Last Updated: October 20th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
There are so many things that make baseball managers unique to the sport. So much focus can be put on them when it's a sport where batters will fail way more than half the time, and pitchers are out there to limit damage more than prevent it.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
We've got a list of managers who were able to carve out long, even legendary careers, but success was fleeting compared to their reputations.
11. John McNamara
With all of the discourse around the Boston Red Sox and the Curse of the Bambino in the 20th century, John McNamara was a big part of it. He was probably the closest to breaking the curse before the historic 2004 season.
However, in Game 6 of the 1986 World Series, he decided to leave Bill Buckner in at first base when they had a better defensive option on the bench. The rest, as you know, is history.
10. Buck Showalter
Buck Showalter might be the most well-known manager who has never won a World Series championship. He is a four-time Manager of the Year, leading teams to the brink of greatness, but ultimately getting let go right before they realize their potential.
Many forget that he was the manager of the Yankees who was fired in order for Joe Torre to take the helm and lead them to greatness.
9. Dusty Baker
There may be no other manager whom I was happier to watch win a championship than Dusty Baker in 2022. For so long, he was a highly respected manager, but he was never able to complete the climb to the mountaintop.
Yes, he managed a team that had Barry Bonds to the World Series, but couldn't get the very last out. It's why some critics questioned the Astros even hiring him in the first place, but he silenced them.
8. Gene Mauch
No other manager has tallied more wins in their career without winning a World Series than Gene Mauch. He was always respected as a tactician and a decision-maker, but he couldn't press the right buttons to win the ultimate prize.
Over 26 years with some great teams, he couldn't even win a pennant, meaning that he also holds the record for most wins without even reaching the World Series.
7. Don Baylor
Sometimes managers get lucky with some great teams. I think there was a sense that Don Baylor had a great team that could possibly win it all in 1995. He was named the National League's Manager of the Year for leading an exciting Colorado Rockies squad.
They wouldn't be able to get past teams like the Atlanta Braves, and a great roster was squandered.
6. Buck Martinez
As part of the media, I have a great deal of respect for broadcasters. When one is in the booth for so long, it's almost accepted that they know enough to be a great manager.
Unfortunately for Buck Martinez, the expertise he voiced on the mic didn't translate to wins in the dugout, as he didn't last two seasons as the manager of the Toronto Blue Jays and moved back up to the broadcast booth afterward.
5. Rene Lachemann
Rene Lachemann was a highly regarded coach throughout his career. He was a part of Tony La Russa's staff in Oakland when they won a World Series title in 1989. Eventually, he was tabbed to be the first manager in the history of the Marlins franchise.
He weathered the ups and downs of a young organization, but ultimately got let go a season before they won their first championship.
4. Danny Ozark
It is so challenging to win a World Series championship. Even teams with multiple Hall of Famers can struggle to reach the promised land. Danny Ozark was managing the likes of Mike Schmidt, Steve Carlton, and Pete Rose, but couldn't seem to get over the hump to win the Commissioner's Trophy.
A year after he was fired, the Phillies were finally able to win a World Series title in 1980.
3. Bill Virdon
For 13 seasons, Bill Virdon was mostly a winning manager. He maintained a very good .519 win-loss percentage with multiple division wins. The conservative approach he used during the regular season wasn't exactly great for the postseason.
He wasn't able to lead a team to the World Series across four organizations: the Pirates, Yankees, Astros, and Expos.
2. Mayo Smith
This entry investigates a reputation for greatness that just plummeted quickly. Mayo Smith arrived in Detroit in 1967 and immediately started winning. It only took another year for them to win the World Series, and it seemed like the future was bright.
However, in 1970, they suffered a losing season, and the fanbase turned on the dugout leader.
Smith was ousted after only one losing season, clearly not being seen as a big reason for them winning a championship just two years prior.
1. Eddie Stanky
Eddie Stanky was a highly regarded three-time All-Star as a player. By the end of his career, the St. Louis Cardinals wanted him to be both a player and a manager for the team. Stanky accepted and led them to some pretty good seasons.
But those were short-lived, as his leadership started to falter and rough years came for the Cardinals. They let him go, and he would eventually have a similar success-to-failure experience with the Chicago White Sox.
