Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
From Ebbets Field to Chavez Ravine, the Dodgers franchise has seen its share of immortals make it to Cooperstown. But some of its most beloved heroes—the ones who made Brooklyn dance and Los Angeles dream—are still waiting for their call. These are the players who defined what it meant to be a Dodger, Hall of Fame plaque or not.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Fernando Valenzuela: The Man Who Made Los Angeles Believe
Before “Fernandomania” swept through Los Angeles, Chavez Ravine was just another baseball stadium. Then came the pudgy 20-year-old from Sonora with the skyward glance and screwball that defied physics. Fernando Valenzuela didn’t just pitch—he united a city, turned every start into a festival, and proved that baseball dreams know no borders.
Maury Wills: The Man Who Stole Baseball’s Speed Record
Before Maury Wills, 50 stolen bases was considered a spectacular season. Then in 1962, he swiped 104 bases, shattered Ty Cobb’s record, and changed baseball forever. Those who watched him at Dodger Stadium still swear they could hear his spikes scratching the dirt before the pitcher even began his windup. He didn’t just steal bases—he stole the show every night.
Tommy John: The Surgery That Changed Baseball Forever
They named a surgery after him, but Tommy John was more than just medical history. After Dr. Frank Jobe’s revolutionary procedure in 1974, John won 164 more games—more than most pitchers win in their entire careers. His comeback didn’t just save his career; it gave hope to generations of pitchers who followed.
Ron Cey: The Penguin Who Waddled Into Dodger History
Tommy Lasorda dubbed him “The Penguin” for his distinctive waddle, but Ron Cey’s bat was pure power. For a decade, he anchored the longest-running infield in baseball history, turning the hot corner at Dodger Stadium into his kingdom. Six All-Star appearances and that unforgettable 1981 World Series co-MVP proved this Penguin could soar.
Orel Hershiser: The Bulldog Who Broke Records
Fifty-nine scoreless innings in 1988—a record that still stands and may never be broken. Tommy Lasorda dubbed him “Bulldog,” though Hershiser’s choir-boy looks suggested anything but. That magical ’88 season, capped with World Series MVP honors, wasn’t just dominance; it was artistry, proving that nice guys don’t always finish last.
Steve Garvey: Mr. Clean’s Quest for Cooperstown
The numbers still sparkle like his perfectly pressed uniform: 1,207 consecutive games played, a National League record that stood for decades. Steve Garvey was more than just statistics though—he was Hollywood’s idea of what a baseball player should be, complete with forearms that belonged in a Marvel comic and a smile that lit up Dodger Stadium. In an era of disco and discord, Mr. Clean represented something timeless about the game.
Pedro Guerrero: The Best Bat Nobody Remembers
Branch Rickey once said baseball is a game of inches, but Pedro Guerrero dealt in feet—as in how far he could blast a baseball. His 1985 season was the stuff of legend: 33 homers and a .320 average while playing three different positions. In the words of his manager Tommy Lasorda, “He could fall out of bed on Christmas morning and hit a line drive.”
Mike Marshall: The Doctor Who Revolutionized Relief Pitching
In 1974, Dr. Mike Marshall—yes, he had a Ph.D. in kinesiology—appeared in 106 games, a record that still stands and probably always will. He didn’t just pitch; he revolutionized the art of relief pitching, using his scientific background to challenge every conventional wisdom about arm care. That Cy Young Award season changed how baseball viewed the bullpen forever.
Jim Gilliam: Junior’s Legacy Lives Beyond the Numbers
From Brooklyn to Los Angeles, “Junior” Gilliam was the Dodgers’ quiet cornerstone for 14 seasons. His number 19 was the first retired by the team for a non-Hall of Famer, speaking volumes about his impact beyond statistics. A switch-hitter who could play anywhere on the diamond, Gilliam embodied the Dodger way before anyone knew what that meant.
