Meet the Underrated Stars Nobody Argued About Enough

Share With Other Baseball Fans:

Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain

Not every player can be defined as a superstar. But that doesn’t mean they didn’t enjoy long and successful careers. Two players that fall into that category are Reggie Sanders and Lance Berkman. Both players brought something special to the game, with impressive stats, memorable moments, and plenty to compare. Join us as we dive into the careers of these All-Star outfielders and break down their stats, awards and impact on the game.

Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.

Reggie Sanders vs Lance Berkman
via Stathead

Early Careers and Breakout Seasons

Reggie Sanders: The Versatile Journeyman

Reggie Sanders began his MLB career with the Cincinnati Reds, debuting on August 22, 1991. Drafted in the seventh round of the 1987 Amateur Draft, Sanders took a few seasons to find his footing. By the 1995 season, he had his breakout year, earning an All-Star selection and proving himself as a reliable power hitter with the ability to steal bases. His versatility allowed him to play across the outfield, making him a valuable asset for numerous teams over his 17-year career.

Lance Berkman: The Big Puma Roars

Lance Berkman made his MLB debut for the Houston Astros on July 16, 1999. Drafted in the first round of the 1997 MLB Draft, Berkman quickly established himself as a potent switch-hitter. Known for his power and on-base ability, Berkman earned the nickname “Big Puma” for his surprising agility despite his size. By 2001, not only was Berkman a regular All-Star, but he also finished third in the NL MVP voting, following a season where he hit .331 and led the league with 55 doubles.

Career Statistics and Consistency

Reggie Sanders: Consistent Power and Speed

Sanders played for eight different teams during his 17-year career, accumulating a .267 batting average, 305 home runs, and 983 RBIs. What sets Sanders apart is his rare combination of power and speed, evidenced by his 304 stolen bases. Sanders joined the exclusive 300-300 club, highlighting his ability to both hit home runs and steal bases effectively.

  • Batting Average: .267
  • Home Runs: 305
  • RBIs: 983
  • Stolen Bases: 304
  • OPS: .830
Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
199123CINNL940406800131109.200.200.275.475311110000/8
199224CINNL1164383856210426612361674898.270.356.462.81912717864012*87HRoY-4
199325CINNL138563496901361642083271051118.274.343.444.786109220105387*9/8H
199426CINNL10744740066105208176221941114.263.332.480.81211019222131*9/H
199527CINNL133567484911483662899361269122.306.397.579.97515528098064*98/HAS,MVP-6
199628CINNL81334287497217114332484486.251.353.463.817114133820149/H
199729CINNL86358312527919219561374293.253.347.510.857120159931039/H
199830CINNL13554548183129186145920951137.268.346.418.76499201107422*89H
199931SDPNL133550478921362472672361365108.285.376.527.904134252106011*798/HD
200032ATLNL103377340437923111372143278.232.302.403.705761379230279H/8
200133ARINL126496441841162133390141046126.263.337.549.88611724225137*9/H
200234SFGNL14057150575126236238518647121.250.324.455.7791072301012073*9/H
200335PITNL13049845374129274318715538110.285.345.567.913131257105024*97H/D
200436STLNL13548744664116273226721533118.260.315.482.79710321554135*97H/D
200537STLNL93329295498014221541412875.271.340.546.886127161840217H/D9
200638KCRAL8835832545802311149772886.246.304.425.729861381010439D/H
200739KCRAL248573122370211011115.315.412.493.9051383621000/79DH
17 Yrs17777043624110371666341603059833041156741614.267.343.487.830115304212171144349
162 Game Avg.162642569951523152890281061147.267.343.487.830115277116144
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
CIN (8 yrs)805329228854997811523312543115863346777.271.353.476.8291181374553192123
KCR (2 yrs)1124433985710330113607839101.259.325.437.76295174122043
STL (2 yrs)2288167411131964154312135661193.265.325.507.833113376138156
ARI (1 yr)126496441841162133390141046126.263.337.549.88611724225137
PIT (1 yr)13049845374129274318715538110.285.345.567.913131257105024
SFG (1 yr)14057150575126236238518647121.250.324.455.7791072301012073
ATL (1 yr)103377340437923111372143278.232.302.403.7057613792302
SDP (1 yr)133550478921362472672361365108.285.376.527.904134252106011
NL (15 yrs)1665660058439801563311592929232971076351513.267.344.491.835116286810969143946
AL (2 yrs)1124433985710330113607839101.259.325.437.76295174122043
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 6/3/2024.

