Who Gets the Ball? All-Star Game Starting Aces, Manager’s Choice
Last Updated: June 17th, 2026 by Matthew BrownRemember when All-Star Game starting pitchers were chosen for more than just popularity contests? When managers picked their aces based on pure dominance, not fan voting or marketing appeal? These 20 legends earned the ultimate honor—taking the mound first in the Midsummer Classic, carrying the weight of league expectations on their shoulders. Lefty Gomez: The Yankee Comedian Who Started Five All-Star Games Gomez’s five All-Star starts from 1933-1938 …