The ’90s Legends: Larry Walker vs. Gary Sheffield

Published: June 9, 2024

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 9th, 2024 by Jake Cain

Larry Walker and Gary Sheffield are two of the best to ever step onto a baseball field. Larry Walker, hailing from Canada, is known for his five-tool prowess, while Gary Sheffield is celebrated for his fearsome batting swing and versatility. Let’s dive into their careers and see what made each of them an icon.

Larry Walker vs Gary Sheffield — via Statehead

Early Years: From Dreams to the Majors

Larry Walker: The Accidental Ballplayer

Larry Walker’s path to baseball was anything but typical. Born in Maple Ridge, British Columbia, Walker initially dreamt of a career as an NHL goalie. It wasn’t until scouts from the Montreal Expos spotted his raw talent that he considered a future in baseball. Walker made his MLB debut in 1989 and quickly became known for his powerful hitting and exceptional defense. His career spanned teams like the Montreal Expos, Colorado Rockies, and St. Louis Cardinals.

Gary Sheffield: The Natural Talent

Gary Sheffield’s journey began in Tampa, Florida, where he grew up playing baseball with his uncle, Dwight Gooden, a future MLB star. Sheffield was a force to be reckoned with from a young age, showing remarkable skill and a fierce competitive spirit. Drafted by the Milwaukee Brewers in 1986, Sheffield made his MLB debut in 1988. Over his career, he played for eight different teams, including the San Diego Padres, Florida Marlins, and New York Yankees, showcasing his versatility and power-hitting capabilities.

Offensive Mastery: The Art of Hitting

Larry Walker: The Complete Hitter

Walker’s offensive stats are the stuff of legends. Over his 17-year career, he maintained a .313 batting average, collected 2,160 hits, and smashed 383 home runs. His ability to hit for both power and average is evident in his three National League batting titles and his 1997 MVP award, where he hit .366 with 49 home runs. Walker’s career slugging percentage of .565 ranks 12th all-time, a testament to his extraordinary hitting skills.

Gary Sheffield: The Fearsome Swing

Sheffield was a menace in the batter’s box, wielding a swing that combined speed with precision. Over 22 seasons, he posted a .292 batting average, amassed 2,689 hits, and belted 509 home runs. Known for his selective eye and power, Sheffield had eight seasons with at least 30 home runs and drew 1,475 walks, placing him among the all-time leaders. His 1992 NL batting title, where he hit .330, and his five Silver Slugger Awards highlight his offensive prowess.

Defensive Skills: More Than Just Bats

Larry Walker: A Defensive Maestro

Walker’s defensive brilliance earned him seven Gold Glove Awards. His arm strength and accuracy made him a formidable presence in the outfield, often deterring baserunners from taking extra bases. Walker’s advanced metrics, including 94 defensive runs saved, place him among the top right fielders in history. His understanding of the game and ability to read plays set him apart as one of the best defensive outfielders of his time.