Lance Berkman: The Switch-Hitting Dynamo

Berkman spent 15 seasons in the MLB, primarily with the Houston Astros, and finished with a .293 batting average, 366 home runs, and 1,234 RBIs. Known for his ability to get on base, Berkman posted an impressive .406 OBP and .537 slugging percentage. His consistency as a switch-hitter made him a formidable presence, and his career OPS of .943 places him among the all-time greats.

  • Batting Average: .293
  • Home Runs: 366
  • RBIs: 1,234
  • OPS: .943
Standard Batting
Year Age Tm Lg G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
199923HOUNL3410693102220415511221.237.321.387.7087936200107H/93
200024HOUNL114417353761052812167625673.297.388.561.9491301986107197H/3RoY-6
200125HOUNL156688577110191555341267992121.331.430.6201.051161358813065*78/9HAS,MVP-5
200226HOUNL1586925781061693524212884107118.292.405.578.9821503341040320*879/HAS,MVP-3
200327HOUNL153658538110155356259353107108.288.412.515.9271382771091313*7/8
200428HOUNL1606875441041724033010697127101.316.450.5661.01616030810100614*97/38HAS,MVP-7
200529HOUNL132565468761373412482419172.293.411.524.9341432451840212379/DMVP-14
200630HOUNL15264653695169290451363298106.315.420.6211.0411633331140822*39/7HDAS,MVP-3
200731HOUNL15366856195156242341027394125.278.386.510.8961302861180511*39/H8D
200832HOUNL1596655541141734642910618499108.312.420.567.9861603141370518*3/DHAS,MVP-5
200933HOUNL136563460731263112580749798.274.399.509.9071402341310414*3/H
201034TOTMLB122481404481002311458327785.248.368.413.7811121671800073D/H
201034HOUNL8535829839731611349326070.245.372.436.8081201301200043
201034NYYAL371231069277019001715.255.358.349.707903760003D/H3
201135STLNL145587488901472323194269293.301.412.547.959164267730417*937/HDAS,MVP-7
201236STLNL32978112217127201419.259.381.444.82612636320033H
201337TEXAL732942562762101634003852.242.340.359.700929270003D/3H
15 Yrs18797814649111461905422303661234864812011300.293.406.537.943144348514766154160
162 Game Avg.162674560991643633210674104112.293.406.537.9431443001360514
G PA AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB CS BB SO BA OBP SLG OPS OPS+ TB GDP HBP SH SF IBB Pos Awards
HOU (12 yrs)15926713556010081648375263261090824210401121.296.410.549.959146305312461150134
STL (2 yrs)1776845691021683033310146106112.295.408.533.9401593031050420
TEX (1 yr)732942562762101634003852.242.340.359.700929270003
NYY (1 yr)371231069277019001715.255.358.349.707903760003
NL (14 yrs)17697397612911101816405293591191864811461233.296.409.548.957147335613466154154
AL (2 yrs)1104173623689171743005567.246.345.356.70292129130006
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Original Table
Generated 6/3/2024.

Impact on the Game

Reggie Sanders: The Reliable Contributor

Sanders’ career is a testament to his adaptability and reliability. His ability to perform consistently across multiple teams made him a valuable journeyman. Sanders’ presence was often a stabilizing force, particularly during playoff runs. His role in the Arizona Diamondbacks’ 2001 World Series championship is a prime example of his impact, as he provided key hits and veteran leadership throughout the series.

