Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Jeffrey Christo
Before Twitter and Instagram, America gathered around transistor radios and black-and-white TVs to follow baseball’s greatest showdowns. These home run chases weren’t just about numbers—they were summer-long dramas that united cities, defined generations, and gave us heroes to believe in. Let’s revisit the slugging duels that made us stay up late to catch the West Coast scores.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
1961: Maris vs. Mantle – When the Asterisk Was Born
The M&M Boys’ chase of Ruth’s sacred 60 split Yankees fans and baseball purists alike. While Mantle battled injuries and abscess, the quiet Maris endured death threats and hair loss from stress. Commissioner Ford Frick’s infamous asterisk decision turned what should have been baseball’s greatest achievement into a bittersweet footnote that took decades to correct.
1998: McGwire vs. Sosa – The Summer That Saved Baseball
Before we knew what we know now, there was magic in every at-bat. McGwire’s 70 and Sosa’s 66 home runs came with curtain calls, home run trots, and Sammy’s hop. The country watched as two sluggers chased history, their friendly rivalry healing baseball’s wounds from the ’94 strike with every mammoth blast.
1932: Babe Ruth vs. Jimmie Foxx – The Original Slugger’s Duel
Double X versus the Bambino—baseball’s first true home run race. Foxx’s 58 homers challenged Ruth’s supremacy, with the Babe finishing at 41 but still commanding every headline. Their battles at Fenway and Yankee Stadium drew crowds that spilled onto the field, with fans standing in the outfield behind ropes.
2001: Bonds Chases McGwire – 73 and the Storm That Followed
Barry Bonds turned baseball into his personal video game, launching 73 home runs into McCovey Cove and beyond. Every plate appearance became must-see TV, with pitchers either walking him or watching their mistakes sail into the night. The record stands, but the controversy never faded.
1927: Ruth’s 60 – Racing Against Himself and History
The Babe’s greatest season came when he was essentially competing against himself. His 60th homer off Tom Zachary created the sport’s most magical number, one that would stand for 34 years. Newspapers tracked every at-bat, with Western Union telegrams spreading the news of each mighty blast.
1969: McCovey vs. Aaron – The NL’s Great Power Show
Stretch McCovey’s 45 homers edged out Hank Aaron’s 44 in a race between two of the game’s most respected sluggers. Their duel represented old-school baseball at its finest—two legendary hitters launching bombs while maintaining a quiet dignity that defined the era.
1990: Fielder vs. McGriff – The Last Clean Home Run Chase
Cecil Fielder’s 51 homers—after returning from Japan—ran away at the end compared to the Crime Dog’s 35 in what many consider baseball’s last innocent power chase. Big Daddy’s moonshots at Tiger Stadium became legendary, while McGriff’s sweet swing kept the race close into September.
1977: Foster vs. Schmidt – When 50+ Meant Something
George Foster’s 52 homers for the Big Red Machine marked the only 50-homer season between 1965 and 1990. His battle with Schmidt (38 HR) represented power hitting in its purest form, before weight rooms and supplements changed the game forever.
1937: Gehrig vs. Greenberg – Titans of the Depression Era
As America struggled through the Depression, Gehrig and Greenberg gave fans something to cheer about. Hammerin’ Hank’s 40 homers topped the Iron Horse’s 37, but more importantly, their chase provided hope and entertainment when the country needed it most.
1994: Williams, Griffey, and The Strike That Stopped History
When the strike hit, Matt Williams had 43 homers in 115 games, while Junior Griffey sat at 40. Both were on pace to challenge Maris’s 61, but baseball’s labor war left fans wondering what might have been. The unfinished race remains one of sport’s greatest “what-if” moments.