Standard Batting
Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
1989	22	MON	NL	20	56	47	4	8	0	0	0	4	1	1	5	13	.170	.264	.170	.434	27	8	0	1	3	0	0	9/H7
1990	23	MON	NL	133	478	419	59	101	18	3	19	51	21	7	49	112	.241	.326	.434	.761	112	182	8	5	3	2	5	*9H	RoY-7
1991	24	MON	NL	137	539	487	59	141	30	2	16	64	14	9	42	102	.290	.349	.458	.807	127	223	7	5	1	4	2	93/8H
1992	25	MON	NL	143	583	528	85	159	31	4	23	93	18	6	41	97	.301	.353	.506	.859	141	267	9	6	0	8	10	*9/H	AS,MVP-5,GG,SS
1993	26	MON	NL	138	582	490	85	130	24	5	22	86	29	7	80	76	.265	.371	.469	.841	120	230	8	6	0	6	20	*9/3H	GG
1994	27	MON	NL	103	452	395	76	127	44	2	19	86	15	5	47	74	.322	.394	.587	.981	151	232	8	4	0	6	5	93/H	MVP-11
1995	28	COL	NL	131	562	494	96	151	31	5	36	101	16	3	49	72	.306	.381	.607	.988	131	300	13	14	0	5	13	*9/8H	MVP-7
1996	29	COL	NL	83	304	272	58	75	18	4	18	58	18	2	20	58	.276	.342	.570	.912	116	155	7	9	0	3	2	89/H
1997	30	COL	NL	153	664	568	143	208	46	4	49	130	33	8	78	90	.366	.452	*.720*	*1.172*	178	*409*	15	14	0	4	14	*9/38HD	AS,MVP-1,GG,SS
1998	31	COL	NL	130	524	454	113	165	46	3	23	67	14	4	64	61	*.363*	.445	.630	1.075	158	286	11	4	0	2	2	*9/H845D	AS,MVP-17,GG
1999	32	COL	NL	127	513	438	108	166	26	4	37	115	11	4	57	52	*.379*	*.458*	*.710*	*1.168*	164	311	12	12	0	6	8	*9H/D	AS,MVP-10,GG,SS
2000	33	COL	NL	87	372	314	64	97	21	7	9	51	5	5	46	40	.309	.409	.506	.915	110	159	12	9	0	3	4	97/HD
2001	34	COL	NL	142	601	497	107	174	35	3	38	123	14	5	82	103	*.350*	.449	.662	1.111	160	329	9	14	0	8	6	*9/HD	AS,MVP-24,GG
2002	35	COL	NL	136	553	477	95	161	40	4	26	104	6	5	65	73	.338	.421	.602	1.023	151	287	8	7	0	4	6	*9/DH	MVP-20,GG
2003	36	COL	NL	143	564	454	86	129	25	7	16	79	7	4	98	87	.284	.422	.476	.898	121	216	9	11	0	1	14	*9H/D
2004	37	TOT	NL	82	316	258	51	77	16	4	17	47	6	0	49	57	.298	.424	.589	1.013	154	152	8	8	0	1	3	9/H8D
2004	37	COL	NL	38	138	108	22	35	9	3	6	20	2	0	25	23	.324	.464	.630	1.093	166	68	2	4	0	1	2	9/HD
2004	37	STL	NL	44	178	150	29	42	7	1	11	27	4	0	24	34	.280	.393	.560	.953	144	84	6	4	0	0	1	9/H8
2005	38	STL	NL	100	367	315	66	91	20	1	15	52	2	1	41	64	.289	.384	.502	.886	130	158	9	9	0	2	3	9H/D8
17 Yrs				1988	8030	6907	1355	2160	471	62	383	1311	230	76	913	1231	.313	.400	.565	.965	141	3904	153	138	7	65	117
162 Game Avg.				162	654	563	110	176	38	5	31	107	19	6	74	100	.313	.400	.565	.965	141	318	12	11	1	5	10
				G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
COL (10 yrs)				1170	4795	4076	892	1361	297	44	258	848	126	40	584	659	.334	.426	.618	1.044	147	2520	98	98	0	37	71
MON (6 yrs)				674	2690	2366	368	666	147	16	99	384	98	35	264	474	.281	.357	.483	.839	128	1142	40	27	7	26	42
STL (2 yrs)				144	545	465	95	133	27	2	26	79	6	1	65	98	.286	.387	.520	.908	134	242	15	13	0	2	4

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Gary Sheffield: The Versatile Defender

Sheffield’s defensive career was marked by versatility. He played right field, left field, third base, shortstop, and even a few games at first base. While not known for his defensive prowess like Walker, Sheffield held his own, particularly in right field, where he spent most of his career. His ability to adapt to multiple positions added value to any team he played for, showcasing his athleticism and game sense.

