Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Matthew Brown
Before the slider became king and the four-seamer ruled supreme, there was a pitch that twisted arms and broke hearts with equal measure. The screwball—that backwards-spinning enigma that dove away from same-handed hitters—was once the secret weapon of baseball’s craftiest hurlers. From smoky ballparks where fans wore fedoras to the bright lights of championship stages, these twenty masters of the reverse curve left batters shaking their heads and fans reaching for their scorecards.
Don't lose this article. Enter your email below, and I'll send it to you right now. Plus, we'll send you other unbelievable stories from baseball's past.
Christy Mathewson’s “Fadeaway” – The Original Screwball That Fooled Ty Cobb
Before anyone called it a screwball, Christy Mathewson was mystifying deadball era hitters with his “fadeaway”—a pitch that seemed to defy the laws of physics as it broke away from right-handed batters. The gentleman pitcher’s signature offering was so compelling that even the great Ty Cobb admitted it gave him fits, watching helplessly as the ball seemed to vanish just as he swung. Mathewson’s fadeaway wasn’t just a pitch; it was poetry in motion, delivered with the grace and precision that made him baseball’s first true superstar.
Cy Blanton’s Depression-Era Screwball That Gave Pittsburgh Hope
When America was counting pennies and Pittsburgh was counting losses, Cy Blanton’s screwball gave Steel City fans something to cheer about in the depths of the Depression. The right-hander’s reverse-breaking pitch helped anchor a Pirates rotation that briefly made Forbes Field feel like a palace again. Blanton’s screwball danced through the strike zone like a silver dollar spinning in the air—precious, mesmerizing, and just out of reach for desperate hitters trying to make contact.
Carl Hubbell’s 1934 All-Star Strikeout Sequence That Still Gives Goosebumps
Five consecutive strikeouts of future Hall of Famers—Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx, Al Simmons, and Joe Cronin—all victims of Carl Hubbell’s devastating screwball in the 1934 All-Star Game. The Meal Ticket’s reverse curve was so unhittable that day at the Polo Grounds that even Ruth could only shake his head and trudge back to the dugout. Nearly a century later, baseball fans still get chills thinking about that magical sequence when one man’s screwball made legends look like Little Leaguers.
Harry “The Cat” Brecheen’s World Series Screwball Mastery
Harry “The Cat” Brecheen prowled the mound with feline grace, and his screwball was the claw that scratched out three World Series victories in 1946 for the Cardinals. The left-hander’s reverse-breaking pitch pounced on unsuspecting Red Sox hitters, helping St. Louis capture their third championship of the decade. Brecheen’s screwball didn’t just break—it stalked hitters like prey, waiting for the perfect moment to strike and leave them swinging at shadows.
Mel Parnell’s Fenway Screwball That Lefties Still Dream About
Mel Parnell’s screwball turned Fenway Park’s Green Monster from enemy to ally, as the southpaw’s reverse-breaking pitch made right-handed pull hitters look foolish trying to turn on balls that faded away from their wheelhouse. The Red Sox ace’s screwball was like a magician’s trick performed in broad daylight—everyone could see it coming, but nobody could solve it. Parnell’s mastery of the pitch made him the last lefty to win 20 games at Fenway until decades later, a testament to how devastating a perfectly executed screwball could be.
Warren Spahn’s Late-Career Screwball That Extended His Hall of Fame Run
When Father Time started catching up to Warren Spahn’s legendary fastball, the crafty southpaw turned to the screwball like an old gunfighter reaching for a hidden derringer. Spahn’s late-career mastery of the reverse-breaking pitch helped him pitch effectively well into his forties, adding another dimension to an already Hall of Fame repertoire. The screwball became Spahn’s fountain of youth, allowing him to continue befuddling hitters long after lesser pitchers had hung up their spikes.
Juan Marichal’s High-Kick Screwball That Danced Past Giants Fans’ Hearts
Juan Marichal’s screwball was the exclamation point on his artistic pitching display, delivered with that distinctive high leg kick that made Candlestick Park crowds hold their breath. The Dominican Dandy’s reverse-breaking pitch complemented his arsenal like a master painter’s final brushstroke, adding another layer of deception to an already mesmerizing repertoire. When Marichal unleashed his screwball from that sky-high delivery, it looked like a fastball until the last moment when it would dart away, leaving hitters grasping at San Francisco fog.
Mike Cuellar’s Cuban Screwball That Helped Baltimore Win It All
Mike Cuellar brought his Cuban screwball to Baltimore and helped turn the Orioles into a dynasty, with his reverse-breaking pitch serving as the perfect complement to the team’s powerful lineup. The crafty southpaw’s screwball was like a secret weapon smuggled from Havana, baffling American League hitters who had never seen anything quite like it. Cuellar’s screwball didn’t just win games—it won hearts in Baltimore, where fans appreciated the artistry of a pitcher who could make the ball dance to a Latin rhythm.
Tug McGraw’s Two-Championship Screwball That Conquered New York and Philly
Tug McGraw’s screwball was the pitch that bridged two championship runs, helping the Miracle Mets capture hearts in 1973 and delivering the Phillies their first World Series title in 1980. The reliever’s reverse-breaking pitch was as unpredictable as his personality, diving away from hitters with the same joyful chaos that made McGraw a fan favorite in two cities. When the game was on the line, McGraw’s screwball was the pitch that made believers out of skeptics and champions out of underdogs.