Lance Berkman: The Clutch Performer

Berkman’s impact on the game was profound, particularly during his time with the Houston Astros and St. Louis Cardinals. Known for his clutch performances, Berkman played a pivotal role in the Cardinals’ 2011 World Series victory. His game-tying single in the bottom of the 10th inning of Game 6 is a moment etched in baseball history. Berkman’s ability to perform under pressure made him a feared hitter in crucial situations.

Memorable Moments

Reggie Sanders: The Record Setter

One of Sanders’ most memorable moments came on August 20, 2003, when he hit two home runs in a single inning for the Pittsburgh Pirates against the St. Louis Cardinals. This rare feat underscored Sanders’ power-hitting capability. Additionally, his record-setting 10 RBIs in the 2005 National League Division Series against the San Diego Padres showcased his ability to shine in high-stakes games.

Lance Berkman: The World Series Hero

Berkman’s career is filled with memorable moments, but his performance in Game 6 of the 2011 World Series stands out. With the Cardinals down to their final strike, Berkman delivered a clutch single to tie the game, eventually leading to a Cardinals victory and a subsequent World Series title. This moment exemplified Berkman’s knack for delivering in pressure situations, cementing his legacy as a clutch performer.

Awards and Accolades

Reggie Sanders: A Decorated Career

  • All-Star (1995): Sanders’ lone All-Star appearance came during his breakout season.
  • World Series Champion (2001): A key member of the Arizona Diamondbacks’ championship team.
  • 300-300 Club: Sanders became the fifth player in MLB history to hit 300 home runs and steal 300 bases.

Lance Berkman: The All-Star Powerhouse

  • 6× All-Star (2001, 2002, 2004, 2006, 2008, 2011): Consistently selected among the league’s best.
  • World Series Champion (2011): Pivotal in leading the Cardinals to victory.
  • NL Comeback Player of the Year (2011): Recognized for his remarkable return to form.
  • NL RBI Leader (2002): Led the league with 128 RBIs.
  • Houston Astros Hall of Fame: Honored as one of the franchise’s all-time greats.

Postseason Performances

Reggie Sanders: Mixed Postseason Success

In 64 postseason games, Sanders batted .195 with seven home runs and 25 RBIs. While his postseason batting average was lower than his regular-season performance, Sanders had several key moments, particularly his record-setting 10 RBIs in the 2005 NLDS. His ability to contribute in critical moments helped his teams in multiple playoff runs.

Lance Berkman: The Postseason Standout

Berkman thrived in the postseason, batting .317 in 52 playoff games with nine home runs and 41 RBIs. His performance in the 2011 World Series, particularly Game 6, stands out as a highlight in his career. Berkman’s ability to deliver in clutch situations made him a valuable asset in the playoffs, further solidifying his reputation as a clutch performer.

Legacy and Post-Retirement

Reggie Sanders: The Giving Veteran

Sanders’ legacy is one of versatility and resilience. His ability to adapt and perform for multiple teams over a long career is noteworthy. Since retiring, Sanders has been involved in various charitable efforts, including his Reggie Sanders Foundation, which supports children with autism and their families, demonstrating his commitment to giving back to the community.

Lance Berkman: The Coach and Mentor

Berkman’s legacy is firmly entrenched in baseball history, not just for his on-field performance but also for his off-field contributions. After retiring, Berkman transitioned into a coaching role, sharing his knowledge and experience with younger players. His time as the head baseball coach at Houston Christian University and his involvement in various charitable endeavors highlight his continued passion for the game and his desire to mentor the next generation of players.

Conclusion

Comparing the careers of Reggie Sanders and Lance Berkman offers a fascinating look at two different paths to baseball greatness. Sanders’ career was defined by his power-speed combination and his ability to adapt to different teams and situations. In contrast, Berkman’s career was marked by his consistent power hitting and clutch performances, particularly in the postseason.

Both players left a significant mark on the game of baseball, providing countless memorable moments for fans. Whether you’re drawn to Sanders’ journeyman spirit or Berkman’s clutch heroics, there’s no denying the impact these two players had on the sport.