A Superstar Showdown: Ichiro Suzuki vs. Tim Raines

Jake Cain

Jake Cain

Published:

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 26th, 2024 by Jake Cain

Ichiro Suzuki and Tim Raines are two players who dazzled fans whenever they took the field. It’s easy to get lost in the sheer volume of accolades, records, and statistics, as both players have left indelible marks on the game of baseball. Let’s dive into their storied careers and see how these legends stack up against each other.

Ichiro Suzuki vs Tim Raines
via Stathead

Early Careers and Debuts

Ichiro Suzuki

Ichiro Suzuki’s journey to Major League Baseball began in the Nippon Professional Baseball league in Japan. Debuting at just 18 years old for the Orix BlueWave, Ichiro soon became a sensation, amassing 1,278 hits with a .353 batting average over nine seasons in Japan. His unique “pendulum” swing and unparalleled contact hitting made him a household name.

In 2001, Ichiro made history by becoming the first Japanese-born position player to be posted and signed to an MLB club, starting with the Seattle Mariners. He didn’t just enter the league; he exploded onto the scene, capturing both the American League Rookie of the Year and AL MVP awards in his debut season.

Tim Raines

Tim Raines, affectionately known as “Rock,” was drafted by the Montreal Expos in the fifth round of the 1977 MLB draft. Raines debuted in the big leagues in 1979, but it was his strike-interrupted rookie season in 1981 that set the stage for his career. He hit .304 and set a then-record with 71 stolen bases, earning him second place in the NL Rookie of the Year voting.

Raines’ aggressive baserunning and remarkable speed made him a fan favorite. Despite struggling with substance abuse issues early in his career, Raines overcame these challenges to become one of the most consistent and dynamic players of the 1980s.

Consistency and Longevity

Ichiro Suzuki’s Consistency

Ichiro’s career in MLB spanned 19 seasons, during which he accumulated 3,089 hits and a .311 batting average. Known for his durability and consistency, Ichiro recorded ten consecutive 200-hit seasons—a feat unmatched in MLB history. His career was highlighted by a single-season record of 262 hits in 2004.

Ichiro’s ability to maintain a high level of performance well into his 40s was exceptional. Even in his final MLB season at age 45, Ichiro continued to be a productive player.

Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
200127SEAAL15773869212724234886956143053.350.381.457.838126316384410*9/DHAS,MVP-1,RoY-1,GG,SS
200228SEAAL15772864711120827885131156862.321.388.425.813120275853527*9/D8HAS,MVP-17,GG
200329SEAAL15972567911121229813623483669.312.352.436.78811229636317*9/HAS,MVP-23,GG
200430SEAAL16176270410126224586036114963.372.414.455.869130320642319*9/DHAS,MVP-7,GG
200531SEAAL162739679111206211215683384866.303.350.436.786113296542623*9/DHAS,GG
200632SEAAL1617526951102242099494524971.322.370.416.786106289251216*98/DHAS,MVP-15,GG
200733SEAAL1617366781112382276683784977.351.396.431.827122292734213*8/DAS,MVP-8,GG,SS
200834SEAAL1627496861032132076424345165.310.361.386.747102265853412*98/DHAS,MVP-20,GG
200935SEAAL1466786398822531411462693271.352.386.465.851129297142115*9/DAS,MVP-9,GG,SS
201036SEAAL162732680742143036434294586.315.359.394.754113268333113*9/DAS,MVP-17,GG
201137SEAAL161721677801842235474073969.272.310.335.645862271101413*9D
201238TOTAL162663629771782869552972261.283.307.390.69693245122555*97/8HD
201238SEAAL95423402491051554281521740.261.288.353.642821421000449/D
201238NYYAL672402272873131527145521.322.340.454.7941131032251197/8HD
201339NYYAL150555520571361537352042663.262.297.342.6397717861624*9H8/7D
201440NYYAL143385359421021321221532168.284.324.340.6648912231221*9H/78D
201541MIANL1534383984591561211153151.229.282.279.5615811180541*9H7/8D1
201642MIANL14336532748951551221023042.291.354.376.73010212343321H987/D
201743MIANL136215196195060320111735.255.318.332.649796521101*H98/7D
201844SEAAL1547445900000037.205.255.205.460339000007/DH9
201945SEAAL2650000000011.000.167.000.167-47000000/9
19 Yrs265310734993414203089362961177805091176471080.311.355.402.757107399492555048181
162 Game Avg.162655607871892267483174066.311.355.402.757107244633311
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
SEA (14 yrs)18618536790711812542295799963343897517800.321.365.416.781113329267472837172
NYY (3 yrs)360118011061273114161384491252152.281.314.364.679884031141356
MIA (3 yrs)4321018921112236261156322878128.256.315.325.64078299144963
AL (16 yrs)2221971690131308285333685112717487109569952.317.359.410.769110369578514142178
NL (3 yrs)4321018921112236261156322878128.256.315.325.64078299144963
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/29/2024.

Tim Raines’ Longevity

Raines played in MLB for 23 seasons, compiling 2,605 hits and a .294 batting average. His career spanned four decades, a testament to his longevity and adaptability. Raines was known for his exceptional on-base percentage (.385) and stolen bases (808), placing him among the all-time leaders in both categories.

Raines’ ability to contribute offensively and defensively well into his late 30s and early 40s made him a valuable asset to every team he played for.

Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
197919MONNL6003000002000000000/H
198020MONNL1527205100005063.050.269.050.319-5100100H/47
198121MONNL88363313619513753771114531.304.391.438.82913513772035*7/H4AS,MVP-19,RoY-2
198222MONNL1567316479017932844378167583.277.353.369.72310123962619*74AS
198323MONNL156720615133183328117190149770.298.393.429.822129264122249*7/48H9AS,MVP-5
198424MONNL16071862210619238986075108769.309.393.437.83013827272347*8/4HAS,MVP-11
198525MONNL150665575115184301311417098160.320.405.475.880151273933313*7/HAS,MVP-12
198626MONNL1516645809119435109627097860.334.413.476.88914527662139*7/HAS,MVP-6,SS
198727MONNL13962753012317534818685059052.330.429.526.955149279940326*7AS,MVP-7
198828MONNL1094884296611619712483375344.270.350.431.7821201858204147/H
198929MONNL145618517761482969604199348.286.395.418.813132216830518*7/HMVP-17
199030MONNL1305384576513111596249167043.287.379.392.77111717993088*7/H
199131CHWAL15570960910216320655051158368.268.359.345.7039821075939*7D/H89
199232CHWAL1446445511021622297544568148.294.380.405.78412222350484*7D/H8
199333CHWAL1154864157512716416542176435.306.401.480.88013819973224*7/H
199434CHWAL1014533848010215510521306143.266.365.409.774102157101433*7/H
199535CHWAL1335815028114325412671327052.285.374.422.79611121283333*7DH/9
199636NYYAL5924020145571009331013429.284.383.468.85111494510417/HD
199737NYYAL743182715687202438854134.321.403.454.856124123400607D/H
199838NYYAL1093823215393131547835549.290.395.383.77810712353031D7H
199939OAKAL58164135202950417412617.215.337.341.6787946501217H/D8
200141TOTMLB51109891427811910189.303.413.449.8621244020020H7/D
200141MONNL4797781324810410186.308.433.436.8691263420010H7
200141BALAL412111300150003.273.250.545.795106600010/7HD
200242FLANL98114899173017002219.191.351.258.609662331024H7/D
23 Yrs2502103598872157126054301131709808081461330966.294.385.425.8101233771142423976148
162 Game Avg.16267157410216928711635298663.294.385.425.810123244933510
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
MON (13 yrs)14526256538394716222818296556635106793569.301.391.437.829131235583251639118
CHW (5 yrs)6482873246144069798285027714330359246.283.375.407.78111310013712221923
NYY (3 yrs)24294079315423743318118269130112.299.395.429.8231153401440132
FLA (1 yr)98114899173017002219.191.351.258.609662331024
BAL (1 yr)412111300150003.273.250.545.795106600010
OAK (1 yr)58164135202950417412617.215.337.341.678794650121
NL (14 yrs)15506370547295616392848297563635106815588.300.390.435.825130237886261641122
AL (10 yrs)95239893400615966146317341717340515378.284.377.410.78711213935616233526
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/29/2024.

Playing Style and Impact

Ichiro Suzuki’s Impact

Ichiro was a pure contact hitter and a defensive wizard. His uncanny ability to place the ball and get on base, combined with his speed, made him a perennial threat. Ichiro’s defensive skills were equally impressive, earning him ten Gold Glove Awards. His arm strength and accuracy in right field turned many hits into outs, creating a lasting impact on the game.

Tim Raines’ Playing Style

Raines was a switch-hitter with a unique blend of speed and power. He excelled at getting on base and creating scoring opportunities with his aggressive baserunning. Raines led the NL in stolen bases for four consecutive seasons (1981-1984) and scored over 1,500 runs in his career. Defensively, Raines was reliable, with a career fielding percentage of .987.

Awards and Accolades

Ichiro Suzuki

  • NPB (Japan):
    • 7× All-Star (1994–2000)
    • Japan Series champion (1996)
    • 3× Pacific League MVP (1994–1996)
    • 7× Golden Glove Award (1994–2000)
    • 7× Best Nine Award (1994–2000)
    • 7× Pacific League batting champion (1994–2000)
  • MLB:
    • AL MVP (2001)
    • AL Rookie of the Year (2001)
    • 10× All-Star (2001–2010)
    • 10× Gold Glove Award (2001–2010)
    • 3× Silver Slugger Award (2001, 2007, 2009)
    • 2× AL batting champion (2001, 2004)
    • AL stolen base leader (2001)
    • MLB single-season hits record (262 in 2004)
    • Seattle Mariners Hall of Fame

Tim Raines

  • MLB:
    • 7× All-Star (1981–1987)
    • 3× World Series champion (1996, 1998, 2005)
    • Silver Slugger Award (1986)
    • NL batting champion (1986)
    • 4× NL stolen base leader (1981–1984)
    • Montreal Expos No. 30 retired
    • National Baseball Hall of Fame (inducted in 2017)

Career Highlights

Ichiro Suzuki

  • Total Hits: 4,367 combined (NPB and MLB)
  • Batting Average: .311 (MLB), .353 (NPB)
  • Home Runs: 117 (MLB), 118 (NPB)
  • Stolen Bases: 509 (MLB), 199 (NPB)
  • Record Holder: Most hits in a single MLB season (262 in 2004)

Tim Raines

  • Total Hits: 2,605
  • Batting Average: .294
  • Home Runs: 170
  • Stolen Bases: 808
  • Runs Scored: 1,571
  • Record Holder: Career stolen base percentage leader at the time of his retirement (84.7%)

Conclusion

Both Ichiro Suzuki and Tim Raines enjoyed tremendous success on the baseball field. Ichiro’s unparalleled consistency and defensive prowess make him one of the greatest contact hitters of all time, while Tim Raines’ speed, on-base skills, and longevity solidify his place among the elite leadoff hitters and baserunners in MLB history.

In the end, comparing these two legends illuminates the diverse ways greatness can manifest in baseball, offering fans a rich tapestry of feats and memories to celebrate.