Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jake Cain
1891: Cap Anson’s Costume Delights Chicago
In Chicago, the comedic side of baseball shone bright when Cap Anson hit the field in an amusing get-up. The Chicago legend, usually known for his serious gameplay and batting prowess, surprised the crowd with false whiskers and a wig. Fans roared with laughter, their spirits lifted as they watched Anson play the entire game against Boston in his unconventional attire. That day, the costume became as memorable as Chicago’s victory, a quirky slice of baseball history cherished by fans.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
1899: Brooklyn’s Dual Finishes
The Brooklyn Superbas had a knack for pulling off late-game heroics, and on the fourth of September 1899, they made a memorable statement with two comeback wins on the same day. They clinched a victory on their home turf, followed by triumphing in Manhattan, which underscored their resilience and capability for turning games around in the closing stages.
Their dual successes are still etched in baseball folklore, especially due to the rarity of securing back-to-back wins in different boroughs on the same day. The Superbas’ display on that day demonstrates that the spirit of baseball is as much about never-say-die attitude as it is about homeruns and strikeouts.
1908: Pirates-Cubs Controversy
In 1908, during a tension-filled game that extended into extra innings, a base-running call became a hot topic. The Cubs challenged a run by the Pirates over a base-running rule, insisting it was a violation. Despite their protest, the umpire let the run stand, a decision which echoed in future games, emphasizing the importance of strict rule adherence.
The incident highlighted the significance of clear rules and their enforcement in baseball, setting a bar for future disputes. This ruling illustrated that even a single play could lead to broader implications for the sport, reminding players and fans alike that sometimes, games aren’t just decided by hits and runs, but by sharp eyes on the rules as well.
1916: Mathewson Vs. Brown Career Finale
In a final showdown that stoked the embers of a legendary rivalry, Christy Mathewson and Mordecai “Three-Finger” Brown took to the mound one last time. It was the swan song for both aces, and in this storied contest, it was Mathewson’s team that came out on top. Fans of the game still chat about the match-up with a touch of reverence, celebrating the two pitchers who defined an era with their unmatched skill and strategy. These titans of the game left their mark not just for their exceptional careers but for one of baseball’s most memorable final duels.
1928: Braves’ Doubleheader Marathon
The 1928 Boston Braves endured what can only be described as a baseball gauntlet. From September 4th, they played an astounding nine back-to-back doubleheaders. With eighteen games crammed into consecutive days, the Braves didn’t just play baseball; they practically lived at the ballpark! It’s a stretch that would have fans clutching their peanuts and Cracker Jacks in disbelief.
For those keeping score, that’s pushing the limits of stamina for any team, let alone during an era without today’s rest and recovery resources. Imagine the pitchers’ arms and batters weary from swinging, day in, day out. Rarely does the modern game see such a grueling test of endurance, making the Braves’ feat a standout historical moment.
As baseball aficionados, we tip our caps to this marathon of games that today’s schedule maker wouldn’t dream of. These Braves players became the iron men of their time, setting a record that’s hard to even think about challenging in today’s game.
1941: Yankees’ Earliest Pennant Win
On September 4, 1941, the New York Yankees clinched their third consecutive pennant, marking the soonest in the season a team had accomplished such a feat. The Yankees were a powerhouse that year, steamrolling the competition with a blend of stellar hitting and pitching. This early win underscored the sheer might they brought to the diamond, hardly giving their rivals a chance to catch a breath. Their achievement wasn’t just a flash in the pan, either; they went on to make their mark in October, showcasing the same dominance in the postseason.
1966: Dodgers’ Record Attendance
In 1966, the Los Angeles Dodgers achieved a seismic feat in baseball allure by drawing over 2 million fans to their games both at home and on the road. This milestone spotlighted their far-reaching appeal across the country. They weren’t just a local favorite, but a national sensation, capturing the hearts of baseball enthusiasts everywhere. Picture the energy in the stands, a sea of Dodger blue, the air thick with cheers, a testament to their magnetic draw.