Mike Marshall’s Iron Man Screwball That Broke Relief Pitching Records
Mike Marshall’s screwball was built for endurance, the perfect pitch for a reliever who appeared in 106 games in 1974 and won the Cy Young Award doing it. The rubber-armed right-hander’s reverse-breaking pitch seemed to get stronger as games wore on, baffling tired hitters who thought they had figured out his patterns. Marshall’s screwball wasn’t just a pitch—it was a philosophy, proving that sometimes the most effective weapon is the one that goes against conventional wisdom.
Tom Browning’s Perfect Game Screwball That Silenced Riverfront
Tom Browning’s screwball was the secret ingredient in his perfect game recipe, keeping Dodgers hitters off balance throughout that magical September night in 1988 at Riverfront Stadium. The left-hander’s reverse-breaking pitch complemented his fastball and curveball perfectly, creating a three-pitch symphony that left Los Angeles batters conducting air. When Browning needed his biggest outs in baseball’s most pressure-packed moments, his screwball was there, breaking away from danger and toward immortality.
Willie Hernandez’s 1984 MVP Screwball That Delivered Detroit’s Title
Willie Hernandez’s screwball was the closing argument in Detroit’s 1984 championship case, with the Puerto Rican reliever’s reverse-breaking pitch sealing victory after victory for the wire-to-wire Tigers. His screwball didn’t just save games—it saved a city’s season, giving Motor City fans something to celebrate during tough economic times. When Hernandez wound up and delivered that screwball in the ninth inning, Tiger Stadium knew the game was over and another celebration was about to begin.
Teddy Higuera’s Milwaukee Screwball That Had Brewers Fans Believing
Teddy Higuera’s screwball turned County Stadium into a house of horrors for American League hitters, with the Mexican southpaw’s reverse-breaking pitch leading Milwaukee’s surprising surge in the mid-1980s. His screwball was like a curveball’s rebellious cousin, breaking the wrong way at just the right time to keep the Brewers competitive in a tough division. When Higuera’s screwball was working, Milwaukee fans could taste October, and opposing hitters could taste nothing but frustration.
Mike Norris’s Oakland Screwball That Made Billy Martin Smile
Mike Norris’s screwball was the pitch that briefly made the Oakland Athletics relevant again, with the right-hander’s reverse-breaking offering giving manager Billy Martin something to get excited about in the early 1980s. Norris’s screwball was like finding a twenty-dollar bill in an old jacket—unexpected, valuable, and capable of changing your whole day. When the lanky pitcher unleashed his screwball at the Oakland Coliseum, it reminded fans why they fell in love with baseball’s unpredictability in the first place.
John Franco’s Brooklyn-Born Screwball That Conquered Queens
John Franco’s screwball was pure New York attitude wrapped in cowhide, with the Brooklyn native’s reverse-breaking pitch becoming the signature of his long and successful career as the Mets’ closer. His screwball had the same tough-guy swagger as Franco himself, breaking away from hitters with the confidence of someone who grew up playing stickball in the streets. When Franco’s screwball was dancing through the strike zone at Shea Stadium, Mets fans knew they were watching one of their own make good on the biggest stage.
Jim Mecir’s Moneyball Screwball That Baffled Righties for a Decade
Jim Mecir’s screwball was like a magic trick, with the right-hander’s delivery making his reverse-breaking pitch nearly impossible to pick up for right-handed batters. His screwball didn’t just break—it seemed to teleport from one location to another, leaving hitters wondering if they had just witnessed actual sorcery. Mecir’s pitch movement made him a matchup nightmare for opposing managers and a fan favorite wherever he pitched.
Yu Darvish’s Modern Japanese Screwball Wizardry
Yu Darvish’s screwball represents the international evolution of the pitch, with the Japanese ace bringing his own unique spin to the reverse-breaking tradition. His screwball is like a high-tech update to a classic car—all the vintage charm with modern precision and reliability. When Darvish unleashes his screwball in today’s velocity-obsessed game, it serves as a reminder that sometimes the best way forward is to look backward to the crafty pitchers who came before.
Hector Santiago’s Modern Screwball Revival in the Analytics Era
Hector Santiago’s screwball is proof that old-school artistry can still find a place in baseball’s computer-driven modern era, with the left-hander’s reverse-breaking pitch providing a human touch in an increasingly automated game. His screwball cuts through launch angle data and exit velocity metrics like a knife through butter, reminding everyone that sometimes the most effective pitch is simply the one hitters don’t expect. Santiago’s screwball revival shows that in baseball, as in life, everything old eventually becomes new again.
Bobby Castillo’s Screwball School That Taught Fernando Everything
Bobby Castillo’s screwball was the gift that kept on giving, as the veteran reliever passed down the secrets of the reverse-breaking pitch to a young Fernando Valenzuela in the Dodgers’ bullpen. Castillo’s screwball was like a family recipe—carefully guarded, lovingly shared, and destined to become legendary in the right hands. While Castillo’s own career was solid, his true legacy lives on in every screwball Fernando threw, making him the unsung hero of one of baseball’s greatest success stories.
Fernando Valenzuela’s Screwball That Made Los Angeles Fall in Love
Fernando Valenzuela’s screwball was more than just a pitch—it was a cultural phenomenon that turned a shy kid from Mexico into the toast of Los Angeles and sparked Fernandomania across the baseball world. His screwball had the power to unite communities, bridge language barriers, and make believers out of skeptics, all while helping the Dodgers win games and capture hearts. When Fernando wound up and delivered that magical screwball, with his eyes rolling skyward in concentration, he wasn’t just throwing a baseball—he was throwing dreams, hope, and pure joy to anyone lucky enough to witness the magic.