Reggie Smith: The Switch-Hitting Star of the ’70s
Before switch-hitting became commonplace, Reggie Smith was launching bombs from both sides of the plate at Dodger Stadium. His 1977-78 seasons were pure poetry: back-to-back 30-homer campaigns when that meant something, especially in the pitcher-friendly confines of Chavez Ravine. In an era of colorful characters, Smith let his bat do the talking.
Jeff Kent: The Greatest Power-Hitting Second Baseman Ever
Before second basemen were supposed to hit for power, Jeff Kent was crushing expectations along with baseballs. His Dodger years might have come late in his career, but that trademark intensity never wavered. Those 351 career homers as a second baseman set a record that even modern launch-angle devotees haven’t touched.
Willie Davis: Three Gold Gloves and a Cloud of Dust
They called him “3-Dog” for his uniform number, but Willie Davis moved more like a gazelle. His 31-game hitting streak in 1969 still stands as a Dodgers record, but it was his graceful gliding in center field that made jaws drop at Dodger Stadium. In an era before artificial turf, Davis turned the outfield grass into his personal dance floor.
Carl Furillo: The Reading Rifle Who Never Missed
Before laser guns measured outfield throws, Carl Furillo’s arm was baseball’s most precise weapon. The “Reading Rifle” mastered Ebbets Field’s notorious right field wall and turned would-be doubles into embarrassing singles. His .299 career average proved he was more than just a defensive specialist, but it was that legendary arm that made Brooklyn fans believe in magic.
Shawn Green: The Slugger Who Made History on a Thursday
On one magical Thursday in Milwaukee, Shawn Green did something no player had ever done: 6-for-6 with four home runs and 19 total bases. His Dodger tenure produced impressive numbers: 49 homers in 2001, a .297 average over five seasons, and defense smooth enough to make right field look easy. In an era when power hitters were under scrutiny, Green’s quiet excellence and dignity made him the perfect Dodger.
Bill Russell: The Quiet Captain of the Infield
For 18 seasons, Bill Russell was the steady hand in a legendary infield that stayed together longer than most marriages. His 2,181 games in Dodger blue are the most ever by a Los Angeles Dodger. While Garvey got the magazine covers and Cey got the nicknames, Russell quietly turned the shortstop position into his personal art form.
Ron Perranoski: The Original Bullpen Ace
Before closers became one-inning specialists, Ron Perranoski wrote the blueprint for relief pitching. His rubber arm and devastating slider helped secure two World Series titles, including a magnificent 1963 season where he appeared in 69 games. In the days before save statistics were official, Perry was saving more than just games—he was saving tired arms and managing’s reputations.
Johnny Podres: The Boy Who Beat the Yankees
Before the miracle of 1955, Brooklyn was where baseball dreams went to die. Then 23-year-old Johnny Podres pitched the game of his life in Game 7, bringing the only World Series title to Brooklyn. His changeup might not have been enough for Cooperstown, but in Brooklyn, Podres will forever be the man who slayed the Yankees.
Don Newcombe: More Than Just Jackie’s Teammate
In 1956, Don Newcombe became the first player to win both Cy Young and MVP awards in the same season. “Newk” was more than just a pioneer—he was arguably baseball’s first true power pitcher, whose 27-7 record that season stands among the greatest pitching performances ever. His legacy extends beyond the diamond as one of the key figures who helped integrate baseball.
Dusty Baker: The Manager Who Was An Even Better Player
Before he became one of baseball’s most respected managers, Dusty Baker was launching bombs into the Dodger Stadium pavilions. His 1976-83 run in Dodger Blue produced two All-Star appearances and a Gold Glove, but numbers don’t capture his impact. Baker helped pioneer the high-five with Glenn Burke and brought a cool factor to baseball that endures to this day.
Charlie Neal: The Second Baseman Who Owned the ’59 Series
When the Dodgers needed a hero in their first Los Angeles World Series, Charlie Neal stepped up with three home runs against the White Sox. His slick fielding and clutch hitting made him the bridge between Jackie Robinson and Jim Gilliam at second base. In that magical ’59 season, Neal proved that the Dodgers’ winning tradition had successfully made the journey west.