Awards and Accolades

Larry Walker’s Trophy Case

NL MVP: 1997
5× All-Star: 1992, 1997-1999, 2001
7× Gold Glove Award: 1992, 1993, 1997-1999, 2001, 2002
3× Silver Slugger Award: 1992, 1997, 1999
3× NL Batting Champion: 1998, 1999, 2001
NL Home Run Leader: 1997
Colorado Rockies No. 33 Retired
Inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame: 2020

Gary Sheffield’s Trophy Shelf

World Series Champion: 1997
9× All-Star: 1992, 1993, 1996, 1998-2000, 2003-2005
5× Silver Slugger Award: 1992, 1996, 2003-2005
NL Batting Champion: 1992

Impact on the Game

Larry Walker: Boosting Canadian Baseball

Walker’s success significantly raised the profile of baseball in Canada. As one of the greatest Canadian players, his journey inspired countless young athletes in a nation where hockey reigns supreme. Walker’s blend of offensive and defensive skills made him a role model and a benchmark for Canadian baseball talent.

Gary Sheffield: The Ultimate Competitor

Sheffield’s impact on the game goes beyond his impressive stats. Known for his fiery personality and competitive nature, Sheffield brought intensity to every game. His willingness to speak his mind and demand respect and fair treatment influenced how players approached contract negotiations and their roles within teams.

