of power, speed, and leadership, was a force to be reckoned with in both the National and American Leagues.

Both players exemplify the excellence that makes baseball the cherished sport it is. As fans, we can appreciate the contributions of both these legends and celebrate their lasting legacies in the annals of baseball history.