1969: Willie Davis’ Streak Ends
On a September evening, the astounding 31-game hitting streak of Willie Davis came to an unceremonious halt. Davis, a Dodger through and through, found himself finally bested at the plate after a riveting run that captivated fans. Climbing to the top as one of the longest streaks in the history of the National League, he couldn’t find his mark against the San Diego Padres’ pitching. The streak, a show of sheer consistency and skill, is still reminisced by baseball aficionados, a testament to Davis’ prowess with the bat.
1974: No-Hit Bid Broken Up
In the heat of the ’74 season, Don Wilson was on fire. For eight innings, the Astros’ pitcher was untouchable, crafting a no-hit game that had fans teetering on the edge of their seats. But baseball can be a fickle friend, and in a choice that left many scratching their heads, Wilson was pulled out of the game. His successor stepped onto the mound, but the magic was gone—boom, the very first batter he faced landed a hit, and just like that, the no-hitter was history.
1985: Carter’s Home Run Feat
On September 4, 1985, Gary Carter achieved a remarkable feat in baseball by hitting his fourth and fifth home runs in a span of just two games. This power display tied the Major League record for home runs over two consecutive games. In doing so, Carter showcased the kind of slugging ability that made him a force to be reckoned with on the diamond. His performance echoes in baseball lore, a testament to his extraordinary hitting talent that fans still reminisce about today.
1993: Jim Abbott’s No-Hitter
On September 4, 1993, Jim Abbott, a one-handed pitcher for the New York Yankees, achieved an extraordinary feat by throwing a no-hitter against the Cleveland Indians. His stunning performance at Yankee Stadium rendered the ballpark electrified, as fans witnessed what many thought was near impossible. The achievement was not only a milestone in Abbott’s career but also an inspirational highlight in baseball history, proving that physical limitations do not define an athlete’s potential. To baseball enthusiasts, Abbott’s no-hitter is a testament to sheer determination and skill, making it a source of motivation and a story shared time and again.
1995: Ventura’s Grand Slam Duo
On September 4, 1995, Robin Ventura did something that most hitters only dream about: he smashed two grand slams in a single game. The Chicago White Sox third baseman became a sensation overnight, as the White Sox trounced the Texas Rangers with a score of 14-3. Fans were buzzing not just about the win, but how Ventura sent the ball flying with the bases loaded—twice. It’s a feat that’s rare enough to make any baseball trivia night, and it’s a testament to how Ventura left his mark as a slugger in the big leagues.
1998: Yankees’ Swift 100 Wins
On September 4, 1998, The New York Yankees raced to an astonishing milestone, securing their 100th victory of the season quicker than any other team in baseball history. That year, they charged through the American League with a dominance rarely seen, finishing with a record of 114-48, which still resonates with fans today.
Their roster, full of talent, worked like a well-oiled machine, with each player contributing to the team’s overwhelming success. This accomplishment is a testament to the powerhouse that was the ’98 Yankees, and a memorable moment for aficionados of America’s pastime who appreciate a team playing the game at its highest level.
Today’s Baseball Birthdays
September 4th marks the birthday of some remarkable players that made significant impacts in the major leagues.
1968: Mike Piazza
- Mike Piazza, often remembered for his powerful swing, celebrates his birthday today. He’s a 12-time All-Star who hit an impressive 427 home runs in his career, mostly as a catcher.
1950: Frank White
- On this day, we also tip our caps to Frank White. This eight-time Gold Glover and five-time All-Star was known for his slick fielding at second base for the Kansas City Royals.
1941: Ken Harrelson
- “The Hawk” Ken Harrelson, born today, made his mark with his flamboyant announcing style, but let’s not forget his 1968 AL RBI title. Harrelson was also known for his distinctive batting stance and powerful hitting during his playing days.
1950: Doyle Alexander
- Celebrating his birthday as well is Doyle Alexander, a crafty pitcher who, during the 1987 pennant race, was traded for future Hall of Famer John Smoltz. With a career spanning 19 years, Alexander’s cunning on the mound was always a sight.