Standard Batting
Year	Age	Tm	Lg	G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
1988	19	MIL	AL	24	89	80	12	19	1	0	4	12	3	1	7	7	.238	.295	.400	.695	93	32	5	0	1	1	0	6
1989	20	MIL	AL	95	405	368	34	91	18	0	5	32	10	6	27	33	.247	.303	.337	.640	82	124	4	4	3	3	0	65/D
1990	21	MIL	AL	125	547	487	67	143	30	1	10	67	25	10	44	41	.294	.350	.421	.771	116	205	11	3	4	9	1	*5
1991	22	MIL	AL	50	203	175	25	34	12	2	2	22	5	5	19	15	.194	.277	.320	.597	67	56	3	3	1	5	1	5/DH
1992	23	SDP	NL	146	618	557	87	184	34	3	33	100	5	6	48	40	.330	.385	.580	.965	168	*323*	19	6	0	7	5	*5/H	AS,MVP-3,SS
1993	24	TOT	NL	140	557	494	67	145	20	5	20	73	17	5	47	64	.294	.361	.476	.837	120	235	11	9	0	7	6	*5/H	AS
1993	24	SDP	NL	68	282	258	34	76	12	2	10	36	5	1	18	30	.295	.344	.473	.817	116	122	9	3	0	3	0	5/H
1993	24	FLA	NL	72	275	236	33	69	8	3	10	37	12	4	29	34	.292	.378	.479	.857	125	113	2	6	0	4	6	5/H
1994	25	FLA	NL	87	384	322	61	89	16	1	27	78	12	6	51	50	.276	.380	.584	.964	145	188	10	6	0	5	11	*9/H
1995	26	FLA	NL	63	274	213	46	69	8	0	16	46	19	4	55	45	.324	.467	.587	1.054	177	125	3	4	0	2	8	9/7H
1996	27	FLA	NL	161	677	519	118	163	33	1	42	120	16	9	142	66	.314	.465	.624	1.090	189	324	16	10	0	6	19	*9/H	AS,MVP-6,SS
1997	28	FLA	NL	135	582	444	86	111	22	1	21	71	11	7	121	79	.250	.424	.446	.870	134	198	7	15	0	2	11	*9/HD
1998	29	TOT	NL	130	549	437	73	132	27	2	22	85	22	7	95	46	.302	.428	.524	.952	155	229	7	8	0	9	12	*9/H	AS
1998	29	FLA	NL	40	166	136	21	37	11	1	6	28	4	2	26	16	.272	.392	.500	.892	139	68	3	2	0	2	1	9/H
1998	29	LAD	NL	90	383	301	52	95	16	1	16	57	18	5	69	30	.316	.444	.535	.979	162	161	4	6	0	7	11	9/H
1999	30	LAD	NL	152	663	549	103	165	20	0	34	101	11	5	101	64	.301	.407	.523	.930	140	287	10	4	0	9	4	*7/HD	AS
2000	31	LAD	NL	141	612	501	105	163	24	3	43	109	4	6	101	71	.325	.438	.643	1.081	176	322	13	4	0	6	7	*7/D	AS,MVP-9
2001	32	LAD	NL	143	618	515	98	160	28	2	36	100	10	4	94	67	.311	.417	.583	1.000	164	300	12	4	0	5	13	*7/D9
2002	33	ATL	NL	135	579	492	82	151	26	0	25	84	12	2	72	53	.307	.404	.512	.916	138	252	16	11	0	4	2	*9/DH	MVP-17
2003	34	ATL	NL	155	678	576	126	190	37	2	39	132	18	4	86	55	.330	.419	.604	1.023	162	348	16	8	0	8	6	*9/H	AS,MVP-3,SS
2004	35	NYY	AL	154	684	573	117	166	30	1	36	121	5	6	92	83	.290	.393	.534	.927	141	306	16	11	0	8	7	*9D/5	AS,MVP-2,SS
2005	36	NYY	AL	154	675	584	104	170	27	0	34	123	10	2	78	76	.291	.379	.512	.891	137	299	11	8	0	5	7	*9D/H	AS,MVP-8,SS
2006	37	NYY	AL	39	166	151	22	45	5	0	6	25	5	1	13	16	.298	.355	.450	.806	107	68	6	1	0	1	2	9/3DH
2007	38	DET	AL	133	593	494	107	131	20	1	25	75	22	5	84	71	.265	.378	.462	.839	119	228	10	9	0	6	2	*D/79H
2008	39	DET	AL	114	482	418	52	94	16	0	19	57	9	2	58	83	.225	.326	.400	.725	90	167	19	5	0	1	3	D/7H
2009	40	NYM	NL	100	312	268	44	74	13	2	10	43	2	1	40	46	.276	.372	.451	.823	119	121	10	2	0	2	3	7H9/D
22 Yrs				2576	10947	9217	1636	2689	467	27	509	1676	253	104	1475	1171	.292	.393	.514	.907	140	4737	235	135	9	111	130
162 Game Avg.				162	688	580	103	169	29	2	32	105	16	7	93	74	.292	.393	.514	.907	140	298	15	8	1	7	8
				G	PA	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	CS	BB	SO	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS	OPS+	TB	GDP	HBP	SH	SF	IBB	Pos	Awards
FLA (6 yrs)				558	2358	1870	365	538	98	7	122	380	74	32	424	290	.288	.426	.543	.970	156	1016	41	43	0	21	56
LAD (4 yrs)				526	2276	1866	358	583	88	6	129	367	43	20	365	232	.312	.424	.573	.998	160	1070	39	18	0	27	35
MIL (4 yrs)				294	1244	1110	138	287	61	3	21	133	43	22	97	96	.259	.319	.376	.695	95	417	23	10	9	18	2
NYY (3 yrs)				347	1525	1308	243	381	62	1	76	269	20	9	183	175	.291	.383	.515	.897	135	673	33	20	0	14	16
ATL (2 yrs)				290	1257	1068	208	341	63	2	64	216	30	6	158	108	.319	.412	.562	.974	151	600	32	19	0	12	8
SDP (2 yrs)				214	900	815	121	260	46	5	43	136	10	7	66	70	.319	.372	.546	.918	151	445	28	9	0	10	5
DET (2 yrs)				247	1075	912	159	225	36	1	44	132	31	7	142	154	.247	.354	.433	.788	106	395	29	14	0	7	5
NYM (1 yr)				100	312	268	44	74	13	2	10	43	2	1	40	46	.276	.372	.451	.823	119	121	10	2	0	2	3

NL (13 yrs)				1688	7103	5887	1096	1796	308	22	368	1142	159	66	1053	746	.305	.414	.552	.966	154	3252	150	91	0	72	107
AL (9 yrs)				888	3844	3330	540	893	159	5	141	534	94	38	422	425	.268	.354	.446	.800	114	1485	85	44	9	39	23

Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 5/28/2024.

Conclusion: Two Legends, One Love for Baseball

You might think that since Larry Walker is in the Hall of Fame his numbers would be vastly superior to Gary Sheffield’s. But as we see here that’s not the case. Walker’s blend of offense and defense made him a five-tool legend, while Sheffield’s powerful swing and versatility made him one of the most feared hitters in baseball history. Both players have left lasting legacies and earned their places among baseball’s elite.